Paul Rivlin
Software, memory and the Jewish calendar

Do the dead have privacy?

Anyone who builds a family tree ends up holding other people’s secrets. A great-grandmother’s second marriage, a child who appears in one census and never again, a cause of death written in a clerk’s hand. The people concerned cannot be asked. Most of them died long before anyone thought of asking.
European data protection law has a short answer to what we owe them. The GDPR, the European Union’s General Data Protection Regulation, gives it in one of its introductory clauses, Recital 27: “This Regulation does not apply to the personal data of deceased persons.” Once you die, your data stops being personal in the law’s sense. The recital’s second sentence leaves the door open: “Member States may provide for rules regarding the processing of personal data of deceased persons.” Some have: Spain, for example, lets relatives ask for a dead person’s data to be corrected or erased. But the default position of the most ambitious privacy law in the world is that privacy ends at death.
That is a coherent view. Privacy law protects people from harm, and the dead cannot be harmed in any way the law knows how to measure. They cannot lose a job, be refused insurance or be embarrassed at work. Whatever damage a revelation does lands on the living: on children, on descendants, on a family’s name.
Jewish law starts from a different place.

A name that outlives the person

In the laws of the days before Yom Kippur, the Shulchan Arukh records an old decree against giving the dead a bad name. The same chapter, 606, describes what a person does who has wronged someone who has since died. He brings ten people to the grave and says there, “I have sinned against the God of Israel, and against this man whom I wronged.” The obligation does not lapse because the other party can no longer answer.
The words matter. The decree, which the Shulchan Arukh attributes to “our early authorities” and backs with a cherem, forbids להוציא שם רע על המתים, giving the dead a bad name. Hebrew has separate terms for harmful speech. Motzi shem ra, the phrase the decree uses, is spreading a false report. Lashon hara is damaging speech that is true. Whether the decree also reaches true but damaging speech is a question for the commentators, and I will not settle it here. But the instinct behind it is plain: a person’s name lives on after them, and it can still be damaged.

Two different questions

The two traditions are answering different questions.
The GDPR asks who can be hurt. Its answer is the living, so it protects the living. Halacha asks what is owed, and to whom. Its answer includes people who can no longer claim anything for themselves. The dead have no rights the law can enforce on their behalf, but the living still have obligations towards them.
For most of history, the difference did not matter much. Information about the dead faded with the people who remembered them. A scandal lived as long as the neighbours did. Today a single document, once scanned and indexed, is permanent, searchable and a click away from anyone with an interest. The question of what we owe the dead has moved from the cemetery to the database.

What a family historian owes

This is a practical question for anyone doing genealogy, Jewish or not. Records that were closed for a century are being opened, transcribed and linked. A name in an old register can now be joined to a photograph, a court case and a living grandchild in an afternoon.
The law will rarely stop you from publishing what you find. The GDPR will not, unless your country has added rules of its own. The tradition asks something the law does not: before you share a fact about someone who cannot answer, ask whether it gives them a bad name, and whether anyone gains from it.
That will not always mean silence. History needs the truth, including the painful parts, and families often need it more. But there is a difference between recording that something happened and putting it in front of strangers. The first can be an act of memory. The second can be the kind of harm that halacha assumes the dead can still suffer.
Privacy law protects the living. Jewish law asks us to protect the names of the dead. A family tree is one of the few places where we have to do both.
About the Author
Paul Rivlin is a software engineer in Rehovot who has been building .NET applications since 2002. He spent five years running the website at Beit Hatefutsoth (now ANU, the Museum of the Jewish People) and six years in fintech support. He now runs Yanshuf Studio, where he builds his own products, among them Or Zarua, a Hebrew calendar and remembrance app.
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.