Choosing a high school is a parenting decision
I once picked up my daughter from a sweet 16 party in New York City at three o’clock in the morning.
That was Sunday morning, following a Saturday night that apparently required considerably more celebrating than I thought necessary. I cannot tell you what was on the menu. I can tell you that three in the morning gives a father plenty of time to reconsider his parenting decisions.
One of mine was allowing our oldest daughter to choose her high school.
Let me be fair. She received a very good education. My concern was the social life that accompanied it. Saturday night seemed to bring another party, another destination, and another late return. We had entrusted her with an educational choice and discovered that we also had signed up for a social calendar.
By the time our next three daughters reached that crossroads, my wife and I had revised the admissions procedure. Their views mattered. The final decision belonged to us.
With families now considering where their children will attend high school, I think that distinction deserves attention.
An educator put it rather neatly: Your children cannot even decide what they want for lunch, and you are going to trust them to choose a four-year high school program?
A little unfair to teenagers? Perhaps. But there is a point beneath the exaggeration. We ask young adolescents to weigh matters whose significance even adults can struggle to assess: academic standards, religious atmosphere, teachers, peer influences, and preparation for the years beyond graduation.
Then we act surprised when “my friends are going there” carries more weight than all of them.
I saw another side of this problem through a girls’ high school with which my family was closely involved. The school relocated from New York to Bergen County, encouraged by parents who had indicated that their daughters would attend.
When my family was closely involved with a girls’ high school in Bergen County, I often heard parents explain their choice of another school this way: Their older daughter attended, was having a wonderful time, and her younger sister wanted the same experience. That is understandable. But I sometimes wondered whose judgment was guiding the decision—and how much weight the educational program carried alongside the social attractions.
The same applies to sons.
I am not proposing four years of misery as a character-building exercise. Children should have friends, enjoy school, and feel that they belong. A student who feels isolated or overwhelmed may have difficulty learning, however impressive the school’s reputation.
Parents need to listen carefully. A child’s objection may reveal something an open house presentation missed. A learning need, an intimidating atmosphere, or a poor fit deserves serious consideration.
Listening, however, is part of deciding. It does not require surrendering responsibility for it.
For families choosing a yeshiva high school, the questions should reach beyond the college acceptance list and the enthusiasm of the student tour guides. What kind of Torah education will our child receive? Will teachers know when that child is struggling? What conduct earns respect among the students? Does the school’s understanding of Jewish life reflect what we are trying to teach at home?
And what will our son or daughter be prepared to do, and to become, after graduation?
There is no single right school for every child, including children in the same family. Parents must do the work of understanding the differences.
Our children deserve a voice in this conversation. They also deserve parents willing to make a difficult decision and explain it, even when the explanation is greeted with a sigh or the dreaded eye-roll.
We are choosing the people and the environment that will help shape them. That responsibility lasts considerably longer than a Saturday night.
Take it from a father who had time to think about it at three in the morning.

