The Fragility of Trust
The story coming out of Nvidia has me thinking about the topic of trust.
Jensen Huang spent more than 30 years building one of the most valuable companies in the world. Employees, investors and governments trusted him. Within a matter of days, after revelations of an affair with a woman suspected of being a Chinese spy, followed by reports of affairs with women who worked under him, he resigned. Thirty years to build. One week to lose. That is how fragile trust is.
When I grew up, I trusted the president. I trusted mayors, congressmen and senators. I trusted the news. I trusted Walter Cronkite, who was called “the most trusted man in America.” After Cronkite, I trusted Dan Rather, only to see his career end in a credibility scandal in 2004. I trusted institutions.
Those days are over.
I don’t think most folks trust politicians or the network news anymore. And it isn’t only institutions. We’ve all watched people with stellar reputations and perfectly manicured images fall from grace. Tiger Woods was the most admired athlete in the world until his serial infidelity came to light. Bill Gates was revered as the world’s great philanthropist until his ties to Jeffrey Epstein were revealed, along with reports that he had pursued an affair with a Microsoft employee. When the people we truly looked up to turn out not to be who we thought they were, it takes a toll on all of us. We become a little more cynical, and a little less willing to believe in anyone.
Closer to home, studies suggest that roughly one in five married men, and one in seven or eight married women, have been unfaithful. Imagine coming home and learning that the person you committed your whole life to, the person you entrusted your family to, has been betraying you. It’s devastating. It’s hard to believe.
Even the experts on honesty can’t be trusted. Dan Ariely, a Duke University professor, became famous as the world’s leading researcher on why people lie and cheat. His bestselling books explained human dishonesty to millions. One of his best-known studies claimed that if you ask people to sign an honesty pledge at the top of a form, before they fill it out, they’re less likely to lie. Companies and governments changed their forms because of it. Then, in 2021, researchers discovered that the data behind the study had been fabricated, and the study was retracted. A study about how to make people honest turned out to be dishonest.
The real test of a person is what he does when he’s sure no one is watching. The Gemara (Brachos 28b) tells us that when Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai was dying, his students asked him for a blessing. He said, “May your fear of Gd be as great as your fear of people.” His students were surprised: “That’s all?” He answered, “If only! When a person sins, he says, ‘I hope no one sees me.'” We worry about being caught by people. We forget about the One who always sees.
Decades ago, I had the privilege of studying Torah with the Wall Street legend Jack Nash, of blessed memory. He once told me: “If you wouldn’t be comfortable seeing what you’re doing reported on the front page of The New York Times, don’t do it.” It’s a simple test, and a powerful one. Imagine how many people would still be trusted today if they had lived by it.
So who can we trust?
According to Judaism, the only One who can be fully trusted is the Almighty. King David writes in Tehillim (146:3), “Al tivtechu vindivim, b’ven adam she’ein lo teshuah.” “Do not put your trust in nobles, in a mortal who cannot save.” The Gemara at the end of Sotah says, “Ein lanu al mi l’hisha’en ela al Avinu shebashamayim.” “We have no one to rely on except our Father in Heaven.”
This isn’t a counsel of despair. It’s the opposite. A person who puts his ultimate trust in Gd doesn’t need people to be perfect. He can be generous with others, forgive their failings, and get up again when someone lets him down, because his foundation was never built on them in the first place.
Does that mean I should assume people are bad? Absolutely not. There’s a wide-open space between blind trust and assuming the man next to you is a murderer, and that space is where we live.
Our Sages gave us a guide for living in it: “Kabdeihu v’chashdeihu.” “Respect him, and suspect him.” The Talmudic tractate Derech Eretz Rabbah tells of Rabbi Yehoshua, who welcomed a guest into his home, fed him and gave him a bed in the upper story. But before he went to sleep, he removed the ladder. In the night the guest got up to steal, stepped off the edge, and fell. Rabbi Yehoshua didn’t assume his guest was a thief. If he had, he never would have let him in. He honored him. But he also protected himself.
Nearly two thousand years later, President Reagan put it in three words when negotiating with the Soviets: “Trust, but verify.”
There’s one more side to this. If trust is so fragile, the most important thing any of us can do is not just choose carefully whom to trust, but become trustworthy ourselves.
The Torah describes the Almighty as “Kel emunah” (Devarim 32:4), “a Gd of faithfulness.” And our Sages teach that we are commanded to walk in His ways: just as He is compassionate, we must be compassionate. Just as He is faithful, we must be faithful. The One we can always trust asks us to become people others can trust.
In a world where so few people keep their word, a person who does, in business, in marriage, in friendship, becomes rare and precious. We can’t control whether others betray us, but we can control whether we are people others can rely on.
Jensen Huang needed thirty years to build trust and one week to lose it. Each of us is building ours, one kept promise at a time.
