Human Problems Deserve Human Attention
“Well then you’re not going to like what I’m about to tell you,” my study-partner John said yesterday during our monthly phone-visit. I’d been expressing worry about over-reliance on online-life because of how it’s rewiring our brains and hearts. I’d just finished quoting a favorite maxim: I’m in favor of treating people more human, not less. Adding, “I want a live human being to answer the phone when I have a problem I need help with.”
John went on to tell me about a growing trend in corporate customer-service. More and more, callers are asking human beings to transfer their call to an AI agent for help. Why? Several reasons, many of them good reasons. The AI agent has all the relevant data. Instantly. It can readily share how others have resolved the problem they’re having. By contrast, the human customer service agent may need to look-up and follow-up with questions they don’t have answers to. Although they’re friendly, they may be vague about what to recommend. So the AI agent saves you time and grants you more knowledge. No wonder it’s becoming more preferred.
Except when it’s not. Another fellow-learner in our community added a thought. She said, maybe it depends on the kind of problem you’re looking for answers to. If it’s an insurance claim, or a broken appliance, the AI agent may be your best bet. But if it’s a knotty issue that’s turning you into an emotional pretzel, then a caring human-being you trust is going to be much better.
This week’s portion of Torah specializes in such knotty human-nature problems. Jacob notices, after his twelve children are born, that his father-in-law Laban’s manner toward him had changed, “he didn’t look upon him as he had been” (Gen. 31:2). God tells him to return home with his family. Yet even a warning from God isn’t sufficient to keep Laban from making trouble for Jacob (Gen. 31:24). Noticing the difference between how somebody’s seeing you. And Laban’s jealousy and hyper-transactional nature. These subtleties and traits require more than data-driven solutions.
And you never know where and from whom you may discover capabilities you didn’t know you had in you. I recently read a reflection from a Pakistan-based Muslim journalist, Sabin, that brought this home. She’d participated in one of Anilla Ali’s important Missions to Israel. You may have met Anilla on the Haviv Rettig Gur podcast this week.
Sabin writes, “I met an old man, a Holocaust survivor, who spoke fluent Urdu. He had lived through humanity’s darkest cruelty, yet he held no bitterness. Instead, he radiated empathy, contentment, and a strange serenity that made my grievances feel small. In his eyes, I saw the possibility of the triumph of resilience and the power to carry pain.”
Human problems deserve human attention. May you grant some and get some in the days ahead.
