On The Journey to the Land
Parshat Behaalotecha and the Eternal Struggles of the Jewish Soul
The wilderness was not just a desert. It was a place of formation. A testing ground. A raw, unforgiving stretch between slavery and sovereignty, between memory and mission. Parshat Behaalotecha picks up this journey, and if we listen carefully, we hear echoes of today.
A Nation in Motion—But Toward What?
Moses pleads with his father-in-law:
“We are journeying to the place of which the Lord said: I will give it to you…” (Numbers 10:29)
This is not a suggestion. It’s a statement of destiny. The people of Israel are not wandering aimlessly—they are heading somewhere, even if they don’t fully understand the destination. This distinction matters. A wandering people lose themselves. A journeying people remember their purpose.
In our time, Jews are again journeying—not just physically, as many return to the Land of Israel—but spiritually and morally. In the face of October 7th, global cynicism and ideological confusion, we are journeying toward light, toward meaning, toward God.
The Menorah: Lighting the Way from Within
The parsha opens with Aaron being commanded to light the Menorah, a task both sacred and symbolic. The Menorah faced inward, with all flames directed toward the central shaft—a reminder that unity, clarity, and centeredness must precede illumination.
Today, as Israel faces war, misinformation, and rising antisemitism, the Menorah speaks again. We cannot rely solely on the world to shine light on truth. We must light our own candles, kindle the sparks of tradition, and shine with moral clarity from within.
The Tabernacle After the Fall: Rebuilding Trust After the Calf
Behaalotecha takes place after the devastating sin of the Golden Calf. Despite the breach, God reaffirms His presence. The Mishkan—the Tabernacle—is completed, a dwelling place for the Divine. This is more than ritual; it is reassurance.
The message is timeless: even after profound failure and betrayal, God does not give up on His people. The process of repair is part of the journey. For a people constantly called to a higher purpose, this is not a loophole—it’s a lifeline.
Pesach Sheni – The Sacred Second Chance
Among the laws in this parsha is the establishment of Pesach Sheni, a second opportunity to offer the Paschal sacrifice for those who were ritually impure during the first. This Torah of Second Chances is profound. The Torah offers restoration, not rejection.
What other nation encodes divine flexibility into law? It tells us: holiness is not perfection. You missed it? Come again. You were unready? Try anew.
A chance to remember. A chance to reorient. A chance to repent.
In a world obsessed with cancellation, unforgiving judgment, and moral puritanism, Judaism offers a counter-narrative: people change, and they deserve the space to do so. Perhaps today, it’s not just individuals, but the entire world that needs a Pesach Sheni. A chance to do better. To return to the truth.
We live in a world that is morally confused—where truth is blurred, history is rewritten, and Jews are once again scapegoated. The moral compass has tilted. Good is called evil, and evil parades as good.
In such a world, the idea of a second chance is not weakness—it is divine mercy. And it is urgent.
When the Ark Moved: A Journey of Spirit and Defence
Each time the Ark sets out, we declare:
“וַיְהִי בִּנְסֹעַ הָאָרֹן, וַיֹּאמֶר מֹשֶׁה: קוּמָה יְהוָה, וְיָפֻצוּ אֹיְבֶיךָ; וְיָנֻסוּ מְשַׂנְאֶיךָ, מִפָּנֶיךָ.”
“And when the Ark travelled, Moses said: Arise, O Lord, and let Your enemies be scattered; and let those who hate You flee from before You.” (Numbers 10:35)
This ancient cry is still sung in our synagogues as we take out the Torah. It’s not merely a liturgical moment—it is a declaration of survival. We still carry the Ark.. We still face enemies. We still walk through a world that often hates what we represent.
This verse is a call to courage: the journey is sacred, but never safe. As Jews today are again scattered, vilified, and attacked—from college campuses to the halls of diplomacy—this prayer feels like a heartbeat of our people.
The Complaints Begin: Year Two and the Myth of Egypt
A year after leaving Egypt, the complaints begin in earnest. The people long for the food of slavery:
“We remember the fish that we ate in Egypt for free; the cucumbers, the melons, the leeks, the onions, and the garlic…” (Numbers 11:5)
Memory can be selective. Pain can be romanticised. Slavery can seem safer than freedom. Today, too, voices are longing for exile, for appeasement, for simplicity—even at the cost of dignity. They forget that the cucumbers of Egypt came with chains.
Freedom is hard. Responsibility is heavier than onions. But it is the burden of purpose.
Leadership, Jealousy, and the Eternal Scapegoat
Miriam and Aaron speak against Moses. We don’t fully understand their motive—perhaps jealousy, perhaps concern—but the moment is telling.
In every generation, Jews have been scapegoated. Whether in medieval Europe, Nazi Germany, the Arab world, or Western academia—when there is confusion or crisis, the Jew is the easy target.
It is no coincidence, then, that this parsha embeds the verse:
“Arise, O Lord, and let Your enemies be scattered; and let those who hate You flee from before You.”
The Torah links Jewish survival to Divine justice. Haters of Israel are, at their root, haters of God’s project.
Reclaiming the Jewish Narrative
Last week, I attended a lecture by Dr. Einat Wilf at the Shalem Centre in Jerusalem. Dr Wilf was a left-wing member of the Knesset who saw the light and is a strong advocate and articulate speaker, defender of Israel—a rational voice in this crazy world.
As I articulate in my blogs, the Torah narratives from Abraham, in this parsha and many other verses, demonstrate the connection between Judaism and the Land. To say that Judaism can be separated from Zionism is a misconception. I know many Jews believe this, but the Bible was written over 3,000 years ago, which makes it clear that there is a connection.
This is reinforced by Dr Wilf, who powerfully articulates:
“The Jewish people are not just a religion. We are a people—with a land, a language, and a mission.”
To deny this is not only dishonest—it is dangerous.
Wilf reminds us that the constant effort to redefine Jews as a religion without a homeland is an erasure of Jewish identity itself. And attacks on Zionism are not about borders—they are about denying Jews the right to be a people among peoples, a sovereign among sovereigns.
The world needs a second chance to hear that truth. To stop rewriting our story. To stop scapegoating the people who’ve carried moral light through the world’s darkest deserts.
And So, We Continue the Journey
The wilderness is not over. The threats are not gone. The complaints still echo.
But we are still moving.
We are journeying to the Land.
And we are not alone.
We carry our Ark.
We light our Menorah.
We speak our truth.
We pray our ancient words:
“Arise, O Lord, and let Your enemies be scattered; and let those who hate You flee from before You.”
And we carry not just the memory of slavery, but the vision of redemption.
Not just the pain of exile, but the promise of destiny.
Not just our past, but the second chance the world still needs.
—
Additional Readings
I also wrote two blogs this week, which I shared on Substack – I invite you to read and follow me on Substack.
Greta, You Didn’t make it to Gaza or Saudi Arabia, but welcome to Israel
A suggested tour of Israel for Greta
https://upgradingesg.substack.com/p/greta-you-didnt-make-it-to-gaza-or
Would the World Be a Better Place Without Jews?
The Utopia After the Jews — A Thought Experiment for a Controversial Year
https://upgradingesg.substack.com/p/would-the-world-be-a-better-place
