Chaim Ingram

The USA midterm elections: Is there a silver lining?

Dear Rabbi.  How worried are you about the changed political landscape in the USA?  I’m terrified for my extended family!   Yours,  Brad (expat Yankee).

Dear Brad,

Last week, I wrote about thinking outside the box.  I’m going to try to do just that with your question.

Firstly, for the benefit of those who have been in hibernation for the past few weeks, the US Democrats who boast an increasing number of ultra-left, anti-Israel – some even antisemitic – figures among their representatives, have turned around both the lower and upper legislative chambers substantially in their numerical favour thus threatening to be a highly potent counterweight to the authority of the (up-to-now) philosemitic, pro-Israel President Trump.

I would indeed be worried if I did not trust in the adage declared by the wisest of men and immortalised in the Book of Proverbs. The hearts of rulers is in the hand of G-D; like diverging streams of water, wherever He wishes, so does He direct them.(Proverbs 21:1)

We have been here before. It has been a recurring pattern in the Diaspora. As someone once put it “the goyim either love us too much our hate us too much!” Sometimes love can turn to hate almost overnight. We have a prime example in this week’s Sidra. After fourteen years of loyal service, Lavan declares to Jacob: “G-D has blessed me on account of you!” (Gen 30:27). A short time later, Jacob becomes prosperous and suddenly “Lavan’s face …was not favourably disposed towards him as before” (31:2)

Today, Israel’s quasi-miraculous continuing economic prosperity even amid internal and external conflict and strife, is triggering a similar turning away of the face in the USA!

But even accepting that in the natural course of events the two largest concentrations of world Jewry in the USA and Israel, may be in for a rough ride these next two years, I would venture to suggest  the following:-

(These thoughts are based on the reasonable assumption that the Republicans will continue to be considerably less hostile to Israel than the Democrats – although this too may change. According to the most recent Gallup poll, 83% of Republicans have a favourable view of Israel in contrast to just 33% of Democrats.)

The governing Republicans have been in the constant line of fire for the past two years due largely to the Iran conflict and its adverse effect on the US economy. A republican President, and Republican politicians dominating both the Senate and the House of Representatives has meant that the party has been on a hiding to nothing. There has been no-one else to blame. (Except Israel of course, but that’s for another time.) Had the mid-term elections not transpired, the focus of this mass discontent would probably have continued to rest exclusively on the Reps. with the result that they would assuredly have been booted out in the next election in two years’ time. With the rise of the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) and the rapid spreading of its Jew-hostile tentacles into the mainstream of the Democratic Party, a rampant Democratic landslide in two years’ time could be extremely worrying news for American Jews.

But I believe the likelihood of this bleak prospect may paradoxically have been reduced as a result of the mid-term election results.

With the current scenario of a Republican President presiding over a hostile Senate and House of Representatives, the chances of any significant legislation passing is slim. The President can veto legislation passed by Congress which can then be overturned only with a two-thirds majority in each House (unlikely). Conversely, if the President proposes legislation,  the House and Senate have to pass it before it reaches the President’s desk to be signed. If they don’t pass it, legislation is stalled.  It will not take long for the impotence of Congress to register in the minds of US voters. And for sure both parties will be blamed if (as is likely) things go absolutely pear-shaped.  Then, with the divisive Trump out of the picture in two years’ time,  it will be a matter of which side fields the stronger candidate for the next Presidential election. With Vance reportedly an increasingly unpopular figure in the Republican party there is a good chance that a pro-Israel figure like Rubio, Cruz or De Santis will be elected as Republican candidate for the presidency  And with disenchantment of American voters with both sides of Congress a likely scenario, the Republicans will have at least an even-money chance of retaining the Presidency.

So, Brad, I see a silver lining where you and others only see doom and gloom!

I suppose it has to do with the way I interpret the Torah and the teachings of our Sages as pointing to a constant message that so much of what seems bad turns out to be good in the end!

Again pointing to this week’s sidra: Jacob is livid when he discovers his uncle Lavan had tricked him by giving him Leah instead of Rachel. However, the less-loved Leah bears him six sons including Yehuda whose tenth-generation descendant turns out to be David, Israel’s greatest king and scion of the future Mashiach.

Later on in Sefer Bereishit,  Joseph is sold as a lowly slave. Yet, through a sequence of events natural in themselves but in consort bearing the hallmark of Divine Providence, he rises from the depths of a dungeon to becoming viceroy of all Egypt enabling him to succour his entire family – the nascent nation of Israel – and save them from the Canaanite famine. Without him having been sold to slavery this would never have happened!

You see, Brad, we never know how things will happen until they happen, often occasioning the most gargantuan surprises. It has occurred in my life, and probably in yours, that what was thought to be a misfortune turned out to be the best thing that could have transpired!

When Moses asks on Mount Sinai to know G-D’s ways (33:13) G-D replies that “no human can ‘see’ Me and live” (33:20) instead G-D shows Moses a vision of His “back” (33:22).

What does this figurative anthropomorphism mean? R’ Saadia Gaon and Ralbag, among other rabbinic commentators, explain that sometimes while we cannot hope to know why tsadik ver-ra lo ve-rasha ve-tov lo, why the righteous so often appear to suffer while the wicked appear to prosper, yet with the benefit of hindsight (symbolised by G-D’s ‘back’) we can sometimes see why the Supreme Architect had deemed it necessary to plan things to pan out the way they did.

Brad, if you are asking me, a rabbi, a question like this, I am sure you are a believer.  So let go and let G-D! He has it all worked out!

We are riding a pulse-pounding, adrenaline-charged, white-knuckle, ginormous global roller-coaster presently. Its operator has infinite experience. He is in total control.

So let’s let out a scream or two if we must,  then take a few deep breaths, exhale, hold on tight and trust we will emerge from the turbulent ride not only unscathed but immeasurably strengthened and energised by the experience!

About the Author
Rabbi Chaim Ingram is the author of five books on Judaism. He is a senior tutor for the Sydney Beth Din and the non-resident rabbi of the Adelaide Hebrew Congregation. He can be reached at judaim@bigpond.net.au
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.