April 15, 1865: A Pesach to Remember
April 15, 1865, should have been a day of celebration. The Civil War was essentially over, the Union had been preserved, and Americans were beginning to contemplate a future without the bloodshed that had consumed the nation for four years. For Jews across America, it was also Shabbat Chol Hamoed Pesach, the festival celebrating freedom from slavery.
But instead of celebration, the day brought unimaginable sorrow. The previous evening, President Abraham Lincoln had been shot by an assassin at Ford’s Theatre. Early Saturday morning, he died. And as Jews gathered in their synagogues to celebrate Pesach, they received the news that the president who had helped emancipate America’s slaves was dead.
The timing could hardly have been more extraordinary.
Just five days earlier, on April 9th, Confederate General Robert E. Lee had surrendered to Union General Ulysses S. Grant at Appomattox, effectively bringing the Civil War to an end. After four years of devastating bloodshed, the country was finally beginning to celebrate the prospect of peace. President Lincoln was looking forward to a new chapter in American history.
On Friday evening, April 14th, Lincoln and his wife, Mary Todd Lincoln, attended a performance at Ford’s Theatre in Washington. At approximately 10:15p.m., actor John Wilkes Booth, a Confederate sympathizer, entered the presidential box and fired a pistol into the back of Lincoln’s head.
Lincoln was carried across the street to the Petersen House, where he was placed in a small bedroom. He never regained consciousness. At 7:22am on April 15th, Abraham Lincoln died at the age of 56.
The news spread quickly throughout the country, and the reaction was one of profound shock and grief. For the Jewish community, there was something especially poignant about the timing. It was Pesach, the holiday when Jews gather to recount the story of their ancestors’ liberation from Egyptian slavery.
Jewish congregations across America were particularly devastated by the news. Lincoln was not simply the president of the United States. To many Jews, he was a friend who had demonstrated an unusual commitment to religious equality at a time when antisemitism and discrimination were still very much part of American life.
As news of the assassination reached synagogues on Shabbat, rabbis struggled to find the words to express their sorrow. According to historical accounts, many abandoned the sermons they had prepared for Passover and attempted to address their congregations spontaneously. Some were so overcome with emotion that they could barely speak.
Something particularly remarkable happened at Congregation Shearith Israel, the oldest Jewish congregation in America. The rabbi recited the traditional Sephardic memorial prayer for the dead … for Abraham Lincoln! This was reportedly the first time that this prayer had been recited for a non-Jew. The congregation considered his contributions and his relationship with the Jewish community so extraordinary that it made an exception to its traditional practice.
In Philadelphia, the distinguished Jewish scholar and religious leader Isaac Leeser was asked to offer words of comfort to worshippers. He attempted to speak but found himself unable to organize his thoughts. He subsequently apologized, explaining:
“The dreadful news and its suddenness have in a great measure overcome my usual composure, and my thoughts refuse to arrange themselves in their wonted order.”
It is difficult to imagine a more human response to such an unexpected tragedy.
In Boston, Congregation Ohabei Shalom took formal action just one day later. Its members adopted a series of resolutions expressing their grief and outrage. They described Lincoln’s death as a calamity affecting not only America but the entire civilized world.
The congregation ordered that its synagogue be draped in mourning for 30 days. A memorial prayer was to be recited every Sabbath, as well as on Mondays and Thursdays. Members also agreed to close their businesses on the day of Lincoln’s funeral so they could observe it as a day of mourning. A copy of the resolutions was sent to Lincoln’s widow, Mary Todd Lincoln. One of the resolutions expressed the hope that Lincoln’s death would be the last sacrifice required to bring an end to the terrible war.
These were not simply expressions of political sympathy. They reflected a genuine sense of personal loss.
To understand the intensity of the Jewish reaction, it is important to appreciate Lincoln’s relationship with the Jewish community.
One of the most consequential episodes occurred in December 1862, when General Ulysses S. Grant issued General Order No. 11, expelling Jews from his military district, which included parts of several states. Grant accused Jews collectively of participating in illicit cotton trading and ordered them to leave.
