Emma Dunn

The Distance I Didn’t Expect: Reflections on a Year Since Aliyah

One year ago, I became an Israeli citizen. I knew moving across an ocean would mean physical distance. I got used to time-zone math, to meetings at late hours, to missing the small moments that previously made up my life. What I didn’t know to expect was the emotional distance between my two homes, and my identity in each place. 

Israel is loud. It is expressive. People are blunt, sometimes to the point of rudeness, and then they invite you to Shabbat dinner. It is deeply communal. Here, I feel like I’m in constant conversation with myself, with the people around me, with my identity, with the present, and with the future. As Senior Director of Israel Programs at Honeymoon Israel, I spend my days helping US couples with at least one Jewish partner have exactly that kind of conversation here, about Israel, about Judaism, and about the homes they want to build. But that isn’t how I grew up.

I grew up in the Midwest, between Minnesota and Wisconsin, where space is a kind of courtesy. It can be impolite to ask too much. You don’t say everything you think. You don’t interrupt, and you don’t force a conversation before it’s ready. A lot is left unsaid, and that’s often meant as kindness. So when I look back toward “home,” I notice the conversation I want to have now doesn’t quite fit there anymore.

I’ve been back to the US twice since I made aliyah. Both times, I felt a gap I couldn’t quite name, especially with non-Jewish friends and family. Immediately following the October 7th attacks, while I was still living in Minneapolis, they asked me questions all the time. What’s happening? Is everyone you know safe? What do you make of the war? Then I moved. During the wars with Iran, in 2025 and 2026, my phone was mostly quiet.

The silence I feel most is from the people I haven’t heard from at all. Those who haven’t called or texted. I know what they’re seeing. I think they’re afraid to ask. Afraid of hurting me, or of showing that they don’t approve of my choices. I understand the confusion, concern and sensitivity. And I believe the people I love can understand me too, if we give each other the chance.

Sometimes the questions go around me instead. This year, when someone close to me was planning a visit, a friend sent them an article arguing that Israel is committing genocide in Gaza, and that visiting meant supporting it. No one asked me what I thought, or what they might actually see here. The article took the place of the conversation.

What I’ve felt with my friends and family, I watched play out on an international stage this month. In the American midterms, Israel came up in Senate debates, in primaries, and in millions of dollars of campaign spending, including in my home state. Israel is clearly on Americans’ minds and hearts. But in politics, as in my own relationships, Israel is mostly talked about, not talked with. It has become a dividing line, a test of which side you’re on, rather than a place full of people you could ask. That’s what worries me most: the same silence and assumptions that I feel personally, scaled up to a whole country.

Three years after October 7th, the misunderstanding and misrepresentation of Israel are enormous, and polarization pushes all of us toward binary choices. Isolating, demonizing, and mischaracterizing a place, the very place I’ve chosen to live and the very people I’ve chosen to build community with, is dangerous for all of us. What I see happening is a fracturing, and that scares me far more than the risk of being impolite.

So I want people to ask. I want the questions said out loud, even the uncomfortable ones. Silence doesn’t protect a relationship. It slowly empties it. That takes courage, the same kind moving across the world asks of you. It may go against our norms or our nature. But when we stop asking, we stop learning. We stop growing.

Before Israel, I spent years in political advocacy, work built on a simple idea: we have more in common than what divides us. I still believe that, and I see it every day in my work at Honeymoon Israel. Watching HMI couples ask hard questions, and stay open to the answers, gives me hope that the rest of us can too.

Building a life in a new place means planting yourself there. You give something up in order to do that. But distance doesn’t have to mean disconnection. So on my one-year aliyah anniversary, here’s my invitation: start the conversation.  Tell me your beliefs. Ask me what people think here, what the elections mean, what I’m unsure about, what scares me, and what gives me hope. Tell me what you wonder about and what worries you. I’ll ask you back, and I’ll listen. And to my growing Israeli community, whether you made aliyah last month or your family has been here for generations: I’d love to hear how you built your home here, and what you’ve learned about holding on to the people you left behind. If I stay open, and you stay open, maybe we can find our way closer together, even from across an ocean.

About the Author
Emma Dunn is the Senior Director of Israel Programs for Honeymoon Israel, where she works at the intersection of Jewish peoplehood, community-building, and modern Jewish identity. She joined Honeymoon Israel in 2022 as the Midwest/Central U.S. Regional Director before relocating to Israel. Prior to HMI, Emma led young adult engagement for the Jewish Federations of Minneapolis and St. Paul and has served on multiple nonprofit boards. She holds a BA and Master of Public Policy from the University of Minnesota and a Certificate in Jewish Leadership from the Spertus Institute. Now based in Tel Aviv, Emma writes about how Jewish community and Israel are shaped by relationships, culture, politics, and daily life. When she’s not working, she’s usually running along the beach, studying Hebrew, or exploring new people, places, and ideas.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.