Paul Gross

The most unacceptable option? Bibi back as PM

In the last pages of my recent book on the threat to our democracy from Benjamin Netanyahu and his far-right partners, I attempted to focus readers’ minds on what was at stake:

…the outcome of this election will be no less critical to Israel’s future than the outcome of the efforts to neutralize Hamas and Hezbollah and to defang Iran.

If, in a few years, Israel is living with secure borders in a more stable Middle East, that would be cause for celebration. Unless it is an Israel that is no longer free. An Israel where the government can pass whatever laws it likes through the Knesset, regardless of their effect on civil liberties and human rights; and where the media is slavishly loyal to the government will also be an Israel where elections are no longer fair. And make no mistake. This is the path the country is on if Netanyahu returns to power, with this coalition.

I had assumed that, were Netanyahu to return as prime minister, the impartiality of the next elections might well be compromised. With the Supreme Court neutered and civil servants politicized, there would be nothing to stop the government from granting power to the Central Elections Committee (which it would control) to ban parties on alleged security grounds, no matter how spurious. And with the government able to exercise authority over media outlets, they would have a built-in advantage in any election campaign.

As it turns out, I underestimated the danger. Forget the next elections. Netanyahu was already intending to put his thumb on the scales of these elections. Yair Lapid put it succinctly in a post on X:

So, there was indeed an attempt to steal the election. It was orchestrated by the Likud from within Netanyahu’s office.

It’s being called Netanyahu’s January 6. In one respect, it’s more like Watergate; the use of the state’s security services for political ends.

This was an unprecedented assault on Israeli democracy. The arrest – without warrants – of innocent citizens, so that the Prime Minister and his media mouthpieces could issue an “Arabs are stealing the election!” rallying cry on election day. It also enabled him to cast doubt on the legitimacy of the results, and of the Arab Knesset members. (The television report can be viewed with English subtitles here.)

Yesterday, Netanyahu’s loyalist Shin Bet chief, who had originally warned of an Arab election-fixing scandal that was “a failure on the scale of October 7”, admitted there is no evidence of anything that affected the election results.

So where does this leave Gadi Eisenkot’s vexed attempts to build a functioning coalition? To my mind, what it should mean is that no government with Netanyahu is now possible. We are no longer in the realm of people like me speculating about what the judicial overhaul would have done to our democracy. The (hopefully) outgoing Prime Minister is a clear and present danger to our country’s future as a thriving democratic state.

I can already hear the accusations of “Bibi-Derangement-Syndrome!” and the complaints about “boycotting” Netanyahu. But there’s nothing deranged or irrational about “boycotting” a man who has so demonstrably put his own interests ahead of the country’s, time and time again. As one former Likud minister told me, “It’s not that Bibi doesn’t love Israel, it’s just that he loves being Prime Minister more.”

In 2021, he was willing to cause actual damage to the economy by preventing a budget being passed, simply in order to collapse his government and prevent Benny Gantz from becoming Prime Minister. Everything is legitimate in his eyes if it keeps him in power. He empowered and emboldened the Kahanist far right that had been deservedly ostracized by mainstream Israel for 40 years. The Likud had led the fight to ban Meir Kahane for racism in the 1980s; today’s Likud Prime Minister not only brought Kahane‘s heirs into his cabinet, he put their leader in charge of the Police; a scarcely conceivable act of vandalism against the state.

He obsessively pursued the judicial overhaul even when he was warned by his defense minister, the head of the Shin Bet, and the IDF that it was damaging the country’s morale and social cohesion and leaving us vulnerable to our enemies. And we paid the highest possible price for that.

He initiated the campaign to demonize and incite against the judiciary and other parts of the state that he did not have political control over. The first time in the history of the state of Israel that a Prime Minister has sought to delegitimize institutions of the state, and the rule of law itself.

His unwillingness to accept a scintilla of responsibility for October 7 is not news, of course. It is also entirely typical. He will rush to the microphones to claim credit for every military success, but disappear from view whenever anything goes wrong, allowing others to take the flak. Recall also his refusal to visit the kibbutzim attacked by Hamas, ignoring the families of hostages or fallen soldiers except those he knows to be his supporters. This is not a national leader, this is a politician always – always – thinking about the next election.

And he is a quite brilliant politician; and one of the very smartest people to have ever led the country in its 78 years. But his obsession with staying in power at all costs has made him the most destructive Prime Minister in the history of the state of Israel. His actions on election day and since have decisively confirmed that ranking.

Yes, Gadi Eisenkot will have to upset some of his voters one way or another if he’s to succeed in forming a government. But the only truly unacceptable option, surely, would be Netanyahu’s return to the Prime Minister’s Office.

About the Author
Before moving to Israel from the UK, Paul worked at the Embassy of Israel to the UK in the Public Affairs department, and as the Ambassador's speechwriter. He has a Masters degree in Middle East Politics from the University of London. He lectures to a variety of groups on Israeli history and politics and his articles have been published in a variety of media outlets in Israel, the UK, the US and Canada. He is the author of "To Be a Free People in Our Land: Zionism, Liberal Democracy, and Israel’s Hinge Election" (Fathom Journal Press, 2026).
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.