‘Kavuni LeDorot’ Esther’s Unspoken Legacy

The palace of Shushan stands in eerie silence, its stillness heavy like a thick fog. Inside, Queen Esther stood alone, the cool marble beneath her feet grounds her in a moment of profound decision. She gazes out over the city, the weight of her choice pressing heavily on her heart. Her body, frail and trembling betrays the toll a three day fast has taken—so weak is she, tradition tells us, that the Shechinah had to physically hold her up. Yet, despite divine support, dread snakes through her veins. She knows the law: to approach the king uninvited is to court death. But something even more daunting is weighing on her.

She had warned Mordechai: “Ka’asher avadeti, avadeti”—“And as I am lost, I am lost.” Esther understood that approaching Achashverosh now would mean sacrificing something far deeper than her life. Even if he grants her favor, even if he miraculously agrees to save her people, by entering willingly, she seals her fate as his queen—not as a captive bride forced into marriage, but as a woman who chose to be by his side. There would be no return to Mordechai, no life among her people, no freedom from the gilded chains of the palace. This is her point of no return.

The Jewish people cannot yet fathom what salvation from this impending genocide might look like, but even if deliverance comes, Esther knows that for her, there is no going back. A part of her will be lost forever. 

“Ka’asher avadeti, avadeti.”

___________________________________________________________________________________________

The scene shifts. The year is 2023, 2024, 2025. He stands before the mirror, adjusting the uniform that feels heavier than it should, as if it carries the weight of a thousand generations. He gazes out over the rolling hills of the land he has always loved, the land he must now rise to defend. The air is thick with shadows of the past, and the future hangs in the balance.

He turns to his family, his voice tight with the gravity of the moment. He explains that Jewish history is calling to him in a way that he cannot ignore – to action, to sacrifice. It is for this very moment that he feels he has been created. There is no promise of victory, only the deep understanding that this choice will forever change him. He may return, but he will never be the same. A part of him will be left forevermore on the battlefield, lost to those he loves – physically, emotionally, mentally.

“Ka’asher avadeti, avadeti.”

___________________________________________________________________________________________

With a heavy heart, Esther turns to enter the king’s courtyard. Her breath catches in her chest as she steps forward – something is wrong. The king’s antechamber is filled with idols, and the Shechinah that has been holding her up must leave (Megillah 15b). Here she stands, seemingly abandoned in her most desperate hour. She is ready to bind herself in an unbreakable knot upon her sacrificial altar. So where is the Heavenly Voice, calling out to stop her before it’s too late? Where is her cloud of glory? A sudden plague coming to strike the king, as had shielded her foremothers in the past? Where are her ten plagues?  Were all the miracles that saved her ancestors simply bedtime stories? Was she undeserving of the same? Every fiber of Esther’s being is convincing her that Hashem was indeed here, and yet has left her. Had God really turned His back on her now, at the moment she needed Him most? The courtyard swirls with the false gods of Persia, each idol a silent mockery of her faith. The silence is deafening. 

___________________________________________________________________________________________

On Simchat Torah, a day meant for celebration and unity, they were ripped from their homes. Slain families and destroyed communities faded into the distance as they were dragged across the border and into captivity. For over a year and a half, hunger and fear were their constant tormentors. They languish mere minutes away from their people and yet totally unreachable. With every passing day, the stench of damp stone and despair fills the air, as the flickering hope of freedom fades further into the shadows. Every moment brings new horrors. They grasp at the faith of their ancestors, but all alone in the dark, the silence is deafening.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

Esther takes a moment to regain her balance. For a moment, God’s name feels a distant echo. But in this hastara sheBitoch haHastara Esther refuses to surrender her agency or faith. If there is now a void where God’s Presence once stood so clearly, then Esther has no choice but to speak it into being herself. And so with the last vestiges of her strength, she composes what would become the 22nd chapter of the book of Tehillim. In the silence, she calls out – 

אֵלִ֣י אֵ֭לִי לָמָ֣ה עֲזַבְתָּ֑נִי רָח֥וֹק מִֽ֝ישׁוּעָתִ֗י דִּבְרֵ֥י שַׁאֲגָתִֽי׃

My God, my God, why have You abandoned me; why so far from delivering me and from my anguished roaring?

Again, silence. But hers is the voice of a soul that will not be quieted. In the absence of immediate answers, she insists that she has witnessed the unbroken thread of God’s faithfulness across generations:  

וְאַתָּ֥ה קָד֑וֹשׁ י֝וֹשֵׁ֗ב תְּהִלּ֥וֹת יִשְׂרָאֵֽל׃

But You are the Holy One, enthroned, the Praise of Israel

בְּ֭ךָ בָּטְח֣וּ אֲבֹתֵ֑ינוּ בָּ֝טְח֗וּ וַֽתְּפַלְּטֵֽמוֹ׃

In You our fathers trusted; they trusted, and You rescued them.

