Leslie Benitah
Journalist | Documentary Filmmaker | Holocaust Educator

The Holocaust Doesn’t Need a Rebrand

Do we need to decolonize Holocaust museums? I’m sorry, what?

Have we reached the point where even Holocaust remembrance needs a fashionable academic makeover? What’s next? Rebranding Auschwitz? Disrupting Yad Vashem? Giving the Warsaw Ghetto a postcolonial upgrade?

Welcome to the age of academic buzzwords, where apparently even Holocaust remembrance needs a trendy new label.

The questions sound absurd. They are meant to. But sometimes absurdity is the only reasonable response to a vocabulary that seems determined to insert itself into every historical conversation.

On November 17, Penn State’s Jewish Studies Program hosted Erica Lehrer of Concordia University for a lecture titled “Do We Need to Decolonize Holocaust Museums?”

I read the title twice. Not because Holocaust museums should be immune from criticism. Quite the opposite. Museums are institutions, and institutions should be questioned. Their collections, educational practices, and historical narratives deserve rigorous scrutiny.

But words matter. Especially when we are talking about the Holocaust.

Before we rush to decolonize anything, perhaps we should ask a simpler question: What, exactly, are we proposing to decolonize?

A Fashionable Word, a Serious Question

The lecture description proposed applying decolonial museum theory to Holocaust museums, including questions of institutional power, exclusions, and historical silences. Following the controversy, Penn State explained that the discussion addressed matters such as the ownership and display of Holocaust-era artifacts and the representation of victims.

Fair enough. Those are serious questions. But since when did returning stolen Jewish property require a fashionable new vocabulary? We already have words for this: provenance, restitution, historical accountability, curatorial responsibility. They are precise. They identify a problem and suggest what needs to be done.

To be clear, decolonial scholarship has raised important questions about how museums acquired objects, who controls them, and whose voices are heard. Such questions can be useful in Holocaust museums, too.

But a framework is not valuable merely because it is fashionable. Its relevance has to be demonstrated.

The Holocaust was the systematic persecution and murder of six million Jews by Nazi Germany and its collaborators. Its ideological foundations, mechanisms, and historical context demand specificity.

Comparison can illuminate history; forcing different histories into a single conceptual template can flatten it.

Not every injustice is colonialism. Not every institutional problem requires decolonization. And not every difficult question becomes more sophisticated when we attach an academic buzzword to it.

The Human Being Behind the Object

I have spent years interviewing more than 150 Holocaust survivors. I have listened to them describe homes confiscated, possessions stolen, families destroyed, and entire worlds erased.

A suitcase in a museum was once someone’s suitcase. A photograph stood on a mantelpiece. A child’s shoe belonged to a child with a name, a family, and a future.

The ethics of how those objects are acquired, displayed, contextualized, and returned are not abstract concerns. Yet what survivors have taught me goes beyond objects.

They do not want to be remembered only as victims, frozen forever at the worst moment of their lives. They want us to remember who they were before the persecution, and who they became afterward.

The Nazis reduced people to categories and numbers. Our responsibility is to restore their names, faces, and stories. This is why I resist language that risks becoming more conspicuous than the history it is meant to illuminate.

When a debate about Holocaust museums becomes a debate about a single fashionable term, the people at the center of the story can disappear from view once again.

The challenge is not whether museums should change. Of course they should, when evidence and ethical obligations require it. The challenge is whether change is being described in language that clarifies those obligations or obscures them.

A Responsibility, Not a Rebranding Exercise

We are entering a new era of Holocaust remembrance. The last living witnesses are leaving us. For decades, a survivor could enter a classroom and say three words that no exhibition, algorithm, or theoretical framework can reproduce: “I was there.”

In their absence, museums and educators will carry even greater responsibility. They must preserve testimony faithfully, provide context, confront omissions, and remain open to new scholarship.

None of that requires treating Holocaust remembrance as a product in need of the latest intellectual rebrand.

I recently stood in Warsaw, where two of my grandparents survived the Warsaw Ghetto. My great-grandparents, Mordka and Bluma, did not. Much of my family’s history had to be reconstructed from fragments: photographs, documents, archives, names, places.

I know how much can depend on one preserved object or one correctly identified name. I welcome serious scrutiny of the institutions entrusted with such traces. I also know how easily an imprecise word can redirect attention away from what matters.

Perhaps the most radical thing a Holocaust museum can do today is not adopt the newest vocabulary. Perhaps it is to tell the truth with historical precision, ethical seriousness, and an unwavering commitment to the individuals whose lives it exists to remember.

Call it provenance. Call it restitution. Call it scholarship. Call it responsibility.

When the subject is the Holocaust, precision is not a luxury. It is a responsibility.

About the Author
Leslie Gelrubin Benitah, Ph.D., is an award-winning journalist, documentary filmmaker, writer, and founder of The Last Ones, the nonprofit behind the Best Holocaust Education Initiative in the U.S. (2025). The granddaughter of four Holocaust survivors from Poland, she has interviewed hundreds of Holocaust survivors across Europe, Israel, and the United States, helping preserve their testimony for future generations.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.