The Sages Are Whitmanesque

We are taught in the Torah that one is supposed to leave a corner of one’s field unharvested for the poor (peah). The Rabbis in the Mishna ask the following question: What if a man who has fields at home is traveling and hungry; may he take from the peah (yes), and more interestingly, when he gets home, should he contribute to compensate for what he has taken?

Rabbi Eliezer says he must, and the Sages say he need not. As Rabbi Yosef Kanesfky pointed out when teaching this Mishna, this is an existential question. Rabbi Eliezer sees the traveler as a wealthy man who was in temporary need, and therefore must pay. But the Sages believe that he was, at that moment, a poor man, and therefore, though compensating later might be praiseworthy, it is not mandated because the poor don’t have to replace the tzedakah they are given. 

In other words, the Sages are Whitmanesque — we all contain multitudes. No one is insulated from being suddenly in another position: The healthy will be sick, the joyous will be bereaved, the rich man may be brought low. The Mishna is reminding us that in an uncertain world, we will all need each other — we just never know when. 

Rabbi David Wolpe is spiritual leader of Sinai Temple in Los Angeles. Follow him on Twitter: @RabbiWolpe His latest book is “David: The Divided Heart” (Yale University Press). 

About the Author
Named the most influential Rabbi in America by Newsweek Magazine and one of the 50 most influential Jews in the world by the Jerusalem Post, David Wolpe is the Rabbi of Sinai Temple in Los Angeles, California.