אֵלֶ֣יךָ זָעֲק֣וּ וְנִמְלָ֑טוּ בְּךָ֖ בָטְח֣וּ וְלֹא־בֽוֹשׁוּ׃

To You they cried out and they escaped; in You they trusted and were not disappointed.

Her ancestor’s faith is her faith, their trust is her trust and that is enough for her. She recalls their cries, their deliverance, and her heart refuses to believe that God will abandon her now.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

In the depths of captivity,  Providence seems to vanish into the oppressive silence. But for the hostages – if God’s presence seems absent, they have spoken  it into being themselves. Keith Segal recites HaMotzi on any morsel of food he is awarded —the only blessing his trembling hands can offer. Omer Shem Tov chants Kiddush every Friday night, holding tightly to tradition and not letting it go. Agam Berger, gripped by hunger, refuses to eat non-kosher meat. Liri Albag decorates her room in anticipation and honor of Sukkot, the holiday that will mark one full year of her captivity. Omer Wenkert’s voice breaks through the stillness, singing Shir HaMaalot at the top of his lungs, refusing to let the despair drown out his prayers. Each of these rituals connects them to generations past, of a people that transcend time and place. Theirs is an ancient faith, a familiar trust and that is enough for them. They recall cries of old, the deliverance of their ancestors, and their hearts refuse to believe that God will abandon them now.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

The air is thick with the sweet scent of victory. The decree of destruction is overturned, and the streets of Shushan are alive with the jubilant sounds of celebration. It is a scene of utter joy, a testament to God’s mercy and the power of Esther’s courage.

But inside the palace, it is another world. The gates that once opened to welcome Esther in the moment of her triumph now slam shut behind her with an unyielding finality. She stands in the quiet of her chambers, the sounds of merrymaking just beyond the walls. The people dance in the streets, but she is not with them. She will never be with them again. Salvation comes for the Jewish people, but not without its price. 

As the celebration swells outside her window, Esther is consumed with a thousand unspoken questions. Why is this her fate? Why, after all her sacrifices—after risking her life for the survival of her people—is she left to walk this lonely path? Her heart had been pure, her intentions devoted to the glory of God and the continuation of her nation, yet she is the one left behind. If God can save an entire nation, why must she be left in darkness? If He could bring about the deliverance of her people, why can’t He deliver her, too? She can hear the clinking of cups, the laughter of children, and the dancing in the streets, but behind these palace walls, she is lost in a sea of unanswered questions.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

The men return. From Lebanon, Syria, Gaza, the Shomron. There are tears, embraces, and an electric joy as husbands, fathers, sons make families whole again. The streets are filled with relief, with the profound sense of reunion and for a moment, there is peace. But they are not really back.

In the warmth of their homes, they feel a chill. The faces of the fallen hover just out of sight. The ugliest of sounds reverberate in their ears. Their homes and families belong to different versions of themselves, ones that they no longer recognize. They are home, but horrible memories feel more real to them than the four walls they now occupy. A nation may be saved, and the world outside sings in celebration, but inside the combat has merely shifted to a war without a front, a battle without an end.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

A generation has passed. Shushan is the capital under a new king, the empire still at the height of its power. The new king has a new cupbearer. His name is Nechemiah – Jewish and a leader of his suffering people. He walks the palace corridors with a careful and confident step but his heart is elsewhere. As recorded in Sefer Nechemiah (Nechemiah 1:1-4)

דִּבְרֵ֥י נְחֶמְיָ֖ה בֶּן־חֲכַלְיָ֑ה וַיְהִ֤י בְחֹֽדֶשׁ־כִּסְלֵו֙ שְׁנַ֣ת עֶשְׂרִ֔ים וַאֲנִ֥י הָיִ֖יתִי בְּשׁוּשַׁ֥ן הַבִּירָֽה׃

The narrative of Nehemiah son of Hacaliah:

In the month of Kislev of the twentieth year, when I was in the fortress of Shushan,

וַיָּבֹ֨א חֲנָ֜נִי אֶחָ֧ד מֵאַחַ֛י ה֥וּא וַאֲנָשִׁ֖ים מִֽיהוּדָ֑ה וָאֶשְׁאָלֵ֞ם עַל־הַיְּהוּדִ֧ים הַפְּלֵיטָ֛ה אֲשֶֽׁר־נִשְׁאֲר֥וּ מִן־הַשֶּׁ֖בִי וְעַל־יְרוּשָׁלָֽ͏ִם׃

Hanani, one of my brothers, together with some men of Judah, arrived, and I asked them about the Jews, the remnant who had survived the captivity, and about Jerusalem.

