Shuki Friedman

Delegitimizing Arab-Israeli Lawmakers Will Fuel Extremism

Even before the election, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, Likud, and their right-wing allies were campaigning to delegitimize Arab lawmakers and their voters. Since the results were announced, they have stepped up the campaign. At the swearing-in of the 26th Knesset, Netanyahu said there was no difference between Ra’am and the Joint List: they disagreed only over “what kind of state will rise here on the ruins of the Jewish state.” He called their members “supporters of terrorism who hate Israel.”
Meanwhile, claims spread that the Arab parties had stolen the election through foreign funding and vote-buying, prompting calls to invalidate votes or even hold a new election. The allegations are being investigated, as they should be, but they remain unproven. Regrettably, Shin Bet director David Zini has also questioned the legitimacy of the Arab vote in categorical terms, though the facts remain unclear. He reportedly spoke of vast sums flowing into Israel; the amounts now being cited are far smaller. He also sought to have all Arab party leaders questioned as criminal suspects, without reasonable grounds to suspect them of an offense.
This campaign comes at a heavy cost. First, it stigmatizes Israel’s Arab minority – roughly a fifth of the population – and effectively seeks to deny them a place in Israeli democracy. Yet the parties they elected met the legal requirements to run. Section 7A of Basic Law: The Knesset allows a party list to be barred if it rejects Israel’s existence as a Jewish and democratic state or supports armed struggle against it by an enemy state or terrorist organization. These parties ran lawfully. Those who declare them illegitimate replace legal standards with political populism.
Second, the campaign undermines the democratic process itself. If a citizen’s vote counts only when cast the “right” way, elections lose their meaning. Third, it tells Arab citizens that taking part in democracy is pointless, encouraging indifference toward the state and a reluctance to share responsibility for governing it. Voters who go to the polls expecting their representatives to tackle crime, housing, and education have chosen civic participation. A blanket rejection of partnership with Arabs tells them that path leads nowhere.
There is an additional risk. In a democracy, the political arena allows even views that challenge the government to be heard within the bounds of the law. When this space is closed off, some on the fringes of the silenced community may come to believe that dialogue and peaceful action offer no way to exert influence – that violence is all that remains. Violence is never legitimate, but the risk that someone will resort to it increases.
This is not a theoretical risk. According to Shin Bet data, Arab citizens of Israel carried out five significant terrorist attacks in 2025. The agency handled about 40 ISIS-inspired cases, while minors’ involvement continued to rise. In June of this year, a terrorist – a Tayibe resident – murdered one person and wounded five others in a shooting attack in the Sharon region. In May 2021, we also saw how quickly violence on the fringes could set mixed Jewish-Arab cities ablaze.
However, the same data reveals something else: these are fringe elements. Approximately 2.1 million Arabs live in Israel. They are part of everyday Israeli life and of the institutions at the heart of its society, government, and economy. The overwhelming majority do not turn to violence – even during difficult years of war. The political campaign of delegitimization, which labels them all as enemies, weakens this majority and strengthens the fringes.
One may decide not to form a political partnership with Arab parties at this time; that is a legitimate political choice. But that decision cannot rest on the wholesale rejection of Arab citizens of Israel and all their representatives in the Knesset. Any such decision must be based on the positions and actions of particular parties or individuals – not on national identity or the stigmatization of more than 20% of Israel’s citizens.
About the Author
Dr. Shuki Friedman is director-general of JPPI, the Jewish People Policy Institute, and a senior lecturer in law at the Peres Academic Center.
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.