Is Our Judaism Portable?

Chabad of Venice, Italy

A colleague, Rabbi Jonathan Gross served as a rabbi in Omaha, Nebraska for close to a decade. Nebraskans, as you may know, take their football and their home team – the Huskers – very seriously. And so, it wasn’t unusual that someone from the local community posted the following question on the rabbi’s blog: “Is it permissible to hang a Nebraska Huskers banner in my Sukkah, and can I watch the Husker game in my Sukkah?”. The Rabbi answered yes to both questions “if that’s what you normally do in your home”. The rabbi went even further, explaining that if those were activities normally done in his home, then he should hang the banner and watch the game in the Sukkah because, for the week of the holiday, our Sukkot are supposed to become our true homes.

The Talmud famously tells us: tzei mi-dirat keva: “go out from your permanent home” vehikaneis le dirat aray – “and enter into your temporary home”. Recreate the atmosphere of your regular home in this temporary hut ,which is why the Shulchan Aruch instructs us to not only to eat in the Sukkah but to also sleep in it, bring one’s nicest things into it – treat it like your real home, hang your banner, watch the game.

But why should we relate to something which is clearly a temporary dwelling as our permanent home? Why not simply treat the Sukkah for what it truly is – a dirat aray- a temporary hut? Does not the halacha disqualify a Sukkah that is created in a permanent way? If so, the Sukkah should be treated as the transient dwelling it is. We can visit it and even recite the Kiddush inside its flimsy walls, but not live in it. The Torah however commands us basuccot tayshvu – to live in our Succot as we do in our permanent homes all year.

Which is it? Are our Succot temporary dwellings or our real homes to live in as we do our permanent ones?

Rabbi Dr. Norman Lamm, zichorana livracha, taught that the Sukkah comes to symbolize the wandering Jew in exile, going from place to place, trying to make his home in someone else’s country – in another people’s culture. The secret to surviving in another nation’s land, suggested Rabbi Lamm, is to fill our Sukkahs – to imbue our foreign surroundings wherever we find ourselves – with our Torah values and unique way of life. This approach to the Sukkah is illustrated by the well- known halacha that a Sukkah constructed on a boat, train or wagon is valid because Torah can be observed anywhere and everywhere.

Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch offered a similar explanation as to why the Torah was given in the wilderness and not in the holy land of Israel: although Israel is the ideal place for the Torah to be practiced, it is not the only place. Revealing the Torah in the wilderness, Rav Hirsch asserts, shows the Torah was meant to be observed anywhere in the world.

To me, this is how Judaism has survived to this day. One Succot I was privileged to spend the holiday with my brother and his family – together with my sister in law’s Grandma Blanca, of blessed memory. At the time, Grandma Blanca was 99. She had fled Germany in 1936 when she was just a teenager. She watched as my wife observed the mitzvah of the minim, benching over the Lulav and Etrog in the Sukkah.  My wife turned to Grandma Blanca and asked if she would like to perform the mitzvah herself. Grandma Blanca was not an observant woman, so she was at first reticent but, at the same time, I saw she was excited. She took the Lulav and Etrog and before reciting the blessing, pulled the Etrog closer to smell its beautiful fragrance. As she breathed in the scent of the Etrog, she immediately began to cry and blurted out: “we had such a nice life until Hitler”. She continued to cry.My wife tried to be of some comfort telling her: “Grandma Blanca: Hitler is gone, but we are still here”. Grandma Blanca composed herself and together they made the bracha and shook the Lulav.

It was a powerful moment I will never forget for it symbolized the great success of Jewish history and continuity. In my mind, the Jewish people still exist and thrive because we still shake a Lulav and Etrog – because we still practice our Judaism. We have survived centuries of persecution because we have learned to maintain our traditions in whatever culture or country we find ourselves. We exist as a vibrant community in America today because of our grandparents who carried their Jewish traditions from Europe. We owe a debt of gratitude to those who did not toss their Tefilin off the boat when they came to these shores and to the many Jews who, despite not being raised with much Yiddishkeit in their childhood, nonetheless have embraced their Jewish heritage. They are the reason we remain a strong and vibrant people.

The British Historian Arnold Toynbee said that what the world can learn from the Jew is how to live in the diaspora. He foresaw a time when minorities and ethnicities will no longer live in their native countries and would be challenged to preserve their culture in other people’s lands. The holiday of Succot, suggested Rabbi Lamm, possess the secret to any people’s continuity – transporting one’s unique identity to new and foreign cultures.

Perhaps that is why the prophet Zechariah speaks of non-Jews one day observing the holiday of Succot and being punished if they do not. Rabbi Lamm suggested that the punishment of extinction is simply the natural consequence of not learning the lesson of the Sukkah: to transport one’s values to a new culture. If a given minority fails to retain their own heritage in whatever new environment they find themselves, they will quickly lose their identity and eventually they will cease to be.