וַיֹּאמְרוּ֮ לִי֒ הַֽנִּשְׁאָרִ֞ים אֲשֶֽׁר־נִשְׁאֲר֤וּ מִן־הַשְּׁבִי֙ שָׁ֣ם בַּמְּדִינָ֔ה בְּרָעָ֥ה גְדֹלָ֖ה וּבְחֶרְפָּ֑ה וְחוֹמַ֤ת יְרוּשָׁלַ֙͏ִם֙ מְפֹרָ֔צֶת וּשְׁעָרֶ֖יהָ נִצְּת֥וּ בָאֵֽשׁ׃

They replied, “The survivors who have survived the captivity there in the province are in dire trouble and disgrace; Jerusalem’s wall is full of breaches, and its gates have been destroyed by fire.”

וַיְהִ֞י כְּשׇׁמְעִ֣י ׀ אֶת־הַדְּבָרִ֣ים הָאֵ֗לֶּה יָשַׁ֙בְתִּי֙ וָֽאֶבְכֶּ֔ה וָאֶתְאַבְּלָ֖ה יָמִ֑ים וָֽאֱהִ֥י צָם֙ וּמִתְפַּלֵּ֔ל לִפְנֵ֖י אֱלֹהֵ֥י הַשָּׁמָֽיִם׃

When I heard that, I sat and wept, and was in mourning for days, fasting and praying to the God of Heaven.

Nechemiah has a life in Shushan. He has a job, responsibilities, and a family. But he feels Jewish history calling to him in a way that he cannot ignore. He knows he must approach the king, and he knows that this is a risky endeavor. But he is only alive now because others before him had taken similar risks, and now it was his turn.

The king awaits his trusted cupbearer, but he sees something is wrong. Nechemiah, usually so composed, is pale, his body thin from days of fasting. The king’s first thought is that Nechemiah seeks to poison him, and suspicion fills the air. But Nechemiah quickly reassures the king, explaining his grief over the fate of his people. The king is calmed, but Nechemiah is not the only one who understands the weight of this moment.

The king is sitting on his throne, “והשגל יושבת אצלו – with his consort seated at his side” (Nechemiah 2:6). It is the Malbim’s commentary who puts names to faces – the king is Darius, son of Esther and Achashveirosh, and the consort seated at his side is none other than his mother, Queen Esther. A lifetime has passed since she was hidden away in the palace, separated from her people. Her sacrifice, the years of silence, the unanswered prayers—these were now a distant memory. Or so she thought.

Nechemiah steps forward, his figure trembling, and something stirs deep within Esther. He stands in the same courtyard, facing the same throne she once faced, bearing the same burden of salvation in a body weak from fasting. And then, Nechemiah opens his mouth and her heart is pierced;

 “אִם־עַל־הַמֶּ֣לֶךְ ט֔וֹב – if it should so please the King” (Nechemia 2:5) 

The very same words she had once said. All at once it comes flooding back. The years of silent suffering, the prayers whispered in every corner of the palace chambers. She had thought that no one had seen, that no one had heard. But she was wrong. 

Nechemia asks to be sent back to Jerusalem to rebuild it, culminating in the building of the second Temple, marking a complete redemption from this long and dark exile under which so many had suffered. The Malbim explains that it is Darius’s love for his mother that encourages his decision to grant Nechemiah his request and send the Jewish people on the next step of their journey towards ultimate redemption. All because of Esther’s sacrifice – the ones she thought no one saw, the ones that she lived with every day in silent suffering. In Nechemia’s echoing of her words, she understood that she had never been alone. That the Jewish people, and God saw and recognized her anguish, that her words had become legend. Throughout the years of her own quiet exile, she had unknowingly become the architect of her people’s future. 

___________________________________________________________________________________________

“קִבְעוּנִי לְדוֹרוֹת” Esther tells the Jewish sages (Megilla 7a), “establish my story for generations”. The Sages are reticent, they fear that to publicize the story of Jewish defeat over their enemies will arouse the wrath of the nations. But Esther explains that her story is already well known, others have already told it. She is right, and the Book of Esther is officially chronicled.

But they are right too –  there is a part of her story that cannot be captured in a tale about a miraculous salvation. Victory is not always so sweet, and the narrative is never as simple as it first appears. The true costs of such stories are not something that can be written down as one of the statistics of a battle – it is inestimable, and grows exponentially.

Esther didn’t need a book in the annals of Tanach to enshrine her legacy of duty and self sacrifice. Her lessons are unspoken, etched in the eyes of those whose joy on Purim can never be as whole as it once was. Their sacrifices are shaping the future of the Jewish people no less than hers. Like Esther, who stood in the palace, struggling in a way hidden from the world’s eyes yet pivotal to its survival, these heroes carry us forward in ways we cannot yet comprehend. The silent battles they fight, though they may seem unrecognized, will one day be woven into the narrative of Jewish survival. And just as Esther’s legacy endures, so too will theirs—etched  לְדוֹרוֹת, for generations to come.