Menachem Creditor

Joyfully answering the call

That moment when it made perfect sense for a despondent punk anarchist to drop by the synagogue

It is a Jewish tradition, on the first day of the month of Adar, to increase joy. (Mishnah Ta’anit)

Importantly, that is not the same as saying one is naturally happier on a specific day on the calendar. Moods seldom follow instructions, and time has a funny way of surprising even the expected. But a mindful dose of recommended joy is a big gift, no?

I’d like to share with you a story, a real experience that occurred today at my shul. A young man came to sit with me. I didn’t know him. He had left a message on the synagogue voicemail about feeling despondent about the current situation in America, and wanted to sit with a rabbi. When we sat together just today I learned that he was a punk rock musician, and an anarchist living in the neighborhood. More than that, deeper than that, he shared with me that he was deeply afraid, not only about threats to free speech, health care, the LGBTQ community, Muslims, Jews, immigrants, and others (each of which he named).

What scared him? He was afraid of his own response to a proposed Nazi march in town this week (not worth linking: it’s hateful garbage, and deserves repudiation, not amplification. We will address it by being a louder, prouder, publicly engaged Jewish community). He was afraid of his own rage and fear and hopelessness, not sure where to turn. So he looked for a synagogue, a safe place. He looked for a rabbi, someone to sit with and trust. It’s not that there were any “fixes” for the things that worried him. But, when we had spoken for a while, he looked at me and said something we all should hear and take to heart:

Thank you for being here. I’m so grateful this synagogue is here and open. I haven’t been to shul for many years. I feel a little less afraid now.

Friends, I’m sharing this with you because the thought that there is an “out there” and an “in here” when it comes to the work of a synagogue is a misperception. No, we can’t care for everyone everywhere. Yes, we  all struggle with budgets and staffing and volunteer energy and fundraising. Yes, a shul is always in the process of becoming, delineating between what some feel is urgent and others feel is important. Yes, all of this is (potential) blessing, pure and profound.

Yes: it is important that we see the work we do “inside” the shul as being in service with the world “out there.” How can we be communal healers if we don’t visit each other when we are ill? How can we effectively pursue a just society if we don’t build the strength of our shul? Where would that young man have turned if my community’s founders hadn’t built a shul?

There is much to do. Again, Jewish wisdom helps: Ours is not to complete the work. Our is to start. (Pirkei Avot) 

We should celebrate what we’ve built here, synagogues and JCCs and day schools and Jewish start-ups. And we should see the strength we continue to build as being in service of this fragile world we share. That kind of purpose is what some might even name “a calling.”

How blessed we are to answer that call.

About the Author
Rabbi Menachem Creditor serves as Scholar-in-Residence at UJA-Federation New York and is the founder of Rabbis Against Gun Violence. Rabbi Creditor has authored and edited over thirty books, including A Rabbi’s Heart, and After October 7: Essays. With millions of views of his daily Torah videos and essays, his leadership has helped shape national conversations on gun violence prevention, LGBTQ inclusion, Zionism, Interfaith organizing, and Jewish diversity. Rabbi Creditor’s music, including the well-known song Olam Chesed Yibaneh, is sung in communities around the world. He is a Senior Lecturer at the Academy for Jewish Religion and speaks widely about the role of faith in building a more compassionate world. He and his wife, Neshama Carlebach, live in New York, where they are raising their five children.
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.