Ed Gaskin

The Compounding Cost of Unequal Markets

CETERIS PARIBUS NEVER APPLIED – PART VI

How lost assets shape the next generation’s opportunities

Income is what a household receives. Wealth is what it can carry forward. A family’s income may rise while it still lacks the assets to withstand a layoff, make a down payment, start a business or help a child finish college. Wealth is accumulated time.

Part V asked what happens when public institutions help create markets and then give people unequal access to them. The answer becomes clearer when we follow a family’s balance sheet over a generation. Unequal rules shape who gets to acquire assets, who gets to keep them and what each family can pass on after the rules change.

Suppose two families each own an asset worth $10,000. One keeps it. The other loses it through a discriminatory process and receives no compensation. At an illustrative annual return of 4 percent, with the gains reinvested, the first family’s asset would be worth about $32,400 after thirty years, before taxes and costs. During those years, the family could also choose to borrow against it to start a business or sell it to help a child buy a home. Either choice would affect the family’s eventual balance sheet. The point is that ownership gives a family choices well before it passes anything on.

The Federal Reserve’s 2022 Survey of Consumer Finances puts the modern gap in perspective. Median net worth was about $44,900 for Black families and $285,000 for white families. In the same survey, about 45 percent of Black families owned their homes. Housing is one of several routes to wealth, and ownership carries costs and risks. But a household that can buy on affordable terms has a chance to build equity as it pays down the mortgage and to benefit if the property rises in value. federalreserve.gov

Consider a family that could have afforded to buy on the terms a federally insured mortgage made available elsewhere, but whose neighborhood was excluded from that market. Federal Housing Administration underwriting helped institutionalize that kind of exclusion. If the family bought years later, it began paying down its mortgage years later. It also missed any appreciation in the intervening years. By the time its children reached adulthood, it might have had less equity to draw on for their college costs or a first down payment. A change in lending rules could expand the family’s choices from that day forward. The years it had lost would still matter. federalreservehistory.org

Now suppose a daughter in that family wants to start a business. She needs equipment, inventory and enough cash to pay workers before customers pay her. If her family has savings or home equity it can draw on, she has more ways to cover those costs and survive a slow first year. If those resources are scarce, she may have to start smaller, postpone hiring or borrow on more expensive terms. A constraint that began in the mortgage market can shape the size and prospects of a firm a generation later.

Land shows what happens when families lose assets they already own. Using Census of Agriculture records, economists Dania Francis, Darrick Hamilton and their colleagues documented a nearly 90 percent decline in Black agricultural land ownership between 1910 and 1997. For a family that lost a farm, the economic consequences extended beyond what it received at the time. The land could have supported a business, generated rent, secured credit or passed to descendants who could decide how to use it. Once the land left the family, those decisions belonged to someone else. aeaweb.org

The neighborhood matters even when families manage to buy. Two households can make every mortgage payment and build very different amounts of equity. In one neighborhood, financing for home repairs and investment in public services can help sustain property values. In another, scarce credit can make routine upkeep harder and discourage investment. Research on the federal government’s redlining maps of the 1930s found lasting effects on homeownership and property values. A judgment about a neighborhood’s risk could help produce the conditions that later appeared to justify it. Counting homeowners tells us who acquired an asset. To understand what they could carry forward, we also need to know how the asset performed. aeaweb.org

Black families built substantial wealth despite these barriers, and families within every racial group followed different paths. The Federal Reserve figures describe where families stood in 2022. Tracing the contributions of past policies requires looking at how earnings, education, geography and inheritance interact. A parent’s missing home equity can affect how much a child borrows for college. Those loan payments can affect when the child buys a home and how much the child can set aside to start a business. What appears in today’s data as a difference in student debt or business ownership can have roots in a decision made in another market decades earlier.

Higher earnings give families more room to save and invest. Even if two households earn the same salary today, one may be saving for a first down payment while the other is drawing on years of accumulated equity. The annual paycheck shows what each family earns. The balance sheet shows what each can put to work.

A fair lending rule can open the door to a mortgage today. It cannot supply the equity a family might have built over the previous thirty years. The final essay takes up the question that follows. What would it take to restore fair competition when yesterday’s rules still shape the capital families and businesses bring to the market today?

–

Endnotes for Part VI

The Compounding Cost of Unequal Markets

  1. Racial wealth and homeownership in 2022. Aditya Aladangady, Andrew C. Chang, and Jacob Krimmel, “Greater Wealth, Greater Uncertainty: Changes in Racial Inequality in the Survey of Consumer Finances,” FEDS Notes, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, October 18, 2023, figs. 1 and 5. Figure 1 gives median family net worth by race and ethnicity. Figure 5 gives homeownership rates. Read the Federal Reserve analysis. federalreserve.gov
  2. Federal Housing Administration underwriting and mortgage exclusion. Federal Reserve History, “Redlining,” June 2, 2023. The section “Redlining Practices before 1968” documents how the FHA incorporated racial exclusion into its mortgage insurance practices. Read the historical overview. www.federalreservehistory.org
  3. Decline in Black agricultural land ownership. Dania V. Francis, Darrick Hamilton, Thomas W. Mitchell, Nathan A. Rosenberg, and Bryce Wilson Stucki, “Black Land Loss: 1920–1997,” AEA Papers and Proceedings 112 (May 2022), 38–42. The authors document a nearly 90 percent decline in Black agricultural land ownership from 1910 to 1997. Read the study. www.aeaweb.org
  4. Long-run effects of redlining on neighborhoods. Daniel Aaronson, Daniel Hartley, and Bhashkar Mazumder, “The Effects of the 1930s HOLC ‘Redlining’ Maps,” American Economic Journal: Economic Policy 13, no. 4 (November 2021), 355–392. The study examines how the Home Owners’ Loan Corporation maps affected homeownership, property values, rents, and segregation over subsequent decades. Read the study. www.aeaweb.org

The $10,000 example is an illustrative calculation. At a constant 4 percent annual return compounded for 30 years, $10,000 grows to approximately $32,434 before taxes and costs.

About the Author
Ed Gaskin attends Temple Beth Elohim in Wellesley, Massachusetts and Roxbury Presbyterian Church in Roxbury, Mass. He has co-taught a course with professor Dean Borman called, “Christianity and the Problem of Racism” to Evangelicals (think Trump followers) for over 25 years. Ed has an M. Div. degree from Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary and graduated as a Martin Trust Fellow from MIT’s Sloan School of Management. He has published several books on a range of topics and was a co-organizer of the first faith-based initiative on reducing gang violence at the National Press Club in Washington DC. In addition to leading a non-profit in one of the poorest communities in Boston, and serving on several non-profit advisory boards, Ed’s current focus is reducing the incidence of diet-related disease by developing food with little salt, fat or sugar and none of the top eight allergens. He does this as the founder of Sunday Celebrations, a consumer-packaged goods business that makes “Good for You” gourmet food.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.