Re: An Open Letter to House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries
How Many Times Has Palestinian Leadership Rejected a Two-State Solution?
At your November 12 press conference, you urged dramatic change regarding the United States’ position on Israel, repeating the familiar goal of “a safe and secure Israel living side by side as a Jewish and democratic state with an independent Palestinian state.”
Most Americans favor that outcome in principle. The historical record shows why it has not occurred: Palestinian leadership has repeatedly refused to accept a permanent Jewish state.
- 1937, The Peel Commission. Britain proposed splitting the land into a Jewish state and an Arab state. Jewish leaders accepted the principle of partition. Palestinian Arab leaders rejected it.
- 1947, The UN Partition Plan. The United Nations voted to create two states, one Jewish and one Arab. Jewish leaders accepted. Palestinian leaders and surrounding Arab states rejected the plan and went to war to prevent Israel’s creation.
- 1964, The Palestinian National Covenant. The PLO adopted its founding charter, declaring Israel’s creation “entirely illegal” and calling for the end of Zionism. Later efforts to cancel the relevant clauses were incomplete and never produced clear acceptance of Israel as the nation-state of the Jewish people.
- 1967, The Khartoum Resolution. After the Six-Day War, Arab states adopted the “three nos”: no peace with Israel, no recognition of Israel, and no negotiations with Israel.
- 1993 to 2016, The PLO and Mahmoud Abbas. Yasser Arafat’s 1993 letter recognized Israel’s right to exist in peace and security but did not accept it as the nation-state of the Jewish people. Mahmoud Abbas has been explicit. In 2014 he said, “We will never recognize the Jewishness of the state of Israel.” In 2016 he added, “I will recognize the State of Israel… However, a Jewish state is not my affair. I will not recognize it at all, and I will not accept it.”
- The Demand for a “Right of Return.” Unlike other refugee populations, Palestinian refugee status is transmitted through generations. Roughly 700,000 people were displaced in 1948; UNRWA now registers nearly 6 million descendants. Demanding that large numbers settle inside Israel rather than in a future Palestinian state would end Israel’s Jewish majority by demographics.
- 2000, The Camp David Summit. President Clinton and Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak offered a Palestinian state on the vast majority of the West Bank and Gaza with arrangements for a capital in East Jerusalem. Arafat rejected it without a substantive counteroffer and refused to accept an end to the conflict.
- 2005, The Gaza Withdrawal. Israel removed every soldier and civilian from Gaza, granting full Palestinian control. Hamas seized power, used the territory as a rocket base, and carried out the October 7 massacre. Israeli public support for a Palestinian state fell sharply afterward and fell further after October 7.
- 2008, The Olmert Proposal. Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert offered Abbas a connected Palestinian state on roughly 93–94 percent of the West Bank (with land swaps), all of Gaza, and significant arrangements in Jerusalem. Abbas did not accept the offer.
- 1988 to 2024, Hamas. Hamas’s 1988 Covenant vows that Islam will “obliterate” Israel. In 2011, Mahmoud al-Zahar said Hamas “would never recognize Israel.” In 2024, Ghazi Hamad stated: “We do not believe in a two-state solution. We will never recognize Israel.”
Israeli forces regularly dismantle Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad cells in the West Bank. The Palestinian Authority has continued “pay-for-slay” payments to terrorists and their families.
Meanwhile, Palestinian textbooks continue to glorify violence against Israelis. U.S.-Israel security cooperation also addresses shared threats from Iranian proxies.
A two-state outcome remains an ideal many Americans support. The record shows Palestinian leaders have not accepted a state living permanently beside a Jewish state.
If dramatic change is the goal, establish conditions where diplomatic moves and U.S. funding for Palestinian governance depend on explicit recognition of Israel as the nation-state of the Jewish people. Demand an end to the generational right-of-return demand into Israel, stop pay-for-slay payments, and campaign for the removal of educational materials that glorify violence.
Until those conditions are met through consistent action, the United States should maintain its support for Israel’s security rather than treat a slogan as a substitute for ninety years of evidence.
Sincerely,
The Rev. Kathleen J. Rusnak, PhD.
Lutheran (ELCA) Pastor, Lecturer, and Author

