Political Power Is an Economic Asset
CETERIS PARIBUS NEVER APPLIED — PART IV
Why comparisons of economic mobility must account for voting, representation and public protection
A deed establishes ownership. Whether officials defend that ownership depends partly on institutions—and on the owner’s ability to make those institutions respond.
The previous essay examined how racial violence destroyed wealth, constrained competition and altered investment decisions. It ended with a question: What enables threatened owners to obtain protection and hold officials accountable? This essay examines one part of the answer: the capacity to vote, organize, influence government and demand enforcement of rights.
Political power cannot guarantee prosperity. It can affect whether people have a fair opportunity to build wealth—and whether what they build survives.
That consideration is often missing from a familiar comparison. An immigrant arrives with little money, works hard, saves, buys a home, educates children and enters the middle class. The story may be true. The difficulty begins when it becomes a universal test: If one disadvantaged population advanced, why did another not do the same?
A family’s achievement deserves recognition. Using it to explain another population’s outcomes requires examining whether the relevant conditions were comparable.
The comparison considered here concerns particular European immigrant communities and their descendants who gained influence within American urban political institutions. Their experience cannot represent every immigrant population. Immigrants differed in citizenship, racial classification, education, resources and opportunities. Black Americans and immigrants are overlapping populations as well.
The narrower question is still consequential: What changes when political access becomes part of the explanation of economic mobility?
Irish American history offers an example. The Library of Congress describes how growing electoral influence helped Irish Americans build political machines that assisted constituents with employment, naturalization and emergency necessities such as food and heating fuel. In Boston, Hugh O’Brien’s election as mayor in 1884 marked a milestone in that political ascent. These networks connected community organization to resources that could stabilize family life. Library of Congress
That achievement followed substantial hardship. The National Park Service documents the poverty, religious hostility and employment discrimination Irish immigrants encountered in Boston, alongside their eventual emergence as an influential political constituency. Recognizing their later access to government does not diminish the adversity they overcame. It helps explain one institution through which they overcame it. nps.gov
Political power here means the practical capacity to organize, influence public decisions and hold officials accountable. Voting is central, but the capacity also includes representation, durable organizations, coalitions, legal advocacy and access to the agencies that implement decisions.
Its economic effects take different forms.
Equal protection concerns whether officials defend property, enforce contracts and investigate coercion. Public investment concerns where government directs schools, transportation and infrastructure. Patronage concerns preferential access to jobs or benefits through political relationships.
These should not be treated as interchangeable. Protection from violence is a right, not a favor. Fair access to public employment differs from rewarding loyal supporters. Political machines could provide assistance while also practicing corruption, coercion and exclusion.
Equal protection should never depend on political connections. Historically, however, communities differed in their ability to demand it and impose consequences when officials withheld it.
That difference belongs inside the economic explanation.
A stable public job can provide wages, benefits and retirement security. Transportation can connect workers to employment and businesses to customers. Public contracting can create revenue for firms. School investment can expand children’s opportunities. Decisions about zoning, sanitation and infrastructure can affect the usefulness and value of property.
These mechanisms do not establish that political influence explains every successful household. They establish why an account centered on work and thrift must also examine the institutions shaping their returns.
Black Americans understood these relationships and organized accordingly. Part II examined Wilmington, North Carolina, where Black residents held office, operated businesses and supported institutions capable of challenging established authority. The 1898 white supremacist coup attacked political and economic independence together: officials were forced from office, the Black-owned newspaper was destroyed and residents were terrorized and expelled. North Carolina’s official historical account documents the forcible seizure of government and destruction of the newspaper office. www.dncr.nc.gov
The additional lesson for this essay is that the relationship ran in both directions. Economic resources could support political organization. Political organization could help defend economic resources. Attacking either could weaken the other.
Black communities did not simply fail to acquire influence. They sometimes acquired it and then faced organized campaigns to dismantle it.
Across the post-Reconstruction South, poll taxes, literacy tests, intimidation, economic retaliation and violence restricted Black voting. Political exclusion reduced the ability to challenge officials and influence the allocation of public resources.
The Voting Rights Act of 1965 attacked major components of this system. According to the National Archives, approximately 250,000 new Black voters had registered by the end of that year, one-third through federal examiners. Registration expanded the population to whom elected officials could be held electorally accountable. www.archives.gov
Registration alone, however, does not demonstrate an economic effect. For that, we need evidence about what government subsequently did.
Economists Elizabeth Cascio and Ebonya Washington examined changes following the act. They found that counties with larger Black population shares in states that had previously used literacy tests experienced greater increases in voter turnout and state transfers than comparison counties in states without those tests. Their research supports the proposition that expanded voting rights changed the distribution of public resources. It does not establish that voting eliminated household wealth disparities. doi.org
The distinction matters. Enfranchisement expanded participation; the research identifies changes in resource allocation following that expansion. Together, they provide evidence for a mechanism through which political inclusion could alter economic opportunity.
Outside the South, the institutional barriers often took different forms. Access to the ballot did not ensure equal access to public employment or responsive government.
Boston provides a concrete example. In Castro v. Beecher, Black and Hispanic applicants challenged police recruitment and hiring practices. Litigation established that entrance examinations used in 1968–1970 were discriminatory, leading to requirements for a nondiscriminatory, job-related examination and remedial hiring procedures. A pathway to public employment was governed by rules that applicants successfully challenged through collective legal action. law.justia.com
This case does not prove that unequal hiring resulted solely from inadequate electoral influence. It demonstrates something more specific: formal political rights could coexist with discriminatory administrative practices. Making institutions respond required organization, litigation and enforcement.
The immigrant comparison therefore needs to ask more than whether two populations valued education or worked hard. Could they enter public employment on fair terms? Could they influence investment decisions? Could they challenge discriminatory rules? Did officials face consequences for ignoring their claims?
A comparison that leaves political access unexamined has not established that the relevant conditions were comparable.
A reasonable objection follows: Black Americans subsequently elected officials and gained influence, yet substantial economic inequality persisted. How much can political power explain?
The answer requires distinguishing representation from control.
Winning office does not necessarily confer control over budgets, administrative implementation or decisions made by other levels of government. Municipal officials operate within state and federal rules. They cannot independently determine regional employment, lending practices or the resources households already possess.
Political influence can also be fragmented, poorly exercised or directed toward narrow interests. Constituents may disagree about priorities. Officials may fail to deliver. These possibilities require scrutiny rather than an assumption that representation automatically produces economic gains.
There is also a difference between protecting future opportunities and replacing earlier losses. A community that obtains fairer access to employment has gained something substantial. Families previously excluded do not thereby receive the wages, pensions or savings they might otherwise have accumulated.
Greater political inclusion can improve future prospects while leaving earlier injuries unrecovered. Establishing the size of those losses—and whether particular remedies are justified—requires additional evidence.
The argument is therefore neither that political exclusion explains every disparity nor that political inclusion guarantees equal outcomes. Political power is an economic asset because it can affect the security, opportunities and public resources available to people pursuing economic goals.
Productivity, saving and entrepreneurship matter. So do the institutions governing whether their returns can be earned, retained and transferred. A convincing explanation examines their interaction.
The family that advances through determination deserves credit. Understanding that achievement also requires asking how public institutions supported, obstructed or protected its efforts. The same questions must be asked of families whose work produced fewer lasting assets.
Political power cannot guarantee prosperity. It can influence whose property is protected, whose claims receive a hearing and whose neighborhoods receive investment. Any comparison of economic mobility that omits those differences leaves a major part of the explanation unexamined.
The next question is how public authority and private interests worked together to distribute those protections—and their costs.
Sources
- Ed Gaskin, “When Black Success Became a Threat”, The Times of Israel, Part II.
- Ed Gaskin, “When Violence Becomes Economic Policy”, The Times of Israel, Part III.
- Library of Congress, “Irish Identity, Influence and Opportunity”.
- National Park Service, “President John F. Kennedy and the History of Irish Immigration in Boston”.
- North Carolina Department of Natural and Cultural Resources, “1898 Wilmington Coup”.
- National Archives, “Voting Rights Act (1965)”.
- Elizabeth U. Cascio and Ebonya Washington, “Valuing the Vote: The Redistribution of Voting Rights and State Funds following the Voting Rights Act of 1965”, The Quarterly Journal of Economics 129, no. 1 (2014): 379–433.
- Castro v. Beecher, 386 F. Supp. 1281 (D. Mass. 1975).
