Malik Roberts

And Now, the $64,000 Question: Why Do I Support Israel?

Every so often, somebody asks me a question that, to hear some people tell it, ought to be accompanied by a drumroll, a flashing neon sign, and the sound of a studio orchestra preparing for the commercial break.

Why in God’s name do I support Israel?

Well, ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls, and everybody watching at home, we have arrived at the $64,000 question. And no, I’m not going to ask the audience, phone a friend, or eliminate two of the four possible answers. I have an answer of my own, thank you very much. And it is based entirely on common sense.

I support Israel because I believe in the rights of indigenous peoples. All of them. Not merely the ones whose histories happen to fit neatly into my preferred political narrative, nor only those whose struggles enjoy the approval of my particular social circle. All of them.

And the Jewish people are indigenous to the Land of Israel.

I realize that this statement, which I consider a fairly straightforward acknowledgment of history, can provoke some remarkably complicated reactions. Apparently, there are people who believe that Jewish history began somewhere in Europe, that Jewish ties to the land are little more than a religious fairy tale, and that the existence of a Jewish state is somehow an inexplicable aberration of modern history.

To that, I can only say: Have we met the history books? Have we met archaeology? Have we met the Hebrew and Yiddish languages? Has anybody introduced them to one another?

I am an African-descended person born and raised in Washington, D.C. who also has a pretty healthy dosage of Cherokee ancestry.

I have spent much of my life thinking about history, identity, belonging, and the ways in which people remember—or conveniently forget—the past. I have also spent an inordinate amount of time watching movies, but that is another story. Or perhaps it isn’t. After all, the history of cinema is full of people trying to tell us who we are, where we came from, and whose stories deserve to be told.

When I think about the Jewish people’s relationship with Israel, I think about the relationship between the Native American nations and the land that became my country. I do not pretend that these histories are identical. They are not. But the comparison raises a question I find difficult to ignore: If we can recognize that Native American peoples have ancestral, cultural, and historical connections to their homelands, why should the Jewish people’s connection to theirs be treated as an exception?

Indigeneity as a virtue in one conversation and an inconvenience in another is not only fraudulent–-it is a lie.

Thanksgiving is an interesting occasion for an American to contemplate questions of history and belonging. Every November, we gather around tables laden with turkey, stuffing, cranberry sauce, and whatever regional delicacies our families insist are indispensable. We celebrate gratitude, family, and the traditions that have become part of our national identity.

But Thanksgiving also invites us to consider the history of the land on which we live. The familiar story of the Pilgrims and the Wampanoag people is considerably more complicated than the cheerful illustrations in our elementary-school textbooks might suggest. Native American peoples inhabited this continent long before European colonization, and their histories did not begin when English settlers arrived.

I support their right to preserve their cultures, languages, traditions, communities, and relationships with their ancestral homelands. I do not believe those rights disappear because centuries of conquest and settlement have transformed the political map.

And I do not believe that recognizing Native American history requires us to wish the United States out of existence.

That distinction is important.

If I can acknowledge that Native American peoples have a history in this land that predates the United States, I see no reason to deny the Jewish people’s ancient connection to the Land of Israel.

The Jewish people emerged in the ancient Near East. Ancient Israel and Judah, the Hebrew language, Jewish religious traditions, Jerusalem, and the historical and cultural life of the Jewish people are inseparable from the land Jews have called Israel.

Jewish communities maintained a presence in the land through successive periods of imperial rule and political transformation. Generations of Jews living elsewhere continued to orient their religious and cultural lives toward Jerusalem. Their holidays, prayers, literature, and collective memory preserved an attachment to the land across centuries of dispersion.

The modern State of Israel was established in 1948. The Jewish people’s history did not begin that year.

This distinction ought not to require a doctoral dissertation to understand.

Nor does it require anyone to subscribe to Judaism as a religion. I am not Jewish on paper, and I do not claim Jewish ancestry. My support for Israel does not depend on pretending otherwise. I can recognize the historical connection of a people to its ancestral homeland without claiming that history as my own.

The Holocaust is indispensable to understanding the modern Jewish world and the urgency of Jewish refuge. But Jewish attachment to Israel existed long before the rise of Nazism. Modern political Zionism emerged in the nineteenth century, drawing upon an older Jewish connection to the land and responding to the realities of antisemitism, nationalism, and the struggle for Jewish security and self-determination. The Holocaust did not create the Jewish people’s relationship with Israel. It demonstrated, with unspeakable horror, the consequences of a world in which Jewish security could not be taken for granted.

We can acknowledge the catastrophe of European antisemitism without pretending that Jews were strangers to the Middle East. We can recognize the circumstances surrounding Israel’s establishment without treating Jewish history as a costume donned for political convenience.

And we can acknowledge Jewish indigeneity without denying that Palestinians, too, have deep familial, cultural, and historical connections to the land. One truth does not require the erasure of another.

