How Do We Measure What Was Lost?
What Greenwood Lost and What Repair Can Restore
Companion essay to Ceteris Paribus Never Applied
A burned house can be counted. What the family might have done with that house over the next thirty years is harder to measure. It might have sold the property, borrowed against it to start a business, or passed it to a child. It might have stayed and used its savings to send that child to school. Each possibility matters. None appears on an inventory of what burned.
The seven-part series Ceteris Paribus Never Applied ended with a principle: a remedy should follow the mechanism of harm. Tulsa’s Greenwood district puts that principle to work. The destruction of a house, the expense of finding temporary shelter, and the loss of a customer base can all begin on the same day. Each leaves a different kind of evidence. Each also asks something different of anyone trying to repair the damage.
The fire and the fight to rebuild
Oklahoma’s legislative findings, drawing on the state commission’s investigation of the 1921 Tulsa Race Massacre, record the destruction of 1,256 homes and much of Greenwood’s commercial and institutional property. The commission put property costs at approximately $2 million in 1921 dollars. The legislative findings also report that Black property owners received no insurance payments for the homes or personal property they lost. For owners trying to rebuild, the missing insurance payments mattered immediately. They had lost their property and would have to find another way to finance its replacement.¹ law.justia.com
The city added a barrier when it applied a fire code that would have made rebuilding too expensive for most individual property owners. B. C. Franklin, I. H. Spears, and T. O. Chapelle encouraged residents to begin rebuilding and promised legal help if they were arrested. The lawyers successfully challenged the city. Greenwood residents went on to rebuild with little outside investment or support. Their achievement belongs in the accounting because it shows what residents could do once they overcame a barrier the city had placed in their way. It also raises a question about what they had to spend or give up to do it.² Oklahoma Historical Society
What a family spent to get back home
Consider a family whose $10,000 house is destroyed. It spends $10,000 from savings to build an equivalent house. Once it moves in, it again has a house and has $10,000 less in savings than it would have had if the original house had survived. Adding the full replacement bill to the full value of the destroyed house would count the same injury twice. Any additional lodging costs during displacement belong in a separate part of the accounting. Those were costs the family would have had no reason to incur if it had been able to stay home.
Now consider another owner whose house was worth the same amount. The owner still has the lot but lacks the savings and credit to rebuild. The property inventory records the same loss for both households. One now has a house and depleted savings. The other might keep paying rent while looking for financing, or sell the lot and move. If we want to understand why the two households ended up in different places, we need to know what resources each could draw on after the fire.
Then consider the family that rented the house next door. The building would appear in the owner’s property claim. The renters might have lost their belongings and faced moving costs or higher rent elsewhere. A payment based on the value of the building would go to the owner. The renters’ losses would have to be established through other evidence. The question of who gets counted therefore depends on what we are counting.
The commission’s $2 million estimate gives us a historical dollar figure for property damage. An inflation adjustment expresses that sum in another year’s purchasing power. Compounding it at an assumed return answers what the money might have grown to if it had been invested under specified conditions. A family trying to replace a home, pay rent, or reopen a business would have had reasons to spend some of that money immediately. Its lost opportunity includes the choices it could have made with resources it now needed for recovery.
What depended on the neighbors
A grocer deciding whether to reopen would want to know how many customers were coming back. A family deciding whether to return would want to know where its members could work and shop. Both could be ready to rebuild and still have good reason to wait. The value of reopening a store or returning to a house depended in part on whether other people could afford to make the same decision.
That is one way the destruction of a district can affect people beyond the value of their own property. A merchant can replace a storefront and still lose customers who relocated. A worker who owned no property can lose a job if the business never reopens. Those losses call for different evidence. Payroll records might show a period without work. Business records might show a decline in sales. And if the appraisal of a destroyed business already reflects its expected earnings, an additional claim based on those same earnings would require care to avoid counting them twice.
What a comparison can tell us
Comparing Tulsa in 1920 with Tulsa in 1930 captures the massacre along with everything else that changed over the decade. Alex Albright and his coauthors use census data to make a more informative comparison. They examine changes for Black and white Tulsans alongside changes for Black and white residents of other cities. The other cities help account for trends affecting Black households more widely. The comparison within Tulsa helps account for local changes affecting residents of both races. The researchers test other sets of comparison cities, though Tulsa’s two pre-massacre census observations give them only one decade to check how outcomes were changing beforehand.³ jamesfeigenbaum.github.io
The researchers estimate that school enrollment among Black children in Tulsa declined by an average of 2.5 percentage points following the massacre, from a pre-massacre level of about 80 percent. They also find that adverse effects on Black homeownership persisted for decades. Black workers in more skilled occupations were more likely to leave in the years after the massacre. The authors estimate that the resulting change in who lived in Tulsa was too small to account for the direct effects they measured. They suggest that the departure of skilled workers and entrepreneurs may also have weakened later economic growth.³ jamesfeigenbaum.github.io
The enrollment finding shows what a population estimate can add. A property inventory can record a destroyed school building. Census evidence can help establish that fewer children were enrolled than we would have expected without the massacre. To determine which child missed school, for how long, and with what consequences, we would need more evidence. Even without a defensible estimate of lost lifetime earnings for each child, the decline in enrollment belongs in an account of the damage.
What repair can reasonably do
A payment for a destroyed house can be judged by whether it compensates the owner for the property taken away. A rebuilding program can be judged by whether people who want to return can finance construction and afford to stay. Assistance for displaced renters calls for evidence of where they lived and what displacement cost them. If the goal is to restore a commercial district, we would also want to know whether businesses can stay open and whether residents can use the services those businesses provide.
Greenwood’s legal victory gives us a concrete example. The lawyers helped remove a rule that stood between residents and the homes they wanted to rebuild. The measure of that victory was what it made possible. What followed still depended on what families could afford and whether enough of their neighbors could return. A remedy can succeed at what it was designed to do while leaving another injury to be addressed.² Oklahoma Historical Society
Return to the family whose house burned. We may never know whether it would have borrowed against the house, sold it, handed it down, or stayed put. We can look for evidence of what the family owned, what it spent to get back home, and what stood in its way. We can also ask what its neighbors needed to return, because some of the family’s choices depended on theirs. That is what Greenwood adds to the argument of Ceteris Paribus Never Applied. The conditions that make a comparison fair also deserve attention when we design a remedy. If the harm changed what families were able to do, the test of repair is what they are able to do afterward.
Endnotes
- Oklahoma Statutes, tit. 74, § 8000.1, findings 2–3, drawing on the final report of the 1921 Tulsa Race Riot Commission. Legislative findings.
- Oklahoma Historical Society, “The Aftermath,” especially “Land Issues.” Historical account.
- Alex Albright, Jeremy Cook, James Feigenbaum, Laura-Thorne Kincaide, Jason Long, and Nathan Nunn, After the Burning: The Economic Effects of the 1921 Tulsa Race Massacre, working paper, July 23, 2025. Full paper.
