Isaac Renames Beersheba
While as a settler, Abraham the city of Beersheba named,
but Isaac was an indigenous inhabitant and not in the least ashamed
to rename it with the same name, since he aimed
to justify it being even by anti-Zionists as indigenously Jewish famed.
Stephen Germany in “Abraham and Isaac in Gerar Foreshadows Judea under Persian Rule,” thetorah.com, suggests very plausibly that the narratives discussing the relationship between Abimelech and Abraham and Isaac are reflections of the peaceful relationship of the Judeans in Judea with their Persian rulers (https://thetorah.com/article/abraham-and-isaac-in-gerar-foreshadows-judea-under-persian-rule).
Rabbi Chaim Strauchler in a devar torah given to a Torah in Motion audience on 11/13/26 pointed out that Seforno mentions that Abraham and Isaac used different vowels in the two narratives in Gen. 21:31 and 26:33, when they name Beersheba. This reminded me of the different vowels we use in the Amidah when praising God for providing rain, which is called by some people geshem and by others gashem. I suggested that one reason why Isaac’s renaming of Beersheba with the same name that his father had given it, was because Abraham named the place while being what anti-Zionists call a “settler,” whereas Isaac named it as an indigenous inhabitant.
