Robert Huebscher

Harvard’s Blind Spot on Gaza

A discussion about alleged Israeli attacks on Gaza’s hospitals ought to examine the evidence that Hamas has used those hospitals for military purposes. Yet that evidence was absent from a November 9 panel hosted by Harvard’s Carr-Ryan Center for Human Rights.

Remarkably, Hamas was not mentioned once during the discussion.

The significance of that omission became clearer three days later, when an Israeli strike on Nasser Hospital killed Dr. Rizk Abu Shaaira, a surgeon featured in the documentary American Doctor. Israel said it had targeted a Hamas commander operating from the hospital.

The center’s director, Mathias Risse, subsequently published an article on the doctor’s death and the documentary. It offered another opportunity to examine the evidence the panel had overlooked.

Dr. Shaaira’s death was a tragedy. The competing accounts of the strike deserve scrutiny. Harvard’s responsibility is to provide both compassion and rigorous analysis.

I have previously criticized the center’s programming on Israel and Gaza.

The problems with the panel, Risse’s commentary and the documentary lie not only in what they presented, but in what they omitted.

The panel discussion

The panel featured three physicians – Dr. Thaer Ahmad, Dr. Rasha Khoury, and Dr. Feroze Sidhwa – and was moderated by Dr. Eman Ansari, a Palestinian and a pediatric emergency medicine physician at Harvard Medical School.  Ahmad and Sidhwa, along with Dr. Mark Perlmutter, were the three physicians featured in American Doctor.

The panelists repeated familiar allegations – genocide, apartheid, ethnic cleansing, blockades and sieges, racism, forced starvation and famine.  These have been challenged by multiple authors and researchers, such as here and here.  But those allegations were accepted as facts by the moderator, without any consideration of the contrary evidence.

More directly relevant to the panel’s stated purpose were its allegations about attacks on medical personnel. The panelists did not establish that the incidents they described reflected a deliberate Israeli policy of targeting healthcare workers, rather than attacks on alleged military targets that resulted in civilian casualties.

Hamas’s use of hospitals for military purposes has placed patients and healthcare workers at additional risk. The Israeli strike on Nasser Hospital three days after the panel illustrates why examining that conduct is essential. According to the Israel Defense Forces (IDF), the strike targeted Muhammad Abu Ismail, commander of Hamas’s Khan Younis Brigade. The IDF subsequently identified three other Hamas operatives whom it said were killed. Hamas said there were six people killed in the attack; it does not distinguish between terrorists and others.

The IDF said Hamas used the entire second floor as a command center, and access to it was restricted for patients.  The IDF said it had previously warned hospital officials about Hamas’s alleged military activities. It is not clear whether it issued an evacuation warning immediately before the strike. Whether the earlier warnings satisfied the applicable legal requirements is among the questions that require examination.

Evidence of Hamas activity at Nasser Hospital is not confined to Israeli military statements. Doctors Without Borders suspended noncritical operations in January 2026 after reporting armed men, intimidation, arbitrary arrests and suspected movement of weapons. A United Nations commission subsequently found reasonable grounds to believe that Hamas personnel had interrogated and mistreated Palestinian civilians inside the medical complex in 2024 and 2025.

The New York Times reported that Palestinian civilians said Hamas used the hospital for administrative purposes. Statements from former hostages document that they were held and tortured in the hospital.

These findings do not establish that the hospital was being used as a military headquarters when Israel attacked it in November. But they provide evidence that should have been examined by anyone assessing Hamas’s activities at the hospital.

Given the evidence of Hamas’s activities in hospitals, the moderator should have asked whether the panelists had witnessed armed activity or intimidation of patients and staff, and whether they had reported such incidents.

International humanitarian law affords hospitals special protection, but that protection is not absolute. Under the Geneva Conventions, a hospital can lose its protection if it is used to commit acts harmful to the enemy outside its humanitarian function, subject to requirements concerning warnings. Even then, an attack must satisfy the principles of proportionality and precautions to protect civilians.

Whether Israel’s attack on Nasser Hospital met those requirements depends on facts that remain disputed, including the nature of Hamas’s activities, the warnings provided and the anticipated civilian harm. Those questions should guide any subsequent inquiry into the strike. The broader question of Hamas’s military activities in hospitals, however, was relevant to the November 9 panel and deserved serious examination.

