As Campus Antismitism Burns, Jewish Faculty Cowers
Last week, the Undergraduate Student Government at Hunter College, a publicly funded university in New York City, canceled its planned “Cultural Arts Night” because Hillel was going to be included. In an appalling statement issued by the organization’s president and vice-president, they claimed they had failed by letting the event planning move forward while not keeping some of the decisions secret from organizers.
This blatant antisemitism is endemic to what is happening on college campuses both in the United States and around the world. Indeed, it can be argued that no institutions are more responsible for the international explosion of antisemitism than college campuses, and no group has done more to poison the minds of our next generation than those we trusted most to shape them, our collegiate faculties and administrators.
The examples now are endless. Most notorious in the United States of course was the December 5, 2023 hearing before the United States House of Representatives Education and Workforce Committee where the Presidents of Harvard, MIT and the University of Pennsylvania (my alma mater), could not confirm that shouting for the genocide of Jews violated the schools’ speech codes against “bullying and harassment”. The woman asking the questions, Congresswoman Elise Stefanik of New York, was shocked and horrified. How could a college president equivocate on a question like that?
And yet they did. Further, they and other college administrators hid behind spurious claims of free speech as entire areas of college campuses were called “encampments” and placed off-limits to those Jews who refused to renounce Zionism. Has any other minority or target group been banned from a section of campus unless it either renounces or swears allegiance to an idea? Of course not.
At its graduation ceremony is 2026, Derek Peterson, the outgoing President of the Faculty Senate at the University of Michigan, one of the world’s premier public universities, praised students who had engaged in anti-Israel protests as people who “opened their hearts to the injustice and inhumanity of Israel’s war in Gaza.” What did the Jewish faculty do? What have they ever done? Nearly always, they sat meekly on their hands. Any protest they might have made was quiet, perhaps dignified, and useless.
This has been a generational process. Since the turn of the century, college faculties have been culled of any voices that are not far left and “progressive”. At many schools, faculties play an oversized role in deciding which candidates might receive offers to join that faculty. Political orientation has become a litmus test. Aside from depriving our students of a truly complete education – how can you truly run a law school where every professor has the same political and jurisprudential philosophy? -this monopoly of the left on our faculties has meant that fewer dissenting voices are tolerated, that students who do not meekly accept the political dynamic force-fed them are belittled or required to self-censor, and that institutions become more malleable to those who choose to manipulate the license to “teach” instead to serve their own political ends.
During the most recent decades the concept of “intersectionality” gained traction among our intellectuals. This takes seemingly unrelated issues and combines them under a rubric of “progressivism” or other buzzwords. Due to this concept, it became necessary for anyone seeking employment at a university, or to advance within the collegiate ranks, to genuflect to institutionalized ideological conformity. Once anti-Israel feelings became part of the progressive mantra, our institutions of higher learning transformed into indoctrination factories for hatred of the one Jewish state. Not surprisingly, that quickly converted into blatant Jew hate.
One would have hoped and expected that our Jewish professors, and others who considered themselves “liberal”, would have recognized the danger, rallied to fight this, and been very vocal about it. One would have been wrong. Meekly accepting the ideological paradigm shift, and often grasping for justifications for it (Bibi is to blame, the Haredim are destroying Israel, the Palestinians are poor oppressed people kept down solely by evil Israel, etc.), our Jewish faculty and administrators not only have failed to fight this rapidly spreading antisemitism, they became almost unwitting accomplices to it. Now they look on in horror as basic Jewish life is blackballed on campus.
There is no easy solution, Anti-Jewish race hate has become so entrenched on campus that fighting it will be long and difficult. But fight it we must, and fight it our Jewish faculty and administrators must. They must be vocal, they must be public, they must be demanding and they must be unyielding. There certainly will be risk to their careers in doing so, but if they do not fight it there will be only a short time until their ability to even have careers in academia will come to an end.
After all, that is a story we have seen before.
