Jan Shure

Time to revisit Balen as part of independent enquiry into BBC bias

As we approach the end of another year in which Jews have continued to face bullying, threat and overt hate, perhaps we should consider whether the avalanche of Jew-hate that has engulfed the West might have been minimized – or even averted altogether – if the anti-Israel bias allegedly rampant in the late 1990s and early noughties at one of the  planet’s most trusted and renowned news organisations had been properly investigated and the findings had led to changes in personnel or news practices.

Oh no, wait, the anti-Israel bias allegedly rampant in the late ‘90s and early noughties at one of the  planet’s most trusted and renowned news organisations was investigated – though perhaps not “properly.” And certainly not independently. And, of course, its findings were never made public.

So let’s remind ourselves of the circumstances that led to the creation of “The Balen Report”.  In 2004, following allegations from UK Jewish communal leaders and the Israeli government of persistent anti-Israel bias at the BBC, the then BBC Director of News commissioned an investigation of the BBC’s coverage of Israel-Palestine.

The man assigned to investigate was Malcolm Balen, “a senior news editor” at the BBC with “over two decades of experience” at the corporation. The man on the payroll examined “thousands of hours” of the BBC’s coverage, and produced a 20,000-word document which became known, somewhat unimaginatively, as “The Balen Report”.

As previously mentioned, the report has never been made public despite pressure from Jewish communal bodies, despite petitions, despite Freedom of Information submissions and despite lengthy legal wrangles that have allegedly cost the BBC approaching half-a-million pounds.

Permit me here to offer an example of the kind of coverage which, in the late ‘90s and the early years of this millennium provoked such outrage in the UK Jewish community and in the Israeli government that an investigation into anti-Israel bias was deemed essential. The example offered below of a typically one-sided BBC News Report should remind us all how the BBC succeeded in promulgating a fake narrative of Palestine victimhood that laid the foundations for global anti-Israelism and the subsequent global upsurge in Jew-hate.

Its methods then – and, of course, subsequently – included careful selectivity with facts; the even more careful omission of vital context; and the consistent framing of Israel’s defence of its citizens against an intensive campaign of murderous terrorism as “aggression” and/or “repression” – and all of it achieved because a significant number of BBC journalists or editors appeared to have swapped journalism for ideology.

Picture the scene: it is the late 1990s or early noughties in Ramallah (or Nablus or Jenin, or basically anywhere in the Palestinian territories). A BBC camera crew is filming for the broadcaster’s news bulletins which are seen across the globe as well in millions of UK households. The camera pans over a scene of devastation. Weeping and wailing Palestinians sit amid the rubble of “their home.” The reporter – and we can take our pick from Plett, Doucet, Guerin, Keane or perhaps even Bowen back then – is carefully informing viewers that the family is mourning their dead son and that this “Palestinian family home” was “destroyed by the IDF.”  The reporter will probably slip in – as inconspicuously as possible – that the son being so pitifully mourned for the cameras, was a suicide bomber. But the details of their deed – their responsibility for murdering or maiming dozens of Israeli civilians on a bus, in a market, in a café, in a pizza restaurant or perhaps in a bar – will certainly not be part of the “package”. And whichever of the BBC’s finest was reporting this story (and, obviously, I use “finest” ironically), he/she would do his/her utmost to ignore the principle of cause and effect, by ignoring the terrorist son’s action and focusing on the demolition which would inevitably be framed as an act of Israeli  “brutality” against a “tragically bereaved” Palestinian family. There would certainly be no mention of the generous rewards to the families of suicide bombers such as million-dollar payouts, pensions and new homes.

Apart from ignoring the lavish financial incentives,  the BBC’s jaw-droppingly biased reports also deliberately ignored the geopolitical context of this orchestrated, lavishly funded murderous Palestinian terror campaign: that it had been launched to ensure that the peace deal hammered out in Oslo could not survive; that there would never be peace, prosperity or Statehood for Palestinians, and that those funding the Palestinian leadership could go right back to their real agenda which was the destruction of the single, tiny Jewish state.

It can be argued that the demolition of the family homes of Palestinian suicide bombers was a misguided policy whose main success was radicalising others and recruiting a fresh cohort of volunteers for a martyr’s death.  But there is also not the slightest doubt that the blatantly one-sided, biased way in which this policy was reported by the BBC won millions of Western supporters (including many Jews) over to the Palestinian “cause”.

If you are wondering why I am revisiting the BBC’s Balen Report, now, some 20-plus years since it was compiled (and when, frankly, its contents seems almost irrelevant given the tsunami of Jew-hate that erupted the day after October 7 2023) it’s because I can’t help wondering how different the world might look for Jews in 2026  if the Balen Report had been published. And if its publication had led to the wholesale removal of journalists or editors who had swapped journalism for ideology. And if it had led to closer scrutiny of news practices.

We have a smoking gun

I can’t help thinking that if the long-buried Balen Report had confirmed the anti-Israel bias at BBC News in that period – and I don’t have the slightest doubt that it did, because if it did not why for 22 years, has the BBC wriggled and weaselled its way out of revealing its contents  – then we have a smoking gun. We have clear evidence that the BBC’s bias provably and demonstrably played a significant role in global anti-Israelism and has therefore also played a significant role in the global upsurge in Jew-hate and antisemitism that was its consequence.

For 26 years, Earl Spencer continued to demand an enquiry into the deceit and trickery at the BBC that led to that explosive and self-immolating Panorama interview with his late sister. It took 26 years, but ultimately the trickery, double-dealing and cover-ups were laid bare by the Dyson Report in 2021.

For an even longer period of time, the BBC  has been creating and consolidating anti-Israelism and anti-Zionism and fanning the flames of Jew-hate. As the victims of this tsunami of hate that has crashed across the globe in the last three years, UK Jews deserve a fresh investigation into anti-Israel bias at the  BBC just as Earl Spencer deserved that investigation on behalf of the late Princess of Wales.  And it can’t be the BBC marking its own homework this time. As the victims, Jews deserve a high-powered and independent public enquiry like that conducted by Lord Dyson into the Panorama deceit; one that examines the BBC’s long-term role in creating anti-Israelism and Jew-hate, and one that finally reveals the findings of Balen to determine whether the flames of Jew-hate might have been extinguished two decades ago if the report had been published and if idealogues had been prevented from replacing journalists.

About the Author
Jan Shure held senior editorial roles at the Jewish Chronicle for three decades. and previously served as deputy editor of the Jewish Observer. She is an author and freelance writer and wrote regularly for the Huffington Post until 2018. In 2012 she took a break from journalism to be a web entrepreneur.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Comments
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.