Breaking the Silence abroad: A statement by Our Soldiers Speak and Ron Ben-Yishai

Dear Friends,

In recent days, focus within Israel has intensified upon the overseas activities of the organization Breaking the Silence; a group comprised of former members of the Israel Defense Forces.

Breaking the Silence actively disseminates often unsubstantiated allegations against the I.D.F. throughout campuses and communities abroad while consistently refusing to cooperate with the investigative channels open to examining their claims within the State of Israel.

As such, we at Our Soldiers Speak have worked closely with leading Israeli journalist Ron Ben-Yishai, a decorated I.D.F. veteran and exemplar of free and open discussion, to provide the statement hereunder regarding these activities. We have done so in order to provide further perspective on the matter. We feel it is our duty to speak out against the pernicious activities undertaken by this group overseas.

Critique, open discussion and thorough investigation of the I.D.F. and it’s activities are at the very core of the ethos of the I.D.F. and of Israeli society at large. The active circulation of unsubstantiated claims abroad is something of which cannot approve.

Please read and share the statement below. We must stop the dissemination of false allegations against our country, Israel and all of those who seek to defend Her.


Our Soldiers Speak


I provide this statement in order to make plain my views on the overseas activities of the organization Breaking the Silence.

I do so as a journalist of more than 46 years experience, dealing with national security and military affairs, as a retired Lt. Colonel in the Paratroops division of the Israel Defense Forces, and as a recipient of the Chief of Staff Distinguished Service Award for my participation in the Yom Kippur War of 1973. I stand firmly behind every word that follows.

1) The very name, Breaking the Silence is a deliberate, wanton misnomer. In the Sate of Israel, there is no ‘silence’ to be broken when it comes to matters of military conduct and ethics. Ours is an open society, the safety of which is ensured by the I.D.F. The I.D.F. has open channels through which all substantive complaints of operational impropriety are considered and investigated to their appropriate legal conclusion. Generally, though not always, this is via the Military Advocate General’s Corps. (M.A.G.), an organization that enjoys a large degree of independence from the chain of command; particularly on matters of conduct and ethics and the legal aspects of warfare. No claims of misconduct need to be taken abroad, therefore. The M.A.G. Corps regularly submits it’s findings for the consideration of legal bodies of the highest standing overseas.

2) Given that such channels are open internally, and that the M.A.G. Corps has repeatedly offered to cooperate with Breaking The Silence, there can be no justification for the dissemination of unsubstantiated claims abroad.

3) By ignoring the channels available to them at home, whether deliberately or not, Breaking the Silence, regrettably, serves as the certification of kashrut for much of the anti-Israel activity overseas. They provide an imprimatur for anti-I.D.F. views in foreign seats of academia.

4) Breaking the Silence leaves foreign audiences with the impression that the alleged, errant act of one solider, proven or not, is indicative of the ethos and the norms of the I.D.F. entire. This is false and libelous.

5) Given the ever intensifying delegitimization campaign against the State of Israel abroad and considering that much of that cynically centers about the work of the I.D.F., Breaking the Silence actively cultivates, perhaps unwittingly, both anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism among those with an already strong prejudice against the State of Israel and it’s citizens. Of particular danger is the false impression cultivated on campuses overseas.

6) As an individual who has dealt with military matters in times of war and in times of peace, both in uniform and as a civilian, I attest to the following absolutely. To the very best of their ability, the IDF and the general security apparatus of the State of Israel, consistently demonstrate probity and dispassionate professionalism when investigating any substantive complaint of military misconduct. They do so even as military operations are carried out. They do so by legal examination, undertaken by lawyers, throughout the planning, the execution and the consequence of any operation.

7) I have personally witnessed missions, both aerial and on land, that were aborted in order to spare the lives of uninvolved, innocent civilians proximate to a designated target; often at risk to our soldiers and officers. I therefore state that restraint and high regard for the international codes of conduct on the battlefield are the true hallmarks of the IDF. Those hallmarks cross all lines of politics, religion and gender within the I.D.F.

8) By continuing their activities abroad, Breaking the Silence demonstrates that they have no desire to correct the problems they claim to seek to remedy.

9) I urge Breaking the Silence to approach, and to coordinate with, the appropriate military and legal authorities in Israel, and to submit all claims for their review in order to facilitate a thorough investigation of every alleged act of misconduct.

10) I support the rights of all to come forward with criticism and complaint about the I.D.F. but they must do so here in Israel so that any wrongdoing may be corrected and punished if necessary. I have the highest confidence in the thoroughness of any investigations undertaken domestically.


Ron Ben-Yishai

Ron Ben-Yishai is a retired Lt. Colonel in the IDF paratroopers division. As a journalist for over 46 years, Mr. Ben-Yishai has covered some of the most volatile conflicts from both within and beyond the borders of Israel. He was the first Israeli correspondent to broadcast live from Baghdad in 2003. He has reported from Lebanon, Yemen, Tunis, Egypt, and Libya. His work has received several awards including the “Life Time Accomplishments” Award by the Tel Aviv Journalists Association in 2008.


OUR SOLDIERS SPEAK – Our Brave Soldiers Speak. Their Proud Truth


About the Author
Benjamin Anthony is the founder and CEO of two organizations. In 2006 he founded Our Soldiers Speak following his combat service inside Lebanon during the Second Lebanon War. Our Soldiers Speak is the leading vehicle, globally, for official and unofficial policy presentations by senior Israeli security and policy experts on college campuses throughout the English speaking world. Follow them at . Separate to Our Soldiers Speak, in 2014, he founded the New State Solution, a working group that envisages a conflict ending alternative to the status quo between Israelis and Palestinian Arabs. Follow them at . Benjamin Anthony regularly provides and facilitates educational briefings for members of the U.S. Senate, U.S. Congress and elite academic institutions throughout the English speaking world. His bio. sketch can be viewed here: