Tikvah in the Desert
The sound of the explosion pierced the quiet morning air in Kfar Aza. The ground shook in the kibbutz not more than two miles from where reported IDF air strikes and artillery fire were taking place in Gaza. Another explosion was heard. Minutes passed. And then I heard the words, “If we don’t make peace with our enemy,” the thought interrupted by the third and final strike I would feel reverberating through my bones, “that’s what happens.”
Those words were spoken by Shachar Shnurman, the first Kfar Aza resident who returned to the kibbutz after Hamas terrorists attacked it on October 7. I was there last week with a delegation of American Jewish communal leaders touring some of the bullet-riddled, burned out homes that remain after that fateful morning three years ago, learning the stories of murdered residents.
It would be tragically understandable for any remaining empathy for Palestinians to be extinguished in someone like Shachar. Yet I was impressed by what remained, even if framed pragmatically: “They’re my enemy, but they’re still my neighbor. . . . If they don’t have a good life, I don’t have a good life.”
That same day, about 50 miles northeast of Kfar Aza, I sat in the home of Elana Kaminka, the mother of Lieutenant Yannai Kaminka, z”l. Yannai died on October 7 defending his trainees on their army base in Zikim. Elana graciously welcomed us into her home, with a focus not on how Yannai died, but on who he was and how he lived. She shared parts of her own journey, including joining the Parents Circle – Families Forum, a group of Palestinian and Israeli families who have lost family members due to the conflict. In her grief, no one would have faulted Elana for turning inward, for turning her back on her Palestinian neighbors of Wadi Fukin, a village located in the valley just below Elana’s town. Instead, while sitting shiva for Yannai, she wrote them a letter, writing in part, “As I experience this pain, I also see you. My heart is open to you. I do not blame you for the deeds of Hamas, and I hope that this horrific situation will somehow lead our peoples to learn, at long last, how to live together with mutual respect, so that there will be no more parents – Israelis or Palestinians – who will grieve for their children.”
Days later our group met with IDF reservist Col. Doron Meinert, who has been in the news for providing protective presence to Palestinians being targeted by Jewish settler terrorists. We met at the ruins of Al Mu’arrajat East, a Palestinian Bedouin village that was previously home to about 120 residents with more than half being children. The residents were forcibly displaced a year ago due to settler terrorism. Israelis like Doron see the occupation as the existential threat it is for Israel and are on the frontlines, placing themselves between settlers and the Palestinians they want to expel, bringing their experiences and the ugliness of the occupation back to inform Israeli society.
There were, of course, Palestinian voices as well. The doctor in Gaza whom we had to conference in via Zoom who just became a father himself. The villagers of Umm Al-Khair in the West Bank who are under constant threat, from looming demolition orders to the settlers living mere feet from them and harassing them regularly. The officials and civil society leaders in Ramallah advocating for Palestinian Authority reforms and improved relations with their Israeli counterparts.
Throughout the week, the challenges within Israeli and Palestinian societies, and between them, were glaringly apparent. These two peoples are far from a meaningful peace, and each will need to make hard internal changes before reaching such a point. Yet the theme that carried through the week was that of tikvah, hope. Hope persisting, and hope attacked.
Hope persisted where there was little reason to expect it. It was in Shachar, who came home to a kibbutz of burned-out houses and worse and still insists that his enemy is also his neighbor. It was in Elana, who, in the rawest days of shiva, chose to look down the valley toward Wadi Fukin and write, “I also see you.” It was in a doctor in Gaza who had just become a father, and in activists in Ramallah still pressing for reform and partnership.
And hope was under attack–in Al Mu’arrajat East, in Umm Al-Khair, in Hebron. What I saw in the West Bank was a perversion of the Zionist project and of what Israel’s founders envisioned, a state whose Declaration of Independence promised complete equality of social and political rights to all its inhabitants. It is Israelis like Doron who understand that such destructive, terrorizing action threatens not only Palestinians but Israel itself.
The Middle East is often thought of as a desert, and the last three years have left it particularly harsh and arid. But like water in the desert, I found hope in unexpected places last week. It would be easy to overlook these hints scattered throughout the region. Like tiny droplets beneath the coarse surface, they signal that a wellspring lies deep below, waiting to be tapped. Israel’s national anthem is “Hatikvah.” But Israel’s hope, and that of the Jewish people, does not need to be–and should not be–contingent on denying another people theirs. The people I met this past week, Israeli and Palestinian alike, are digging, searching, and in some cases safeguarding the reservoir. Our task is to help them reach the water.
