Efrat, Israel – Why must Sukkot occur in such close proximity to Rosh Hashana and Yom Kippur? A fresh analysis of a famous dispute in the Talmud regarding precisely what it is that the sukka commemorates yields a fascinating answer to this question.

Rabbi Akiva [Tractate Sukka 11b] maintains that we are replicating the actual booths in which our ancestors dwelt during their desert wanderings, while Rabbi Eliezer believes that we are re-creating the miraculous “clouds of glory” which descended from the Almighty as an ethereal protective shield when they left Egypt.

Since our tradition records that the final judgment and absolution of God during this period of repentance is rendered on the seventh day of Sukkot (Hoshana Rabba), it is clear that the sukka is an intrinsic part of a process that began with Rosh Hashana. We may be waving the Four Species during the day and sleeping in the sukka at night, but the essence of this time period is repentance.

Hence, even when R. Eliezer and R. Akiva disagree as to the identity of the “booths” themselves, perhaps they are also distinguishing between two different aspects of the repentance process.

Indeed, the Holy Zohar speaks of two forms of repentance: a lower repentance (teshuva tata’a) which is for a specific transgression or group of transgressions, and a higher repentance (teshuva ila’a) which is an uplifting of the entire personality, a total ennobling of one’s direction in life. I would suggest that R. Akiva’s sukka, reminiscent of the flimsy desert structures, is linked to the lower form of repentance, and R. Eliezer’s “clouds of glory” sukka is linked to the higher form of repentance. Ultimately, we need both of them!

Maimonides, in fact, supports this hypothesis in his Laws of Repentance. Initially, he describes the penitent as having to experience a humbling process: “The path of repentance is for the penitent to cry out constantly before God with tears and beseeching. He gives charity according to his ability, distancing himself from what he did, and he changes his name as if to say that he is not the same person who committed these transgressions, transforming his deeds into righteous deeds. He exiles himself from his place, because exile serves as forgiveness for sin in that it causes a person to become more subdued, humble and subservient.” [Hilchot Teshuva 2:4]

Here we see an implicit connection between the last step in the repentance process and the sukka. Since no one understands the humbling experience better than a person who has fallen so low that he must leave his accustomed abode and no longer has a permanent roof over his head, the sukka becomes in actuality the final step in Maimonides’ vision of repentance. And the entire desert experience, with the Israelite wanderings from place to place, has served as the historical paradigm of Jewish exile, according to most biblical interpretations, with the sukka standing out as the ultimate personalized symbol of this exile.

Yet, several chapters ahead, Maimonides codifies a different kind of repentance, a state of perfection that places the penitent close to the Divine Presence: “Repentance is on the highest level because it brings a person close to the Divine Presence. Yesterday he was hated by God and alienated and abominable. But today he is beloved, delightful, close, a beloved friend.” [Ibid, 7:6-7]

A friend of God! The highest achievement of repentance. What do friends do? One way to express delight and closeness with a beloved friend is to invite him into your home. And in a sense, this is what happens on Sukkot.

During Yom Kippur, we were all in the presence of God (lifnei Hashem) like angels in heaven. But on Sukkot, which arrives just days afterward, our presence before God is extended by His making our home and His home the very same home. All through the months of Elul and Tishrei, we add the 27th Psalm to the prayer service, which includes the following verse: One thing have I desired of the Lord …that I may dwell in the house of the Lord all the days of my life…” [Ps. 27:1]

Finally, on Sukkot our desires are answered. In effect, God is the bridegroom, and we, the Jewish people, are the bride called upon to enter the bridegroom’s home. The seven days we sit inside the sukka correspond to the seven days that a marriage is celebrated. Since no ‘Sheva Brachot’ is complete without new faces at each of the seven festive meals, we also invite into our sukka new faces for the duration of the seven days: Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Moses, Aaron, Joseph and David, and the custom is called ushpizin.

Perhaps we must first seek forgiveness for our individual transgressions and lovingly accept the exile of the sukka of R. Akiva before we can enter the marriage chamber of the glorious sukka of R. Eliezer. How fortunate are we that the one naturally turns into the other as we reach upwards in our relationship to the Divine.