Jonathan Ferguson
Jonathan Ferguson
The New Understanding: Post-Secular Pluralism and Universalism!

Cursory Notes on Chinese Antisemitism

The book Chinese Perceptions of the Jews and Judaism: A History of the Youtai by Zhou Xun ( p.50), briefly discusses Kang Youwei, “the leading reformer of the ‘Hundred Days Reform’ in 1898,” and notes that this prominent figure in recent Chinese history had a critical view of Jews. The future Datong utopia, emancipated from superstition, would also be emancipated from Judaism and other backward faiths. Again, according to Zhou Xun (ibid.), Kang’s priorities of ‘the disciplining of individual sexual conduct and the regulation of the population’s reproduction’ led him to characterize Jewish people in a critical manner.

Although my ongoing PhD research involves Kang Youwei, I have not focused, in particular, on Kang Youwei’s antisemitism. Still, this snapshot of Chinese antisemitism in modern times highlights the importance of challenging political correctness, by recognizing racism (including antisemitism) as truly universal. It is important not only to recognize antisemitism in the Occident, or in the majority-Muslim world (two very obvious long-term historical hotspots of anti-Jewish hatred), but antisemitism everywhere in the world.

The fact that it is may not always be expedient to do so hardly makes the task any less pressing. I cannot say how widespread antisemitism is in China nowadays, but I do have some anecdotal experience (from my observations as a non-Jewish person) of positive stereotyping of Jews among Chinese people. I am not interested in the speculative glass bead game of whether degrading notion of Jews as ‘homo economicus’ is ‘worse,’ ‘less bad’ or ‘equivalent’ to more explicit forms of hatred. But this much I can say:

Political expediency has no place here.

I look forward to a serious engagement with the problem of antisemitism in every society and historical context; and I will hint, for now, that a serious account of antisemitism in China and among Chinese people may have implications for the revisionist ‘prejudice plus power’ thesis, which is so contrary to the common sense of people in the UK, if not elsewhere. If ‘mere’ racial prejudice is to be deemed less serious than racism with institutional power, then it must be asked whether privileging institutional racism over ‘mere’ racial prejudice can be tolerated much longer.

Clearly, racial prejudice is possible regardless of the power dynamics. I would be interested to see what light an investigation of antisemitism among the Chinese diaspora (or indeed anti-Chinese racism among the Jewish diaspora) would shed upon the relative strengths and weaknesses of the ‘prejudice plus power’ thesis.

It will also be interesting to see how Israel-China relations might be affected by such discussions. In the near future, I intend to write a little on the question of whether China has already hit ‘peak anti-Zionism.’

About the Author
Jonathan Ferguson is an honorary Yorkshireman, originally from Northern Ireland. Unfortunately however, it is utterly impossible (or at least something of a thankless task!) to note the slightest trace of Swiftian bantz and blarney in his scrupulously highminded and middle of the road prose style. He is also a Chinese graduate of the University of Leeds (BA, MA) and King's College London (PhD). On a deeper level, he is a curious mind and a recovering cynic; or to put it another way, an Orthodox Christian. His work is focused on religiophobia and the coming Age and World of post-secular pluralism and universalism. If you like (or love, or even absolutely HATE!) his work, then by all means do feel free comment on his work, or write to him in the personal comment box on his Times of Israel profile... Or alternatively, in the very worst, ne plus ultra cases of radical fanfatuation, just click "HERE" to become a Patron!
Related Topics
Related Posts