Sherwin Pomerantz

Yes, This is the Kind of Country We are ….And Proud of It  


Among the many articles in today’s press about the ongoing war here (for those living overseas please understand it is no less a war here in Israel than it is in Gaza independent of the lopsided body counts) one item hit my eye that caused me to pen this piece.

In a Jerusalem Post interview with residents of Gaza 27 year old Ahmed Mansour, wounded in the attacks on Gaza, is quoted as saying from his hospital bed:  “They even shelled people as they fled their houses.  What kind of human beings could do that?”  So for the benefit of my cousin Ahmed, let me tell you what kind of human beings we are even though you will probably never see this piece.

Since Israel withdrew from Gaza in 2005, 11,000 rockets have been fired into Israel from Gaza and, before this week, only once, in 2012, did Israel respond by going into Gaza to try to eliminate the sources of those rockets.  Ahmed, you would never see that level of restraint on the part of any country in the world whose sovereignty was being attacked by a neighbor, regardless of the complaints that neighbor had about the relationship between the two political entities.  As a case in point Russia annexed the Crimean peninsula earlier this year after just days of angst and without being threatened militarily. So that’s the kind of country we are, a Jewish country with Jewish values and a desire not to inflict civilian casualties.

And when, just in the period from July 7-17, 1,539 rockets were launched from Gaza we still did not invade.  Rather, we attempted to take out the sources of the rockets with an air attack.  But first, our military telephoned and texted the residents of Gaza who were in target range of our missiles with warnings to leave.  Before the attack itself we detonated a small charge on the roof of the building to underscore the seriousness of the warning.  It was only then that we attacked locations that your government was using as missile launching sites camouflaged in private buildings. So that’s the kind of country we are, a Jewish country with Jewish values and a desire not to inflict civilian casualties.

But last week we thought we saw light at the end of the tunnel, not the tunnels your government built as infiltration paths into Israel, but the tunnel of conflict.  Through the efforts of the Egyptian government, the UN and others, a cease fire proposal was put on the table which our government immediately accepted and your government rejected calling it, in the words of one of your leaders comfortably ensconced in the safety of Lebanon, “a joke.”  After all had the cease fire been accepted you would not have been wounded and perhaps, just perhaps, we could have met together in Cairo and figured out a way to improve both our lives.  We accepted the proposal because we value a human life above all.  So that’s the kind of country we are, a Jewish country with Jewish values and a desire not to inflict civilian casualties.

Finally, when it became painfully obvious to all of us living here and being driven to seek shelter from your rocket fire multiple times a day, we knew we had no choice but to put our young men, our sons, fathers, brothers, uncles and cousins in harm’s way by launching a ground incursion into Gaza to destroy the system of tunnels your government had built in order to attack us.  Of course, as is our custom, before we did that we once again warned your people to leave their homes in the area of the planned invasion in order to minimize casualties while your government told your friends and family to remain.  Our question of you should be what kind of government has so little respect for the value of human life that it urges you to remain in place in spite of the warnings of our military command to the contrary?  As for us, we place a high enough value on every human life, even yours, to minimize the potential casualties that eventuate from a ground invasion.  So that’s the kind of country we are, a Jewish country with Jewish values and a desire not to inflict civilian casualties.

Ahmed, your life is not one that any of us would like to experience.  You are residing in a living hell created by your own leadership for their own political purposes without regard to your welfare.  Even sadder is the fact that the shots are being called by people sitting far away from the conflict whose own lives and those of their families are clearly not in danger.  The question you raise should be directed at your own government, a government that chooses to let you live in squalor and poverty while creating a political crisis with us that makes us sacrifice our best and brightest in battle.

As Cicero said in his first oration against Cataline, “O tempora o mores”…..shame on the times and its customs.  And shame on the government of Gaza for making you suffer and forcing us to inflict death and destruction on your land.

About the Author
Sherwin Pomerantz is a native New Yorker, who lived and worked in Chicago for 20 years before coming to Israel in 1984. An industrial engineer with advanced degrees in mechanical engineering and business, he is President of Atid EDI Ltd., a 32 year old Jerusalem-based economic development consulting firm which, among other things, represents the regional trade and investment interests of a number of US states, regional entities and Invest Hong Kong. A past national president of the Association of Americans & Canadians in Israel, he is also Former Chairperson of the Board of the Pardes Institute of Jewish Studies and a Board Member of the Israel-America Chamber of Commerce. His articles have appeared in various publications in Israel and the US.