The panel’s failure to examine the broader evidence of Hamas’s military activities in hospitals cannot be justified. Risse was notified in advance of the discussion that one of the panelists, Sidhwa, “systematically and repeatedly lied about Hamas activities in Gaza,” including about activities in hospitals.  Why, then, did he allow the discussion to proceed without a moderator who asked questions that would challenge the panelists’ conclusions?

The discussion assigned Hamas no responsibility for its actions – for the war crimes of using hospitals as command centers and depots for storing weapons and ammunition.

Risse’s article and the movie

To his credit, Risse acknowledged the allegations that Hamas has used hospitals for military purposes: “The Israeli military and several human rights organizations have alleged that Hamas has done so in Gaza, and a human rights center should take that seriously and examine it, not look away.”

Risse’s acknowledgment makes the omission hard to explain. If a human rights center must investigate allegations of Hamas’s military use of hospitals, why did the panel he organized fail to address them?

Risse suggests that tunnels near or beneath the hospital would be unsurprising, given the extent of Hamas’s tunnel network and Gaza’s dense urban landscape. That misses the point. The IDF said it targeted Hamas operatives using the hospital itself, not tunnels beneath it.

The documentary itself warrants separate scrutiny, particularly its treatment of claims about Israeli intent. Risse lauds the movie as “a record of how Western audiences have been spared the sight of what is done with Western weapons.” He writes that the three physicians have “great integrity whose testimony seems fully credible.”

The physicians’ testimony about the suffering they witnessed deserves to be heard. But there is an important distinction between documenting injuries and establishing responsibility for them. A doctor who treats a wounded child can testify authoritatively about the child’s injuries. Determining whether those injuries resulted from a deliberate attack on civilians, an attack on a military target or another cause requires additional evidence. The film does not adequately make that distinction.

While Risse cautions viewers to keep in mind that many of the claims in it are contested, that is not enough.

Risse cannot call the physicians “credible” without mentioning their well-established biases. Ahmad has accused Israel of genocide and apartheid and that it is waging a “war on children.” I have previously written about Sidhwa and documented the false claims he has made against Israel.  He has written anti-Israel propaganda since 2007 and has edited work by Norman Finkelstein, an outspoken critic of Israel whose rhetoric is often antisemitic.  Perlmutter, in a now-deleted post on X, equated Zionism with Nazism. He also stated that Hamas represented just 0.1% (about 200 people) of the Gaza population.

The film’s director, Poh Si Teng, began filming in 2024 after already stating that Israel was committing genocide. Her public position raises questions about whether she approached the documentary with an open mind or sought evidence to support a conclusion she had already reached.

The movie has been criticized for giving “insufficient attention to the circumstances that led to the war in the first place or the responsibility that Hamas has for so much pain and suffering. That lack of important context means the film is, fundamentally, a prosecution of Israel – and its biggest weakness is the part of the story it leaves out.”

Like the controversial film NAZA, American Doctor presents claims that are unverified or cannot be verified by independent sources, such as deliberate targeting of children. Critics have pointed out that the film provides no verifiable timestamps, locations, or details regarding the specific incidents – leaving viewers without evidence of how, when, or by whom victims were killed.  This is especially important because, according to an October 2023 report by the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, approximately 10% of rockets launched by Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad malfunctioned and landed in Gaza.

What Harvard left out

The same weakness runs through the panel, Risse’s commentary and the film: evidence that might complicate their account receives insufficient attention.

The greatest failure of the Carr-Ryan Center is not that it has criticized Israel. Criticism of Israel, like criticism of any government, is entirely appropriate when supported by evidence.

The failure is its unwillingness to subject allegations against Israel to the scrutiny that serious scholarship demands. Evidence concerning Hamas’s activities in hospitals cannot be dismissed merely because it complicates the narrative.

The purpose of a human rights center is not to decide in advance who is guilty. It is to discover what the evidence shows.

Harvard should know the difference.

About the Author
Robert Huebscher is a resident of Lexington, MA. He has been an entrepreneur over the last 40 years. In 2007, he founded Advisor Perspectives, which then became the most widely read newsletter by financial advisors.
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.