David Brog

A tale of two hearts

Two seemingly unrelated stories that highlight the contrast between a culture of death and one that values of life

Last week, a disturbing video made the social media rounds. It shows an armed rebel dismembering a dead soldier’s body. He then extracts and eats the soldier’s heart. According to Human Rights Watch, the cannibal is a Syrian rebel leader named Abu Sakkar. His snack was a Syrian government soldier.

While cutting away at his victim, Sakkar says, “We swear to Allah that we will eat your hearts and livers, you soldiers of Bashar the dog.” Bashar Assad is the Syrian President the rebels seek to topple.

We’ve seen this movie before. We’ve seen the bloody beheadings of Daniel Pearl and hundreds of others. We’ve seen the lynching of Israeli soldiers by men who then held up their blood-drenched hands in celebration. We’ve seen the blood lust of Assad himself, who’s already killed tens of thousands of his citizens in his effort to cling to power.

The same day that this video was posted, a group of Israelis was engaged in a similar activity. They too surrounded a prostrate Syrian. They too cracked open her chest. But the Israelis did not consume her heart. They healed it. The Israelis were a team of doctors. Their patient was a four-year-old Syrian girl born with a life-threatening heart defect.

This tale of two hearts provides a penetrating insight into what has driven the Arab-Israeli conflict for the last two decades. The radical element in Islam which rejects our reverence for human life cannot be appeased by words, compromises or dialogue. This culture of death demands corpses. Eating them is optional.

As Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah has stated it: “The Jews love life, so that is what we shall take away from them. We are going to win, because they love life and we love death.” This culture of death is what drives members of Hezbollah, Hamas and other terrorist organizations to blow themselves up in Israeli buses and cafes. This culture is what drove members of these organizations to dance in the streets last month upon hearing that Americans had been murdered in Boston.

Israel, like America, celebrates life. That is why the group which performed this operation – the Save a Child’s Heart Foundation – is so widely celebrated in Israel for saving the lives of Arab children from Syria, Iraq, the Palestinian Authority and elsewhere. This is also why Israeli soldiers repeatedly enter dangerous neighborhoods on foot – rather than bombing them from their air – in their effort to capture or kill terrorists. They are seeking to minimize civilian deaths. Many Israeli soldiers have paid the ultimate price for this caution.

This situation defies the modern drive towards moral relativism. Yes, Israelis – like their American counterparts – do kill innocent civilians in their effort to combat terror. But when they do so, it is not a success to be celebrated. It is a tragedy to be lamented and a mistake to be corrected. Israelis have never celebrated the deaths of innocent Arabs. I pray and believe they never will.

There are of course many Arabs and Muslims who reject this culture of death. Many do so in words. Some have done so in powerful deeds. In March 1997, for example, a Jordanian soldier – Corporal Ahmed Daqamseh – opened fire on a group of Israeli schoolgirls visiting the Jordanian border. He killed seven schoolgirls and wounded six others before his rifle jammed.

A few days after the attack, King Hussein of Jordan did something extraordinary. He travelled to Israel to express his remorse. He actually knelt down before each of the grieving families. “Your daughter is like my daughter. Your loss is my loss,” he told them. At that moment in time, peace – real peace – seemed possible.

Sadly, not all Jordanian’s share the late King’s heart. Speaking on Al Jazeera in 2001, Daqamseh’s mother said, “I am proud of my son. My son did a heroic deed and has pleased Allah and his own conscience.” Last month, over ninety percent of the members of the Jordanian Parliament – 110 out of 120 – signed a petition calling Daqamesh a “hero” and demanding a special pardon to release him.

And therein lies the problem. It seems that time has been kinder to Daqamesh than to King Hussein. Time has been kinder to the Egyptian Islamic Jihad than to Anwar Sadat, the Arab peacemaker they murdered. The radicals are not on the run. They are on the rise.

Will the Arab world be led by people with King Hussein’s heart, or will it be led by people who eat hearts? At various times during the past decades, there was reason for optimism. This is not one of those times.

About the Author
David Brog is the executive director of Maccabee Task Force, an organization that combats the spread of antisemitism and the Boycott Divestment Sanctions (BDS) Movement on college campuses. He previously served as executive director of Christians United for Israel (CUFI) for its first 10 years. Prior to CUFI, Brog worked in the United States Senate for seven years as chief of staff to Senator Arlen Spector, and staff director of the Senate Judiciary Committee. A recognized Jewish thought leader and advocate for Israel, Brog is the author of “Standing with Israel: Why Christians Support the Jewish State,” “In Defense of Faith: the Judeo-Christian Idea and the Struggle for Humanity” and “Reclaiming Israel’s History: Roots, Rights, and the Struggle for Humanity.” In 2007, Brog was listed as one of The Forward newspaper’s "Forward 50" most influential Jews in America. He is a graduate of Princeton University and Harvard Law School.