The Myth that Muslims are Conquering Europe
In recent years, one sentence has almost become a given in Israeli discourse, among the American right, and within the old establishment of Jewish communities: Europe is lost; the Muslims have conquered it. You hear it in panels in studios, read it on social media, hear it from worried Jews, and hear it from the president of the United States and the prime minister of Israel.
Nothing is more difficult for me than racism, but it is most painful when it comes from my own people. Because behind this statement is not a demographic analysis but an ancient fear: the fear of a whole group marked as an enemy.
We have already heard this claim. Again and again throughout history, leaders, priests, and thinkers have explained that Jews threaten the “purity of the European nation.” They said we reproduce too much, that we are loyal to a foreign nation, and that we take over politics and culture. The same tune is returning today, but this time Muslims are the target. A people that has paid such a price for theories of “demographic takeover” should be the first to recognize them, not the last to repeat them.
The numbers show a different picture. According to the Pew Research Center, Muslims constitute about 6 percent of the population of Western Europe, including the European Union, Norway, and Switzerland. In France, the percentage of Muslims is the highest in Europe, with estimates reaching around 10 percent. Even in the highest immigration scenario, which is no longer possible today because Europe has closed its gates and is preventing massive immigration, they will be about 14% in 2050, much less than Christians and the non-religious.
Muslims in Europe are far from dominating its politics: there is no Muslim party that forms a government in any Western European country or where they constitute a significant force. The claim of Islam’s takeover of Europe does not stem only from racism. It also stems from the need to explain to ourselves that criticism of Israeli governments’ policies is not related to us or our actions. In the past, the accusation was directed at the historical antisemitism stemming from the Catholic Church’s claims that we did not accept Jesus and even caused his crucifixion. However, in reality, the Catholic Church has changed its stance regarding blaming the Jews, and in addition, the influence of religion is gradually diminishing across Europe.
Today, the claim is about the impact of Muslim immigration. However, in reality, the most significant political impact of Muslim immigration to Europe is the strengthening of the far-right –whose parties found a partner in Netanyahu. In February 2025, Likud joined “Patriots for Europe” as an observer, the first party outside the Union to do so. In this bloc are members of the National Rally party of Le Pen, the Austrian Freedom Party, the Spanish Vox, and others, which Israel has previously boycotted due to their antisemitic roots.
In March 2025, the government invited representatives of these parties to a conference in Jerusalem that focused specifically on the fight against antisemitism. Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Sa’ar acknowledged that some of them have problematic roots but explained that what matters is their actions today. The common denominator is clear: not love for Jews, but hostility toward Muslims.
And there may be an attempt to reinterpret European criticism of the occupation of the Palestinian people by using the word “occupation” in a different sense. But any empirical study will show that most Europeans’ criticism of the occupation of the Palestinians does not stem from an increase in the number of Muslims on the continent. Europeans place great importance on international law and are very opposed to occupations, both because of their painful history with Germany and the Soviet Union and because of the current threat to Europe posed by Putin’s aggressiveness and Trump’s abandonment.
The reason European criticism has intensified recently stems from the fact that Europeans are exposed to the atrocities in Gaza and the West Bank that are spared from most Israelis due to our media’s self-censorship. Additionally, following October 7 and the results of the Israeli response, there is a growing feeling in Europe that what happens in Gaza or the West Bank does not stay there and affects the entire world, and therefore action is required.
In any case, it is ridiculous to use the accusation of occupation to describe families who have come work in Germany or study in France, even if some of them participate in protests across Europe about the cost of living and some even wear keffiyehs and blame Israel.
Anyone who truly cares about European Jewry must understand that a pluralistic Europe that protects all minorities is essential for its security. Whoever marks one minority as the enemy from within today will not stop there. And we, of all nations, know this best.
Whoever wants to reduce the criticism and hostility toward us from Western Europe should maintain Israel as a liberal democracy and strive to end the occupation of the Palestinian people, which is the main reason for the damage to Israel’s standing in Europe.

