“New York Times Helped Spread a Blood Libel Against Israel”
If someone not familiar with the egregious coverage of Israel by The New York Times through the years started reading Times stories after October 7, it would not be surprising if they concluded the editor in charge of news coverage was a member of Hamas.
But the paper’s scurrilous reporting on Israel is hardly new. The anti-Israel posture of The Times has been constant and the chastisement of Israel on the editorial pages –- well before October 7 –- seldom failed to condemn the Jewish state no matter the issue or policy involved.
The debasement of Israel had its beginning when Arthur Hays Sulzberger, the Jewish publisher of the paper, opposed the establishment of the State of Israel in 1948. And, as one writer put it, his anti-Israel, anti-Jewish feelings “trickled” down to the staff through the years.
But now, with Gaza, it has outdone itself with its distorted coverage of the Israel-Hamas war, which, according to the Israel’s Ambassador to the U.S., Yechiel Leiter, is paving the way for another genocide of Jews.
Speaking recently at the 43rd International Conference of Chabad-Lubavitch Emissaries, Leiter minced no words. I will let Leiter speak for himself.
“There is no difference between what is being done to us today and what was done to our grandparents in the ghettos of Europe 800 years ago.
“This is a blood libel. This is very serious. We have to know how to identify what the enemy is and who the enemy is. This is not another antisemitic rant. Please understand, this is a blood libel, and a blood libel will cost lives. And the reason why they are accusing us of genocide is to prepare the next genocide against us.
“The New York Times had helped spread a blood libel against Israel, and the motivation behind accusations of genocide against Israel is to prepare the next genocide against us.”
He described how he met with editors at The Times a year ago. “I went into a room. They were the jury. They were the judge. They were the firing squad — 15 editors with another six on the screen. And they were accusing me. They were accusing the government of Israel, they were accusing chayalei tzahal [the soldiers of Israel] of a genocide, of starving people to death.”
Leiter said he presented the editors with facts: the number of trucks carrying humanitarian aid entering the Gaza Strip every day; how soldiers risked their lives to protect non-combatants; and how the combatant-to-civilian ratio in the war was the lowest in modern history.”
In response, he said, “they gave me feelings.”
Leiter said one editor objected by saying “everybody can’t be wrong.” He replied that “not everybody is wrong. Not everybody thinks that we’re committing genocide. To the extent that everyone does think so,” Leiter added, “it was The Times that was responsible.”
He said he cited as an example a July 2025 Times report titled “Gazans Are Dying of Starvation” featuring a photo of Mohammed Zakaria al-Mutawaq, an 18-month-old Palestinian from Gaza. Mohammed was emaciated.
“Anybody who saw the picture immediately thought of the Holocaust,” Leiter said. “So now we were the perpetrators of genocide. Once we were the victims, and now we’re the Nazis.”
What The Times had neglected to mention, Leiter stressed, is that the boy suffered from a genetic disease, cerebral palsy and other illnesses. The Times also cropped from the photo the boy’s perfectly healthy brother.
(Such a photo of a suffering child could have been published of any one of the millions of children in war zones –- Yemen, Sudan, Haiti, etc. But The Times decided to use one involving Israel).
“The senior editor of The New York Times said to me, ‘Ambassador, don’t you think you’re making too much of a misappropriation?’ I said ‘No, that’s not a misappropriation. That’s a blood libel.’”
(Here are two examples of what the editor considers “misappropriation”: Palestinian prisoners were raped by dogs and “The horrific abuse inflicted on Israeli women on October 7 now happens to Palestinians day after day.” These uncollaborated “misappropriations” were in a piece by Political Columnist Nicholas Kristof.)
Leiter continued: “Hitler didn’t just happen; it was decades of preparation of demonizing and delegitimizing Jews. And now through the State of Israel, through the Jewish state, there is an attempt to delegitimize and disenfranchise Jews as Jews.
“We have to call it for what it is. We have to identify the problem. And we have to fight it. We fight it by knowing who we are. We fight it by knowing who our friends are. And we fight this by knowing who the enemy is and by identifying them as the enemy and calling them out as the enemy.”
Given Leiter’s reference to the Holocaust, a word about The Times’ coverage of the worst crime against humanity in history.
The paper basically “ignored” the severity of the annihilation as documented by Laurel Leff in her book Buried by the Times, The Holocaust and America’s Most Important Newspaper.
She reports how the paper minimized history’s worst genocide by underplaying the atrocities and the “real story” was hidden from readers. She wrote that major stories about the Nazis’ slaughter of Jews were placed in back pages near “soap and shoe polish ads.”
Leff and others also pointed our The Times avoided describing the victims as “Jews.” In discussing the tragic story of the Warsaw Ghetto, the paper reported that “500,000 persons were herded…” into the ghetto and “400,000 persons” were deported to Treblinka, a concentration camp. The word “Jew” was not used.
Some 50 years later, Max Frankel, then Times executive editor, acknowledged the paper’s inexcusable reporting on the Holocaust, calling it “the century’s bitterest journalistic failure.” On The Times’ 150th anniversary in 2021, in a piece under the headline, “Turning Away from the Holocaust,” he wrote:
“And then there was failure: none greater than the staggering, staining failure of The New York Times to depict Hitler’s methodical extermination of the Jews of Europe as a horror beyond all other horrors in World War II — a Nazi war within the war crying out for illumination.
“The Times drowned its reports about the fate of Jews in the flood of wartime news. Its neglect was far from unique and its reach was not then fully national, but as the premier American source of wartime news, it surely influenced the judgment of other news purveyors.”
One more example, from my files, of The Times’ inexcusable not-so-subtle bias in which I was involved. In 1997, a Times reader, Sherman Miller, of Longwood, Florida, sent a letter to the paper in which he charged its coverage of alleged torture by Israel and Palestinians was “uneven and lacked professional integrity.” He said he was surprised by the distortion from a paper which is “supposedly the bastion of actual reporting.”
He received the following reply from then news editor, William Borders:
“The whole point is torture by Israel, a democratic ally of the United States, which gets huge support from (the U.S.) is news. Torture by Palestinians seems less surprising. Surely, you don’t consider the two authorities morally equivalent.”
Miller replied to executive editor, Joseph Lelyveld (top dog), arguing that if Borders’ premise were true, then Palestinian attacks (such as a bombing in Jerusalem) would not be covered because they came from an “amoral authority” which is “absurd and “an insult to the intelligence” of readers.”
I wrote a column on this exchange in which I accused the paper of having a “double standard.” After my column appeared, Lelyveld wrote me a letter in which he said, with my charge I was “mangling language” and the accusation was “incredulous.” He denied “we (The Times] have had a dual moral standard.” I invited him to speak to my journalism ethics class at Wayne State University to discuss the issue. He never accepted the invitation.
The major point is that Israel is probably facing the worst crisis since its founding in 1948. And Jews around the world are being vilified as they were in Germany in the 1930s. But this time the vilification is world-wide.
The damage that The New York Times has done, given its power and reach, is irreparable. Moreover, given its “prestige” in the world of journalism, many in the media simply follow its lead, compounding the libel.
Sadly, to hope that Leiter, in his session with the paper’s editors –- 21 of them –- touched their journalistic conscience is probably in vain.
(Berl Falbaum is a veteran journalist and author of the recently published book, The Media’s Defamation of Israel: A Critique of the Israel-Hamas War News Coverage).
