Must Politicians Be Willing to Forgive?
Recently, 60 Minutes produced an unusual interview of Donald Trump. The interviewer, Russ Douthat, decided to confront him with the fact that the President had narrowly escaped death a few times at the hands of would-be assassins. Wondering if that had affected the man who so boldly and frequently mentions his unforgiving nature regarding his enemies, Douthat posed this: Upon leaving this world and in the presence of the “judgment throne of God,” assuming that all that was necessary for the President to enter “Paradise” would be a willingness to forgive his enemies, could he do that. Trump responded that he is a “religious person” but said that “in being real,” he actually couldn’t forgive the likes of James Comey and Nancy Pelosi: “I do hate some of my enemies and I always will” for what they had done to him.
I actually found Trump’s remark here to represent the punctilio of honesty on his part – particularly given his arguably gratuitous statement that he is “a religious person.” Indeed, an unwillingness to forgive seems to be the antithesis of what Christianity teaches as a bedrock principle of the religion, a matter commonly understood even among those who don’t practice that religion. (Lest it go unsaid, for a whole variety of reasons I’m certainly not in a position to challenge the President over his views on this issue).
And why is it a bedrock principle? At Calvary, at the very last moments of Jesus’s life on earth, as he hung from his crucifix he said: “Father, forgive them for they know not what they do.” As his very life was leaving him, Jesus was forgiving his totally unapologetic executioners (or any others who had sinned in connection with his torment and fate). Although that particular act of forgiveness was, one would think, specific to Jesus, the Christian Bible sees it as teaching—and emphasizing—the concept to all Christians who have been the victims of offense by others.
Christianity’s view of the duty of forgiveness differs somewhat from Judaism’s. In Judaism, the duty to forgive another individual specifically only arises when the offender repents or apologizes and thereby overtly seeks to be forgiven. If someone is offended and the offender is essentially unwilling to recognize or even deal with what they have done or is outright impervious to the harm caused, the offended party is not required to do anything to forgive the offender. However, if the offender comes forward in regret with sincerity and earnestness, the offended person must then forgive him or her, hard as it might be to do so.
What if the person holds a grudge and won’t forgive? Interestingly, the offended person does not hold all the power. According to the Talmud, if the offender seeks to apologize three times – an odd, random number – and the offended party declines the three overtures, the offended person now becomes the sinner who is labeled “cruel” in having rejected a person’s sincere and earnest attempt to offer an apology. Maimonides, the great medieval Jewish philosopher articulated that that this “sinner” status is imposed on the person who actually started out as the “victim” of wrongdoing seemingly regardless of how small or devastating was the original offense he suffered.
As I see it, the question posed to the President was actually somewhat unfair. He was being asked about his political enemies in the context of an interview of him as president. If, for example, he was attending church services after his presidency was over and was asked whether he would forgive his enemies while he was at the precipice of an afterlife, I suppose it would be fair to ask him if he would forgive a counterparty in a business or personal dispute. But to be asked on worldwide television, while still in office, whether he will someday forgive his political enemies might actually have political consequences for him: the “enemies” might see him as willing to forgive them and potentially take political advantage of that willingness.
Yes, it would be interesting to see how his supporters particularly in the Evangelical community might have read his unwillingness to forgive even when wanting to gain entry to Paradise. But expecting most of our politicians to honestly express whether they have a forgiving nature, especially in sight of the judgment throne of God, is probably shortsighted indeed.
Again, though, Trump is known to be a dealmaker, as he so often likes to tell us. Would he present a different account to God, denying a willingness to forgive his enemies when the gates of hell are also open? We probably know the answer. The only problem with him reversing his course at that critical moment in his existence would be God’s undoubted capacity to lie-detect those facing both Door 1 and Door 2 – if you know what I mean.
The other thing is this: while the citizenry certainly would want our politicians to be morally based individuals, how politicians relate to their supposed religious obligations or the afterlife is not typically seen as particularly important. Politicians often have enemies – meaning those with whom they have fought politically over time. It’s the nature of the political beast. And a politician saying he would withdraw his grudge at or near life’s end might theoretically make him more vulnerable while still in office – almost suggesting that he isn’t as firm in his political position while at that status.
True, perhaps we might want politicians who are less likely to almost endlessly hold a grudge even to the end of their lives, but it’s not typically the reason why we vote for or against them. Russ Douthat’s intriguing question was, yes, interesting. But so was Trump’s honest, revealing and, frankly, almost expected answer.
But would their exchange really matter to the general electorate, even if Trump were himself up for reelection?
