Every Jew
In September 2013, at the age of one hundred and forty-one, the American magazine Popular Science stopped accepting comments on new articles posted to its website, and its online editor Suzanne LaBarre justified the decision by citing a University of Wisconsin study in which just over a thousand Americans had read the same piece about nanotechnology, some with civil remarks beneath it and the rest with insults. Those who had seen the insults came away with a more polarized view of the technology’s risks, and the authors of the study had written in The New York Times that rudeness often changed how readers understood the article itself. The study merely suggested such an effect, and a critic would soon call it small, but the magazine concluded that if what came below could rewrite what came above, the prudent course was to leave nothing below.
On Tuesday, November 17, I watched a Brazilian on YouTube spend half an hour translating Israeli society for the average Brazilian with a clarity I seldom find among us, who live here and struggle to explain the country to ourselves. Then I scrolled down to the comments, and the hatred toward us that I found there frightened me more than the clarity had impressed me, because what comes below can rewrite what comes above, and whoever watched that video may have taken home less of the patient script than of the hatred that followed it, posted in a comment section that belongs to the whole world and that none of us can switch off.
The Brazilian Jew lives inside that comment section, according to the figures released in March by the confederation of the country’s Jewish communities, CONIB, which recorded nearly a thousand reports of antisemitism in 2025, close to three a day, eight in ten of them on social media. I think of Bom Fim, the Jewish neighborhood of Porto Alegre, in southern Brazil, where I spent my whole life until I made aliyah, and of the Jews there who have never voted in an Israeli election or worn the uniform of our army and who nonetheless run into that hatred on their phones and at their children’s schools, which respondents to a CONIB survey named as the place where antisemitism appears most often.
Those Jews are written into the first line of the Law of Return, passed unanimously on July 5, 1950, at a Knesset session timed to fall on the anniversary of Herzl’s death according to the Hebrew calendar, and that line says that every Jew has the right to come to this country as an oleh. Ben-Gurion made a point of telling the plenum that the law granted nothing to the Jew of the Diaspora and merely recognized a right inherent in him by the very fact of his being a Jew, and he added that this right had preceded the State and had built it. For two thousand years, the Jew’s place in the world had depended on the goodwill of whoever ruled where he lived, and the 1950 law replaced that goodwill with a door no foreign government can shut, which makes the State the main reason we go on existing as a people and makes each of us who vote here someone who also decides for millions of Jews who do not. If we forget this, the State will go on standing and will lose the purpose for which it was built, and I will no longer be able to say why it exists, I of all people, who came in through that door.
Behind that door, in late September, President Isaac Herzog visited the headquarters of the army division in charge of the West Bank, and on October 8 he wrote the prime minister and the defense minister a letter that became public only in early November. In it, Herzog stated that we were a step away from disaster, turned to the Book of Judges to recall that in the West Bank everyone did what was right in his own eyes, called Jewish nationalist violence organized crime and a moral stain on us, recounted that in Jalud, days before his visit, our soldiers had come within a hair’s breadth of firing live ammunition at Israeli civilians, and warned that dilemmas like that one could lead to civil war.
On November 10, as the members of the new Knesset were being sworn in, several hundred right-wing protesters were demonstrating outside, behind three rows of barriers guarded by armed Border Police officers, against what they called a betrayal of the soldiers, a government backed by the Arab-majority parties. A man who identified himself as Moshe and declined to give his last name explained to a reporter that in that case there would be civil war in the streets, and added, most politely, “Right now we are demonstrating here affably, politely and with respect. But it will become a civil war.” That same day, Itamar Ben-Gvir said, with all the authority of the minister in charge of the police, that the nineteen Knesset members from those parties, two of them Jews, supported Hamas and Hezbollah and needed to be thrown out, and announced that his party was proposing a law to strip anyone who was not loyal of the right to vote, while, inside, Netanyahu was calling for a national unity government in a speech that accused those same parties of seeking Israel’s destruction.
Jalud and the sidewalk outside the Knesset turned into video, the video crossed the ocean, and the hatred out there found in the hatred in here everything it needed to look reasonable, so that what was done here in our name reached Porto Alegre before dinner and the classroom the next morning, and in this way we have put at risk the existence of the whole people, both the Jew who lives here and the Jew who will never come. The civil war that the president raised as a risk and the protester offered as a promise would do the rest, because the door opened in 1950 would be of no use to anyone arriving if, on the inside, Jews were shooting at one another.
I know that hatred of Jews needs no help from us, and CONIB itself acknowledges that in Brazil antisemitism appears less as open hostility than as historical ignorance and tolerance of centuries-old stereotypes, a sign that the hatred below the video was already in place before 1948 and would outlive a flawless Israel. The State was born as an answer to that hatred, and an answer that hands its adversary fresh images and threatens to split from within ceases to be an answer; of the hatred and the answer, only the latter depends on us.
The stand we have to take has a deadline, since Gadi Eisenkot was given the mandate by the president on November 8 and has until early December, with the possibility of an extension, to put together a coalition. The government that emerges from these weeks, whoever its prime minister turns out to be, must begin where Herzog asked it to, treat the gangs that terrorize Palestinian villages as organized crime, and turn every instrument of the State against them, and it must also deny the threat made outside the Knesset the right to choose who may support it, because a country that yields to a politely promised civil war hands control to the man who promised it.
