International Pressure Will Help Save Zionism
The UK government’s sanctions this week on companies promoting construction in the settlements had real effects. Shortly after, the publication of tenders for the E1 project was frozen until a new government is formed, and Minister Smotrich’s maneuver to create facts on the ground before the new government is in power was thwarted.
Canada and Australia have already joined the initiative. In Israel, many see the move as blatant interference. I see it as help that we desperately need.
Most Israelis do not know what E1 is. E1 is not just another neighborhood of Ma’ale Adumim. The project is intended to cut between the northern part of a future Palestinian state and its southern part and to disconnect it from East Jerusalem, its designated capital. In other words, it is an obstacle deliberately built to thwart any political horizon.
The recognition of a Palestinian state by European countries also sparked anger here. Some saw it as a reward for Hamas for October 7, while others argued that it is a decision that only the Israeli government is entitled to make. Even my friends, supporters of the two-state solution or at least separation, tell me that external pressure is harmful and that Israel should decide for itself.
I understand the argument, and I reject it.
Zionism was meant to help us take responsibility for our fate and not wait for the world to decide for us. But the fate of the Palestinians is not an internal Israeli matter, just as Ukraine’s sovereignty is not a Russian internal matter, regardless of Putin’s claims about Kyiv as the “cradle of Russian culture.”
According to international law, Israel’s internal affairs stop at the Green Line, as does Israeli law, except for annexed East Jerusalem. This issue has dramatic global implications for other peoples. This issue has dramatic global implications for the entire Middle East, Europe, and the interests of the United States.
Moreover, international recognition of a Palestinian state is essential to save both peoples from a bloody bi-national reality. This situation is the greatest threat to the Zionist vision, greater than Iran and its proxies.
International recognition of a Palestinian state is not a prize for Hamas or Smotrich, because both oppose the two-state solution, which the international community promotes.
Recognition strengthens the Palestinians who support the diplomatic solution and will eventually convince most Israelis, who do not see the leadership coming from Israeli politics and believe it is an impossible solution.
The recognition of a Palestinian state will become a reality the moment the United States joins, as it is the last permanent member of the United Nations Security Council that has not yet recognized Palestine. A Security Council resolution turns international consensus into reality.
I would prefer that Israel itself lead the initiative: a demilitarized Palestinian state as part of a historic regional agreement that it offers us. In the current political reality, this will not happen. Therefore, external pressure is not only legitimate but also necessary. History teaches us this lesson.
Most Israelis supported the peace with Egypt, despite the concession of Sinai and the evacuation of the settlements. But Begin’s government did not initiate this peace. It was born of American pressure that began with Kissinger and ended with Carter and of Sadat’s willingness.
Willingness like Sadat’s on the Palestinian issue has existed for years despite Israeli rejectionism: the Arab Peace Initiative has been on the table since 2002, and the PLO recognized Israel within the 1967 borders with land swaps long ago.
Peace with Jordan occurred because Secretary of State Baker forced Shamir to attend the Madrid Conference, enabling Clinton to help Rabin reach an agreement later.
What is currently lacking is effective international pressure. The British government under Prime Minister Andy Burnham and his Jewish Foreign Secretary, Ed Miliband, is showing other countries the way.
In my opinion, the Burnham administration is the most Zionist government in London since the Balfour Declaration, because it is determined to act and does not hesitate in the face of manipulative accusations of antisemitism or political flattery to anti-Israel voters.
Anyone who claims that Britain’s steps to save the two-state solution and promote humanitarian aid for Palestinian families in Gaza, who are facing winter in tents due to anti-Israel sentiment, is being willfully misled. These are steps that are beneficial not only for the Palestinians but also for Israel.
French President Emmanuel Macron also deserves credit for recognizing a Palestinian state and for his move with Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, which led many other countries to do the same.
The most effective pressure of all, from the United States, is still missing. But there is room for optimism. In the Democratic Party, a major shift is taking place: its leadership understands that the unqualified support given to right-wing governments in Israel has harmed American law, interests, and values.
Most American Jews understand this shift as well. They understand that such a move is also in the interest of the democratic nation-state of the Jewish people and for them as Jews in their places of residence.
When the American pressure arrives, it will not be against Zionism. It will be to save it.

