A Jew is a Jew: A Shared Identity is a Shared Fate

“A pro-Israel Jew and an anti-Israel Jew walk into a bar. The bartender says, ‘I’m sorry, we don’t serve Jews.” This popular saying that’s been recently circling the internet represents a harsh reality: antisemitism does not differentiate between pro-Israel and anti-Israel Jews. Despite internal divisions, we ultimately face the same external threats. Whether one supports or criticizes Israel, our identity as Jews subjects us to the same prejudices and dangers. Now, more than ever, there must be unity in adversity and perpetual solidarity within the Jewish community.

In recent years, many Jews in America have distanced themselves from Israel, believing their stance against the nation’s policies shields them from the challenges faced by their Israeli counterparts. Some also view their criticism as a moral high ground, removing themselves from the conflicts and issues faced in the Middle East. This belief, however, is fundamentally flawed. Historical events, such as the Holocaust, have shown that despite our internal differences, we face persecution as a unified group; the true nature of antisemitism is persistent and indiscriminate, targeting us regardless of political stance or geographic location.

Recent years have also seen a disturbing rise in antisemitic incidents across the world. According to the Anti-Defamation League (ADL), there was a 337% increase in antisemitic incidents in the US between October 7 and December 7, 2023, compared to the same period in 2022 [1]. In the UK, London police reported a 1,353% increase in antisemitic hate crimes from October 1 to 18, 2023, compared to the same period in the previous year [2]. In 2023, France registered the highest increase in recorded antisemitic incidents of any country with reliable statistics, with nearly a quadrupling of cases [3]. These attacks do not spare those who are critical of Israel. The fact remains that antisemites don’t care about political beliefs or actions.

The equation is simple: a shared identity makes us equally vulnerable to hate crimes. Events around the world have a ripple effect, impacting Jewish communities globally. The recent Israel-Hamas war, which began on October 7th, has also heightened awareness and concern among Jews worldwide in polarizing ways. In the immediate aftermath, the Jewish Agency reported a significant increase in inquiries about Aliyah, reflecting a renewed connection to their roots and a sense of urgency to stand with their fellow Jews in Israel [4].

While some have found renewed solidarity with Israel, others have taken a different path, joining anti-Israel protests and aligning with Palestinian causes. This internal polarization highlights the complex nature of our collective identity. Despite these internal divisions, unity has historically been a source of strength for our people. Solidarity is crucial in times of adversity. Internal divisions only weaken the community’s ability to combat antisemitism effectively. Recognizing our collective responsibility towards each other is essential for the resilience and future of the Jewish community.

Moreover, unity does not mean the absence of dissent. Constructive dialogue within communities about differing perspectives on Israel is necessary for growth and understanding. However, these discussions mustn’t detract from the overarching goal of combating antisemitism and supporting one another. Engaging in respectful discourse while standing together against common threats will only fortify our community.

To ensure our collective resilience, we must foster environments where all Jews feel supported, regardless of political beliefs. This means actively participating in community events, supporting Jewish organizations, and advocating for policies that protect and uplift Jewish people globally. Educational programs that address the history and contemporary issues of anti-semitism can also play a pivotal role in uniting against prejudice.

Internal differences should not overshadow the common identity and fate that bind us all. By standing together against antisemitism, we can only strengthen and honor our shared heritage. Unity and solidarity are vital for building a stronger, more resilient Jewish community capable of facing any challenge because a Jew is a Jew, regardless of political beliefs. Together, we can ensure a brighter future, one united in both purpose and strength.

Footnotes

1. Anti-Defamation League (ADL), “ADL Reports Unprecedented Rise in Antisemitic Incidents Post- Octo.7,” Link
2. The Times of Israel, “London police report 1,353% rise in antisemitic hate crimes since Hamas onslaught,” Link
3. Times of Israel, “In global surge of antisemitism, France stands out with near-quadrupling of cases,” Link
4. Israel Hayom, “Aliyah Applications See Massive Uptick Following October 7,” Link