Yitzhak Klein

Another View: Addis-sur-Seine

Prof. David Betz is director of the MA program in War Studies at King’s College, London. One of his specialties is the study of failed states that collapse into civil disorder or civil war: The conditions that lead to political disintegration, the conditions in societies that undergo collapse. In a pair of disconcerting articles in Military Strategy Magazine (here and here), Betz applies the accepted tools of analysis in his field to contemporary Britain and France:

“[A] generation ago all Western countries could still be described as to a large degree cohesive nations, each with a greater or lesser sense of common identity and heritage. By contrast, all now are incohesive political entities, jigsaw puzzles of competing identity-based tribes, living in large part in virtually segregated ‘communities’ competing over diminishing societal resources increasingly obviously and violently. Moreover, their economies are mired in a structural malaise leading, inevitably in the view of several knowledgeable observers to systemic collapse. . . .

“Moreover, it is not simply that the conditions [for societal breakdown] are present in the West; it is, rather, that the conditions are nearing the ideal. The relative wealth, social stability and related lack of demographic factionalism, plus the perception of the ability of normal politics to solve problems that once made the West seem immune to civil war are now no longer valid. In fact, in each of these categories the direction of pull is towards civil conflict. (Betz, “Civil War Comes to the West”)”

It is against the background of this analysis that we ought to view the recent, recurrent mass street violence in France. The cause of the demonstrations that bring hundreds of thousands of ordinary citizens into the streets, most of them nonviolent, is the impending collapse of French finances and the realization by millions that when they need to rely on it the French welfare state will simply not be there. A committed ideological minority, red (communist) and green (Islamist), deliberately engages in violence in order to bring down the existing French state and build a new political order in their own image on the ruins.

Politically, the situation in France parallels that of the Weimar Republic in 1932.  The political center that sustains the current French state has withered into impotence and the extremes of Left and Right dominate. In the Presidential elections scheduled for this April the leading candidates are Marine Le Pen of the National Rally and Jean-Luc Melenchon of France Unbowed. Let’s leave aside the policy positions of these two candidates: The question is what is likely to happen in France if current polls are correct and Marine Le Pen is elected President.

The violent riots observed recently in France are likely to prove only the appetizer.  The radical left could take to the streets with the objective of overturning the results of the election. Le Pen will not flinch in the face of such a challenge. The French gendarmerie has already reached the limits of its capabilities; if necessary, the army will to be ordered into the streets and if necessary will open fire.

The radical left coalition will have taken this into account and in fact be courting it.  A common political tactic of the radical left in modern times is to foment street violence in hopes of causing authorities to react with violence.  Then the Left then tries to further delegitimize the regime as violent, oppressive fascists.  At this point neither side is likely to remain in control of events and the path to outright civil war may be short.  It will be interesting to see how the Government of France, which recently recognized a Palestinian state, reacts if banlieus (suburban concentrations of Moslems) in France declare themselves to be de facto Islamic states and proclaim to the world that they are occupied territory.

One thing is sure:  If Frenchman fights Frenchman, there are some whose first priority will be to get the Jews.

The latest issue of Makor Rishon weekly features an article on aliya from France.  Since the outbreak of the riots in October this year the number of French Jews considering moving to Israel has increased severalfold.  The Absorption Ministry anticipates that 20,000 French Jews may come on aliya in the next two years, perhaps as many as 50,000 in the coming few years.

All this assumes that things in France, bad as they are, will not get significantly worse anytime soon.  French Jews will for the most part be able to continue with their current lives.  The number interested in aliya may grow, but they will be able to do so in an orderly fashion, opening files with the Ministry of Absorption, taking the time to find jobs and decide where to relocate to in Israel.

I propose that to assume that matters in France will be the same after April as they are now is taking a big risk.  Plans need to be made now for the contingency that things for French Jews may get much worse very quickly.  If France descends into permanent ethnic and political violence it may become necessary to act in emergency mode:  To evacuate far more than a few score thousand Jews to Israel, and to do it fast.

In May 1991, as the Ethiopian civil war ground to its conclusion, the IDF took over Addis Ababa airport and moved nearly 15,000 Beita Yisrael to Israel in a couple of days.  France is a big country with a powerful air force and it will not be possible to respond to an emergency situation without the consent of the Government of France.  The point is that planning should begin now.  The government of Israel – even the current transition government – should begin conversations with the Macron regime and, informally, with Marine Le Pen.  There’s no point in trying to talk with Jean-Luc Melenchon.

The choice of what to do in case France descends into civil disorder is up to every French Jew, but French Jews should be informed that contingency plans are being laid.  Israel should be prepared to bring many, many of them out of conflict zones and to airports where they can be flown to this country.  They may come with no more than a suitcase apiece, or not even that.  The time to look ahead and prepare is now.

About the Author
Dr Yitzhak Klein is Head of the Department of Policy Research at Kohelet Policy Forum, Israel's leading conservative policy institute. He holds a PhD in International Relations.
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.