And therein lies the fundamental idea behind the Ushpiezen, the special guests (Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Joseph, Moses, Aaron and David) whose spirit visit our Sukkahs every day of the holiday. Each personality of the Ushpeizin, suggested Rabbi Lamm, symbolizes the idea of surviving spiritually in an alien setting: Abraham was told “Lech Lecha” – to leave his birthplace and travel to an unknown place. Isaac, although he remained in the same place his entire life, was made to feel almost like stranger in his own home, never understood by own his wife and children. Jacob was forced to run from his brother Esau for fourteen years, all the while carrying on the traditions of his father Isaac. Joseph was sold into slavery by his brothers and lived out his life in a foreign country, but somehow maintained the demut yonko- the image of his father and the values of his family. Moses, before he rose to greatness, also had to flee from Pharaoh and hide out in Midian for many years. Aaron – at the most critical juncture of his life, was left alone to lead the people when Moses ascended Har Sinai to receive the Torah. Finally, David spent much of his life running from various enemies, Jewish and non-Jewish alike.

Each member of the Ushpizen was forced to manage in a foreign environment but they all maintained the traditions of their forebears. All brought their unique Jewish values and lifestyle with them, no matter where they went.We are no different today. We send our children off to college where staying Jewish is challenging. Our work and careers often place us in environments less than conducive to Jewish values. With the rising numbers of young men and women becoming more observant than the rest of their families, many do not have parents or siblings who share their new founded passion for Judaism.  How do we conduct ourselves on campus, at work, or when we are with our own friends or family who may be less observant or have a different outlook on life? Do remain proud of our heritage or do we make excuses for our religious observance so we can fit in? Are we trying to inspire others to follow in the ways of Torah?

All these situations require us to ask ourselves: are we living the lesson of the Sukkah? Are we bringing our Torah to these all these places, demonstrating that Jewish values apply everywhere – not only in the synagogue or Beit Midrash, but to all parts of our existence?In my 25 years of engaging our less affiliated brothers and sisters in Jewish life, I have found this aspect of Judaism to be its most compelling feature: that the Torah pertains to every part of our lives. Recently I was having lunch with an MJE participant – Josh, a Ph.d/MD student in medical school. Although Josh’s Judaism consisted only of a Pesach Seder and Yom Kippur services, he has since become more committed to Torah observance because of his fascination with Jewish medical ethics. The whole idea that Judaism pertains to what he does professionally was such a turn on for him. He had no idea that the Torah had anything more to do with his life than what he saw at the Seder table or in synagogue on Yom Kippur.

I shared with Josh a powerful teaching by the great Jewish judge, Rabbi Dayan Grunfeld: Three of the four sections of the Shulchan Aruch deal not with ritual law – with how we pray or celebrate the holidays, but rather with how we confront everyday life. The Choshen Mishpat section of the Shulchan Aruch deals with torts, property law and contracts, namely, how we handle power. Even Ha’ezer contains laws pertaining to marriage and divorce, ie-relationships and Yorah Deah focuses on food (Kashrut) and laws sexuality (Nidah). Three of the four sections of the Code of Jewish law deal with how we approach the basic human drives for power, food and sex. Only one of the four sections of the Shulchan Aruch, namely, Ohr Hachayim deals with ritual law – the laws of prayer, holidays, Shabbat etc. The majority of Jewish tradition pertains to everyday life. Judaism has as much to do with what happens in the marketplace, the kitchen, and the bedroom as it does the synagogue. Yiddishkeit was never meant to be confined to shul. Like the Sukkah, the Torah was meant to be brought into every part of our lives, into everywhere and anywhere we find ourselves. The vessels of the Tabernacle were carried on poles so they could be taken from place to place. However, once the holy vessel – be it the Menorah or the Altar, was brought to its resting place to be used as part of the service, the poles would then be removed until it was time for it to be transported again. This was the case for all the vessels of the Tabernacle except for the Ark of the Covenant to which the Torah prohibits: lo yasuru mimenu – “Do no remove the poles”. Why were the carrying poles permanently affixed to the Ark and why is the Torah so emphatic that Ark’s poles never be removed? Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch suggests that because the Ark housed the Tablets representing the Torah and the Torah must be portable. The Torah must be ready at a moment’s notice to be brought to wherever it is needed, be it in the workplace or on college campus.

I truly believe this is how we – the Jewish people, are still here. The secret to Jewish continuity is the secret of the Sukkah – never to allow the Torah to be confined to any one place but instead applying it to all facets of human existence.

If we can meet that challenge, we will not only have learned the lesson of the Sukkah but we will also  have fulfilled our mission to be an Ohr l’goyim, to bring the light of Torah to all people and to all places.

Chag Sameach

About the Author
Rabbi Mark Wildes, known as The Urban Millennials' Rabbi, founded Manhattan Jewish Experience (MJE) in 1998. Since then, he has become one of America’s most inspirational and dynamic Jewish educators. Rabbi Wildes holds a BA in Psychology from Yeshiva University, a JD from the Cardozo School of Law, a Masters in International Affairs from Columbia University and was ordained from Yeshiva University. Rabbi Mark & his wife Jill and their children Yosef, Ezra, Judah and Avigayil live on the Upper West Side where they maintain a warm and welcoming home for all.
Comments