The order was deeply antisemitic, punishing an entire religious group for the alleged misconduct of individuals.
Jewish leaders appealed to the president. Lincoln intervened, and the discriminatory order was rescinded in January 1863. For American Jews, this was an important demonstration that the president would not tolerate collective punishment based on religious identity.
Lincoln also supported legislation permitting Jewish clergy to serve as military chaplains. Previously, the position was restricted to Christian clergy, effectively excluding Jewish soldiers from having a chaplain of their own faith. The legislation of 1862 changed that policy.
Lincoln also maintained friendships with prominent Jewish Americans, including Abraham Jonas, a lawyer and political supporter, and Issachar Zacharie, a Jewish physician who became a trusted personal adviser.
At a time when Jews were still fighting for acceptance in American public life, Lincoln’s actions carried enormous significance. He treated Jews as equal citizens, deserving of the same rights and protections as their Christian neighbors. It is little wonder that his assassination was experienced as a personal tragedy by so many American Jews.
However, the most fascinating connection between Lincoln’s assassination and Passover might be the parallel between Lincoln and Moses.
Both men became associated with the liberation of an oppressed people. Moses led the Israelites out of Egyptian bondage. Lincoln, through the Emancipation Proclamation and his leadership during the Civil War, helped bring about the liberation of millions of enslaved Americans.
But there is another, more poignant parallel.
Moses led the Israelites through the wilderness, but he never entered the Promised Land. He died on Mount Nebo, able to see the destination but not experience the fulfillment of the journey.
Lincoln similarly helped bring the country to the threshold of a new beginning. The Union had been preserved, slavery was being abolished, and the country was beginning to contemplate reconciliation. But Lincoln would never live to see the nation rebuilt. He was murdered just as the war was ending, before he could guide the country through the difficult process of Reconstruction.
The comparison between Lincoln and Moses was particularly meaningful to Jewish observers, who understood the symbolism of a liberator who does not live to see the ultimate realization of his mission.
There is another biblical connection worth remembering. In Leviticus 25:10, the Torah declares: “Proclaim liberty throughout all the land unto all the inhabitants thereof.” These words, which became associated with America’s own ideals of freedom, are famously inscribed on the Liberty Bell.
For Jews celebrating Passover, the message of freedom was not an abstract historical concept. It was the central theme of the holiday they were observing that very week.
Finally, there is one additional detail about Lincoln’s final hours that has always intrigued me.
A popular story recounts that, on the afternoon of April 14th, just hours before he was shot, Lincoln was riding in a carriage with his wife, Mary. He was reportedly in a cheerful mood, relieved that the war was nearly over and looking forward to a more peaceful future.
According to one account, Lincoln told Mary that he wanted to visit the Holy Land and Jerusalem. The often-repeated quotation attributed to him is:
“We will visit the Holy Land and see those places hallowed by the footsteps of the Savior. There is no place I so much desire to see as Jerusalem.”
If authentic, these would be remarkable words, particularly given the timing of his death on Passover.
There is, however, an important historical qualification. The Jerusalem story comes from later recollections rather than a reliable contemporary transcript. Historians have questioned its authenticity, and it should not be presented as an established fact or as Lincoln’s actual final words.
On April 15, 1865, American Jews were confronted with an extraordinary historical irony. They were celebrating Pesach, the holiday commemorating the liberation of their ancestors from slavery, while mourning the death of the man who had helped bring freedom to millions of enslaved people in America.
The story reminds us that the Jewish experience in America has always been intertwined with the broader American struggle for freedom, equality, and religious tolerance.
There is something almost biblical about the timing of Lincoln’s death. On the very holiday when Jews recount how Moses led their ancestors from slavery to freedom, America lost the man who had helped emancipate millions of enslaved people.
Like Moses, Lincoln would not live to see the Promised Land of national reconciliation.
On April 15, 1865, American Jews mourned not only a president, but a man who had demonstrated that the ideals of liberty, justice, and religious equality were not exclusively Jewish or Christian ideals.
They were American ideals, too.
