Israeli Enough? Ask the Miami Boy
While hundreds of thousands of reservists left their families and jobs, Yair Netanyahu stayed in Miami. Israeli reservists criticized him for remaining there while more than 300,000 troops were being called up. One of them told The Times that Yair was enjoying life on Miami Beach while he himself was on the front line.
He wasn’t there because of the war, since he had moved to Miami months earlier, but the war didn’t change his plans. He stayed. According to reports, he lived in a luxury apartment costing $5, 000 a month, while his father sought to increase the security funded by Israeli taxpayers. While soldiers fought and Israelis were evacuated from their homes, the public purse kept serving the life of a 32-year-old overseas.
And now, from that safe distance, he explains to us who is “Israeli enough.” In a post published overnight between Saturday and Sunday, he called for removing Arabic from all official signs and documents, writing that Arab citizens who are Israeli enough for child allowances “can be Israeli enough” to read Hebrew. That is how someone writes whose only qualification for being Israeli is his last name.
It is worth remembering who those Arabs were on October 7. Bedouin soldiers, who are Muslim, were among the first to arrive on the scene as terrorists attacked the communities and army bases of the western Negev, fighting alongside Jewish soldiers. Osama Abu Asa, a Bedouin guard at the Nova festival, was killed trying to protect young people hiding in a shelter, believing Hamas would not kill him because he was Muslim.
Twenty-one Bedouin were murdered that day, along with five more Arab Israelis from the north, and Arab Muslims were also abducted to Gaza. Anyone who asks whether they are “Israeli enough” should look at the graves and the casualty lists. As a Bedouin IDF commander put it, Hamas made no distinction and killed Bedouin and Jews alike.
The Muslim Soldiers Fighting for Israel
The status of the Arabic language and the Nation-State Law can be debated seriously. It is a legitimate debate, with supporters on the right. But what Yair Netanyahu offers is not a debate. It is a cynical one-liner in a tweet, meant to inflame rather than persuade. He presents Arab citizens, a fifth of the population, as a burden collecting “benefits, ” rather than as citizens who pay taxes, treat patients in hospitals, and live in communities that also endured the rockets and the attacks. And as always, he does it without paying any price.
This is not an isolated case. In the first weeks of the war, he was already sharing clips and headlines from abroad that placed the blame for the massacre on the judicial system, the IDF and the Shin Bet. According to an analysis by The Seventh Eye, about 39% of his Telegram posts looked like an attempt to fend off criticism of his father. That is the pattern: push the blame far from home, find a new enemy, and divert the discourse into internal conflict.
timesofisrael
And that home is his father’s home. The massacre of October 7 happened on Benjamin Netanyahu’s watch, after years in which he headed the state. To this day he refuses to publicly take responsibility for the failures that led to the massacre, leaving the inquiry for after the war. After so many dead, so many hostages, shattered families and burned communities, that responsibility has not stayed with the man at the top. It has been passed to the IDF, the Shin Bet, the judiciary and anyone else a finger can be pointed at, and the son is the amplifier of that propaganda online. These are the hallmarks of the Netanyahu era: many dead, ruin and devastation, and a man who evades responsibility to this day.
timesofisrael
Anyone who wants to see a “machine of poison and division” need not look far. The social media accounts of a prime minister’s family member are a tool for stoking conflict, and others pay the price. Public criticism of these tweets is not “incitement against the family.” It is a response to a man who never carried the burden, yet doesn’t hesitate to preach to others.
Even his way back home was not especially impressive. The Shin Bet confirmed that Yair was returned to Israel from Miami following a significant threat to his life. In other words, even when he came back, it happened after the threat arrived, not out of a choice to join the rest of Israelis.
timesofisrael
Israel will not be stronger if we erase a language from signs. It will be stronger if those who speak in its name are willing to bear some of the burden they demand of others.
