Ed Gaskin

The Government-versus-Markets Debate Misses Race

CETERIS PARIBUS NEVER APPLIED — PART V

How public rules and private decisions shaped Black access to capital

A family could have enough income to make the monthly payments on a home and still find that the neighborhood stood between it and a mortgage. Federal insurance reduced the risk a private lender took in making a loan. The Federal Housing Administration helped determine where that protection was available, and its underwriting standards treated Black occupancy and racial change as threats to property values. A private lender made the loan decision, while a public agency set the terms under which it would insure the loan. Where, in that transaction, does government end and the market begin? www.federalreservehistory.org

American economic debate often starts by asking whether government should intervene in the market. The traditions associated with Milton Friedman and Friedrich Hayek press us to ask what happens when public officials have too much discretion over private decisions. The Keynesian tradition presses us to ask how public action shapes the conditions under which people invest. The history of federal mortgage insurance makes both questions unavoidable. Public policy could make lenders more willing to extend credit, and public officials could use the rules of that same program to decide which neighborhoods would share in the benefit.

The previous essay argued that political power is an economic asset. Its value becomes tangible when a family needs an institution to explain a denial, correct an error, or change a rule. A household can save for a down payment and make a persuasive case to its lender. It takes a different kind of influence to challenge the underwriting standard by which a federal agency judges an entire neighborhood. The ability to make an institution answer for its decisions is part of what gives political power its economic value.

In housing, the rule itself mattered. Private lenders already practiced redlining, and the FHA gave exclusionary lending practices federal support through its own underwriting standards. That distinction matters because it identifies what each institution controlled. The lender could approve or deny an individual application. The FHA could decide whether a loan on that property qualified for federal insurance. A lender could still make an uninsured loan, but the federal government had already changed the terms on which lenders were being asked to serve different neighborhoods. Public rules and private decisions could reinforce each other, even when the public agency never dealt directly with the borrower. www.federalreservehistory.org

Consider what happens when lenders are less willing to finance purchases in a neighborhood. Fewer prospective buyers can make an offer. An owner who needs to sell may have to accept a lower price. That sale can then become one of the comparable sales an appraiser uses to value the next house on the block. A lender reviewing the next mortgage application can point to the lower appraisal as evidence for caution. Each decision can look reasonable when viewed on its own. Taken together, the decisions can help produce the conditions that appear to justify them. A rule that begins by treating a neighborhood’s racial makeup as a sign of financial risk can end by depressing the very prices lenders look to for evidence of risk.

The experience of Black farmers shows how much could also turn on the administration of a program. In Pigford v. Glickman, Black farmers alleged that the US Department of Agriculture discriminated against them in access to loans and other assistance and failed to respond adequately to their complaints. The case ended in a court-approved settlement. For a farmer, timing is part of the value of credit. A loan that comes through after planting season cannot buy seed in time for that year’s crop. An application can remain pending on paper while the economic opportunity it was meant to finance disappears. A complaint process offers little practical recourse for that season if it cannot produce a timely decision. www.congress.gov

These cases put three questions at the center of the debate. Who set the standard? Who exercised discretion? What recourse did the applicant have? In housing, federal officials set the insurance standards and private lenders made individual lending decisions. In agriculture, federal programs delivered assistance through local offices, where the handling of an application could determine whether a farmer received credit in time to use it. In both cases, a serious assessment of the program has to include the experience of the person trying to get through the door. How was the rule applied, and who could get a decision reviewed while there was still something to be gained? www.federalreservehistory.org

This is where the market argument and the argument for public action meet. If we care about competition, we should ask whether qualified borrowers could obtain capital on fair terms. If we care about what public programs accomplish, we should ask who gained the ability to buy a home, keep a farm operating, or build an asset they could pass on. Both questions require us to examine the rules, who applied them, and whose interests counted when those rules were challenged. Any effort at repair should begin with that same inquiry, because the remedy depends on how the harm occurred.

Removing a discriminatory rule changes the terms of the next transaction. It leaves families entering that transaction with the assets they accumulated under the old rules. A family that was denied a mortgage years earlier may now be able to buy. A family that bought during those years may already have equity it can borrow against or use to help a child make a down payment. Both can face the same underwriting standard today and have very different resources with which to meet it. Part VI follows that difference from one household balance sheet to the next generation.

About the Author
Ed Gaskin attends Temple Beth Elohim in Wellesley, Massachusetts and Roxbury Presbyterian Church in Roxbury, Mass. He has co-taught a course with professor Dean Borman called, “Christianity and the Problem of Racism” to Evangelicals (think Trump followers) for over 25 years. Ed has an M. Div. degree from Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary and graduated as a Martin Trust Fellow from MIT’s Sloan School of Management. He has published several books on a range of topics and was a co-organizer of the first faith-based initiative on reducing gang violence at the National Press Club in Washington DC. In addition to leading a non-profit in one of the poorest communities in Boston, and serving on several non-profit advisory boards, Ed’s current focus is reducing the incidence of diet-related disease by developing food with little salt, fat or sugar and none of the top eight allergens. He does this as the founder of Sunday Celebrations, a consumer-packaged goods business that makes “Good for You” gourmet food.
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.