Danny Shapiro

Three Promises. One Urgent Priority: Bibi Has Got to Go

Forming Israel’s next government will require painful compromises. One election promise must not be abandoned.

AI-generated illustration based on Knesset Spokesperson’s Office photos.

The elections are behind us, coalition negotiations are well underway, and Israelis are following every twist and turn with a mixture of hope, anxiety, and growing impatience. Every declaration by a party leader, every rumored meeting, every apparent shift in position is immediately dissected by television commentators and social media pundits.

My advice? Have a little patience. We’re watching political negotiations. Much of what we’re hearing is designed to strengthen bargaining positions, reassure nervous supporters, or test potential partners. And much of it is meant to build alibis – not only in case the talks fail, but even more so if they succeed through painful compromise. If Eisenkot ends up forming a government with Arab support or participation at the eleventh hour, he, Bennett, and Lieberman will need to tell their voters: We tried everything, we had no choice – it was either this, breaking our central promise to oust Bibi, or dragging the country to new elections.

I get why journalists and pundits are obsessing over every twist and turn. This is the biggest political story in the country, people are riveted, and there’s endless airtime to fill. In the digital equivalent of a Roman gladiator show, you have to throw the lions their red meat. The political theatre pays the bills.

What is driving me crazy, however, is the endless, sanctimonious whining about broken election promises. Did Lieberman break his pledge? Is Bennett betraying his voters? Every politician breaks promises – including, richly and abundantly, Netanyahu himself.

So spare me the theatrical outrage: Voters handed the Knesset a mathematical puzzle in which the anti-Netanyahu parties simply cannot fulfill all their commitments simultaneously. The real question isn’t who breaks a promise – it’s which promises can be compromised, and which absolutely must be kept.

Three Promises, One Supreme Priority

The four Jewish opposition parties made three central commitments:

  1. Netanyahu must go.
  2. End the outrageous Haredi military draft exemption (and for some, exclude ultra-Orthodox parties from the coalition).
  3. Establish a “Zionist” government that does not rely on Arab parties.

Look at the math. A governing majority requires 61 seats. Netanyahu’s bloc won 53, the four Jewish opposition parties won 48, and the two Arab parties won 19. Without Likud, the Haredim, or the Arab parties, there aren’t enough seats to govern. Something has to give.

Anyone who reads me knows I passionately support including Arab citizens in government – not as an unfortunate necessity, but as a moral and political imperative. And nobody needs to convince me that the Haredi draft exemption is morally indefensible, economically destructive, and an insult to everyone who serves. I care deeply about both causes. Yet neither can be allowed to prevent the removal of Benjamin Netanyahu.

While practical concerns about the stability of a government reliant on the Joint List are real, that is a problem to solve, not an excuse to surrender. Voters themselves understand this: a recent Jewish People Policy Institute survey found that 52 percent of Eisenkot’s voters, and a 49 percent of Bennett’s, prefer a change government with Arab parties over unity with Likud. And I’d bet those numbers would rise considerably if voters were confronted with the real choice: a government supported by Arab parties, another Netanyahu government, or yet another election. Netanyahu’s removal isn’t one promise among three equals; it is the overriding purpose for which these parties were elected.

Voters delivered a clear mandate: anti-Netanyahu parties won 67 of the Knesset’s 120 seats – 56 percent of parliament. Yet we are subjected to the disingenuous claim, from Bibi on down, that “unity is the will of the people.” That trick relies on erasing the 19 Arab MKs – nearly 16 percent of the Knesset – from the equation, exposing the racism behind the notion that only a Jewish-majority coalition holds legitimacy.

