Has America Lost Its Edge as Freedom’s Defender?

For decades, the United States proudly held the title of “Leader of the Free World,” a beacon of liberty and justice in a tumultuous world. But as I read George Gilder’s recent article, “Israel: Leader of the Free World,” I can’t help but wonder: has America lost its moxy? Where is the bold, unapologetic commitment to defending freedom that once defined us?

Gilder’s article is a poignant reminder of what true leadership entails. He argues that Israel, through its unwavering dedication to self-governance, innovation, and resilience, has emerged as the new leader of the free world. This shift raises unsettling questions about the current state of American leadership.

Historically, the United States was not just a powerful nation—it was the embodiment of liberty. We stood up to tyranny, whether it was on the beaches of Normandy, in the jungles of Vietnam, or during the Cold War standoffs. Our commitment to freedom was non-negotiable. But today, as Gilder points out, that commitment seems to be wavering. Our stance on Israel and its enemies has become increasingly equivocal. We tolerate antisemitic violence within our borders, and our resolve to confront global threats is often questioned.

This isn’t just a matter of foreign policy; it’s a matter of identity. America’s leadership was never about dominance—it was about ideals. The defense of freedom, the belief in self-governance, and the willingness to stand against oppression were our guiding principles. Yet, in recent years, it feels like we’ve lost sight of these values. Have we become complacent? Are we too inwardly focused, or simply weary from the burdens of leadership?

Gilder’s critique is a wake-up call. If America is to reclaim its role as the leader of the free world, we must renew our commitment to the principles that made us great. We must demonstrate, through action and not just rhetoric, that we still believe in the cause of liberty. This means standing firmly with our allies, like Israel, who share our values and fight the same battles we once led.

The question of whether the U.S. has lost its desire to defend freedom is not just academic—it’s existential. The world is watching. If we falter, if we equivocate, the mantle of leadership may pass to others who are willing to uphold the values we once championed.

Israel’s rise as a global leader should inspire us, not intimidate us. It should remind us of what we once were and what we can be again. But it requires introspection, courage, and a recommitment to the ideals that made America the land of the free and the home of the brave.

The defense of freedom is not just about military might or economic power—it’s about moral clarity and the courage to lead. As Gilder eloquently suggests, if we are to remain free, we must pass the Israel Test. The question now is: are we up to the challenge?

Reference:

Gilder, G. (2024, August 14). Israel: Leader of the Free World. RealClearPolitics. Retrieved from https://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2024/08/14/israel_leader_of_the_free_world_151445.html