Goldie Warshawsky Klugman

It’s hard to believe that there is one question that makes all the difference

There’s a question, and please correct me if I’m wrong, that is not posed in Gaza to the suffering Gazans nor to any members in the Israeli Arab parties – Mansour Abbas, Achmad Tibi, or in the UN or The Democratim (our Left) or even in Haaretz,(Leeor Mehakel, Ofri Ilani) despite the never-ending wail about Arab injustice, e.g., from either Arabs or what we call our Israeli Left, why? No reporter working in Gaza, Amanpour, Francois Picard and our own Trump, the outside world of Media etc etc; certainly not Mamdani or even Edward Said as far as I know, said
“tell me, looking back do you regret not agreeing to the partition of Palestine in the 1947 UN vote? Do you think it might have been a mistake?” It is not asked of Jordan, Egypt, Qatar etc? Why avoided?

In my mind we have to know this before making our moves- it’s an answer every Jew is entitled to- we must close the gap between those still floating on abstractions….about human nature, ignorant of past politics and events and and reality….for at this moment we’re weak disparate groups fighting within about the answer and nothing more; for as told to me by too many Israelis, “if we said to them….we’ll give you everything else and we’ll just take Tel Aviv….they’d say No”. This is what the Likud says. The rest of us are asking how true this is ..Are there changes taking place among our opponents because of the costs of war? Ask! We have to Ask! And the answer must be YES, we’re tired of war.

About the Author
I am a lecturer of American Government, and the history of Liberal movements. I have 2 Masters Degrees, one is from New York University: " Women's Liberation and the Media"; and the other is from Tel Aviv University: "The Comparison of Hannah Arendt and Nachman Syrkin on the subject of Antisemitism". I've been activist in the U.S. Democratic Party and Meretz, Shalom Achshav for many years and currently involved in HaDemocratim; there isn't a Liberation activity that I haven't been part of both in Israel and New York: Equality, Anti-War, Battered Women, Early Childhood Education
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.