Beyond the math, a Netanyahu-led unity government is a nonstarter for two decisive reasons. First, it would be political suicide for Eisenkot, Bennett, Lieberman, or Golan to hand two more years to the very man they campaigned to oust. Second, Netanyahu himself – not just Ben-Gvir and Smotrich – is the obstacle to Israel’s recovery. Israel must rebuild its international legitimacy, repair its democratic institutions, and heal deep societal rifts. The strategic statesman of 15 years ago ‒ Bibi 1.0 – is gone; Netanyahu has burned his credibility and become a global red flag. Nothing can turn this clock back: Reshuffling his cabinet won’t rehabilitate him, nor can you rebuild national trust with a man whose entire political operation relies on demonizing his opponents as enemies of the state.

And now, as I write, the unfolding scandal over Netanyahu’s “stop the steal” narrative is getting uglier by the hour. Information passed directly to the police through Netanyahu’s own chief of staff triggered dramatic election-morning raids and arrests of Arab activists over unsubstantiated vote-buying claims (which have already been refuted), a spectacle Netanyahu immediately exploited to delegitimize an election he had lost. Investigators are now examining whether the police were deliberately manipulated to manufacture that exact pretext.

Think about what we’re dealing with: not just another barrage of lies and incitement, but the potential weaponization of law enforcement to subvert the democratic process. As Gadi Eisenkot put it unequivocally, “Under no circumstances must Netanyahu be allowed to remain at the helm of government for even one minute longer.”

“Only Bibi Can”: The Politics of Blackmail

Recently, respected public intellectual Micah Goodman argued in a conversation with Haviv Rettig Gur, titled “The Case for A Unity Government”, that seizing post-war regional diplomatic opportunities requires a broad government, and that an Eisenkot-led coalition backed by Arab parties would be paralyzed by ferocious opposition from Netanyahu’s political machine. Goodman’s solution? A unity government with Netanyahu serving as prime minister for the first two years.

This stands the old Israeli adage that “only the right can make peace” on its head. Historically, leaders like Begin and Sharon could use their right-wing credentials to persuade supporters to accept painful territorial compromises.

This new “Only Bibi Can” argument boils down to this: Because Netanyahu can mobilize his supporters to destroy the legitimacy of any government that replaces him, we have no choice but to leave him in power. That’s political blackmail.

We saw Netanyahu’s “poison machine” tear into the Bennett-Lapid government in 2021, and we saw it throughout the four year tenure of the outgoing government and the election campaign, and again on November 10, when Netanyahu stood before the new Knesset, called for “unity,” and immediately launched a venomous attack on Arab parties and anyone considering partnering with them.

The poison machine has been in high gear for most of the past decade, and it will not rest now.

Accepting Goodman’s logic sets a grotesque precedent: the more effectively you demonize opponents and wreck the country’s cohesion, the more indispensable you become. Lose an election? Just make the alternative look ungovernable until your rivals come crawling back.

Furthermore, we already know what a Netanyahu power-sharing deal is worth. In 2020, he promised Benny Gantz a premiership rotation on live television – “no tricks, no shticks.” Seven months later, Netanyahu exploited a budget loophole to collapse the government and rob Gantz of his turn. Why on earth would Eisenkot or anyone else trust him now?

Keep your eye on the ball

Coalition negotiations are messy and often go down to the wire. In June 2021, Yair Lapid secured a government less than forty minutes before his mandate expired. I don’t know how these talks will end. What I do know is that Israel needs years of responsible governance to recover from the Netanyahu era, and that recovery cannot begin with Benjamin Netanyahu still sitting in the prime minister’s chair.

The opposition made three promises. Two are negotiable political goals; the third is existential. Getting Netanyahu out isn’t just another item on the negotiating table – it is the reason the table exists, the whole ballgame. We have endured too much and fought too hard to hand him two more years out of fear.

Keep your eye on the ball. Bibi has got to go. The rest is negotiable.

About the Author
Danny Shapiro has lived in Israel since 1980. Over a 35-year career, he worked in public affairs, fundraising and strengthening ties between Israel and Jewish communities around the world, including senior positions at several major Israeli institutions. A progressive Zionist, he writes about Israeli politics, democracy, Zionism, and Israel's relationship with the United States and the Jewish world. He lives in Tel Aviv and publishes regularly on Substack.
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.