One laughs at the assumption that a Black American who supports Israel must have somehow wandered out of his assigned political department. Apparently, somebody tarnished the Black Pride manifesto. I obviously missed the memo informing me that my opinions about the Middle East are supposed to be determined by a committee of people who have either never met me, or have presuppositions of what my views ought to be if they do know me. Even if there were a prescribed list of positions I must hold to qualify as a “proper” Black man, I would have run it through a paper shredder.

I have never believed that my racial identity requires me to outsource my judgment. I am perfectly capable of listening to people whose experiences differ from my own, learning from them, and reconsidering my assumptions. But listening is not the same thing as surrendering my independence.

I am Black. I am American. I am an artist and a student of film history. I am also someone who supports Israel.

These things are not mutually exclusive.

My support for Israel does not diminish my concern for Black Americans. My interest in Jewish history does not require me to abandon my interest in African American history. My recognition of antisemitism does not cancel my opposition to racism, and my opposition to racism does not excuse antisemitism when it appears in spaces where I might otherwise feel politically at home.

I refuse to believe that compassion is a limited resource, distributed in fixed quantities according to demographic category.

My own upbringing taught me that the people we love can leave us with lessons that are both invaluable and incomplete.

My mother, who introduced me to movies and impressed upon me the importance of opposing racism and antisemitism, died when I was fourteen. My father, an artist with a soft spot for macho-tough-guy movies, helped shape my visual imagination and my interest in composition, color, and the art of cinema. He also held views about Jews and Israel that I came to reject.

I loved my father. I can acknowledge what he gave me without inheriting every opinion he held. Love is not a requirement to reproduce another person’s prejudices, and family loyalty should not demand intellectual surrender. We can honor the people who shaped us while making our own judgments about the things they never resolved.

I have spent much of my life studying the art of storytelling. A good film historian knows that a story can be distorted by what the storyteller leaves out. A scene can be technically accurate and still be misleading if the larger context has been removed. History works much the same way.

If you tell the story of Israel beginning in 1948, you have already omitted thousands of years of Jewish history. If you tell the story of Palestinian displacement while refusing to acknowledge Jewish persecution and national aspirations, you have omitted essential context.

And if you tell the story of either people as though the other has no history, you have not produced an honest account. You have produced an edit. And as a history buff, I have a wholesale objection to bad editing.

My public embrace of Zionism became much more pronounced after October 7, 2023.

The Hamas-led attacks on Israel that day, involving mass murder, hostage-taking, and atrocities against civilians, forced a question into the foreground that I could no longer treat as an abstract political debate: What does it mean to support the Jewish people’s right to live in security and freedom when that right is challenged by people who seek to destroy the Jewish state?

For me, the answer was not to become less sympathetic to the Jewish people. It was to become more explicit about my support.

I watched with horror as the murders and kidnappings of Israeli civilians became the subject of arguments in which the victims’ humanity sometimes seemed secondary to the political narratives surrounding them.

The murder of a child is not made less terrible by the politics of the child’s country. The kidnapping of a grandmother is not justified by a historical grievance. Deliberately targeting civilians does not become acceptable because the perpetrators claim to act in the name of a cause.

The moral principle is not complicated.

I also refused to accept the notion that opposing Hamas meant opposing Palestinian people, or that expressing concern for Palestinian civilians required me to minimize the crimes of Hamas. Palestinians are not collectively responsible for every action of Hamas, just as Israeli civilians are not collectively responsible for every action of their government.

It is possible to support Israel’s existence, condemn Hamas’s atrocities, and grieve for Palestinian civilians caught in war. It is possible to believe that Israel has a right to defend its population while insisting that military operations comply with international humanitarian law and that civilian lives be protected. It is possible to want Hamas removed as a governing and military threat, and a future in which Israelis and Palestinians can live without fear of one another. Those positions are not contradictions. They are the difficult requirements of taking human life seriously.

The word Zionism has become so politically overcharged that most people seem to believe it can mean only one thing: white supremacy in its purest form. That is very clearly not so.

At its most fundamental, Zionism is the affirmation of the Jewish people’s right to self-determination in their ancestral homeland. There have always been differences among Zionists concerning religion, socialism, liberalism, territorial questions, security, diplomacy, and the political arrangements under which Jews and their neighbors should live. Zionism is also something I happen to go along with.

Israel is demonstrably the spiritual, ancestral, and national home of the Jewish people and has the right to exist as such.

That is my answer to the $64,000 question. No lifeline required.

Happy Thanksgiving.

About the Author
Malik Roberts is a Washington, DC-born, Atlanta-based film historian, illustrator & writer whose interests span American cinema and cultural history, and the intersection of identity and ideology. An American Zionist and advocate for civil rights, LGBTQ equality, and Jewish peoplehood, he writes from the conviction that historical memory, intellectual honesty, and moral consistency must transcend political convenience.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.