Sherwin Pomerantz

Democracy Must be Preserved Even During Wartime  


The decision by Knesset Speaker Yuli Edelstein to ban MK Haneen Zoabi from all parliamentary activity except voting for the next six months is both a mistake in judgment and a challenge to the survival of democracy in Israel.

Before anyone misunderstands me, let me be clear that I think Haneen Zoabi is a danger to Israel whose activities border on treason and that her use of the democratic process to undermine the stated policies of the government to which she swears allegiance is reason enough for her to be removed permanently from the Knesset.

Having said that, Israel needs to be very careful not to use the difficult situation in which we find ourselves today as an excuse to undermine the critical pillars of democratic life in this country.

I wrote after the Mavi Marmara incident in May 2010 that Haneen Zoabi’s participation in that activity when she was a sitting member of the Knesset was no less than an act of treason.  I believe it then and I believe it now, even though no charges were ever brought against her.  And that it was a mistake at the time not to prosecute her for that.

The current situation emanates from remarks she made at the time the three young yeshiva boys were kidnapped when she said on radio that “the kidnappers are not terrorists.  They have to use these means until Israel will wake up a little, until the citizens of Israel and Israeli society will wake up and feel the suffering of the other.”  Effectively she condoned the kidnapping as a means of fighting for one’s freedom and, of course, we all know the very sad end of that story both for the families involved and for all of us who live here.

As a result of those comments and others (i.e. her support for Hamas rocket attacks on Israel during Operation Protective Edge and the posting on a Hamas website encouraging Palestinians to take part in “popular resistance” and put Israel under siege instead of negotiating), Attorney General Yehuda Weinstein investigated her statements and ruled that what she said was not criminal incitement.  At that point the case was closed.  Frankly, the Attorney General was probably wrong on this item as well, not so much regarding what she said but because she is a sitting member of the Knesset during a period of war when her statements are in direct opposition to the policies of the government she is pledged to support.

So, yes, she should have been labeled guilty of treason in 2010 for her participation in an exercise sponsored by foreign forces against policies of the government to which she swore allegiance.  And yes, she should have been found guilty of criminal incitement for her latest remarks praising the actions of the enemy of the government to which she swore allegiance.

But the arm of government charged with making those determinations decided, for better or for worse, that the charges did not have merit. It then demeans the integrity of the Knesset to pass judgment on its own, a judgment that differs from the official positon of the state.  We need to remember that the Knesset is not a private club, but an arm of the Government of Israel.  If it were private club and it wanted to expel a member it would have the right to do so without regard to what anyone else says but, of course, within the existing laws of the country.  But the Knesset makes a mistake to think that it can act unilaterally because of its perceived breach in the judgment of the attorney general.

Once again, I am no fan of MK Haneen Zoabi and I think she is a dangerous and destructive element in Israel society who has clearly demonstrated that she should not be permitted to run for national office. However, the democratic nature of the country is challenged by those government units who, in the name of some higher authority, choose to impose their own sentences. And the fact that we are at war does not give them license to do so….not at all.

At this difficult time in our history, we would do well to remember the words of John F. Kennedy when he said:  “Israel was not created in order to disappear – Israel will endure and flourish.  It is the child of hope and the home of the brave. It can neither be broken by adversity nor demoralized by success. It carries the shield of democracy and it honors the sword of freedom.”  Those words were true 50 years ago when they were first uttered and remain so today, we simply have to remind ourselves of their import.

About the Author
Sherwin Pomerantz is a native New Yorker, who lived and worked in Chicago for 20 years before coming to Israel in 1984. An industrial engineer with advanced degrees in mechanical engineering and business, he is President of Atid EDI Ltd., a 32 year old Jerusalem-based economic development consulting firm which, among other things, represents the regional trade and investment interests of a number of US states, regional entities and Invest Hong Kong. A past national president of the Association of Americans & Canadians in Israel, he is also Former Chairperson of the Board of the Pardes Institute of Jewish Studies and a Board Member of the Israel-America Chamber of Commerce. His articles have appeared in various publications in Israel and the US.