Tough US Love Can Save Israel

The political change in the United States frightens many Israelis. They fear the loss of American support, restrictions on military operational freedom, and diplomatic pressure that will harm Israel’s security. But if Israel manages it correctly, this change might be the greatest opportunity we’ve had in years to secure our future. True friends tell each other the truth, even when it is unpleasant. To maintain our most important alliance, we must first and foremost listen.
For decades, Washington has provided Israel with almost unconditional support: political backing, advanced weaponry, and massive financial aid. Has this policy made Israel safer? The situation is clear. We are approaching the 60th year of military occupation; the West Bank is descending into a reality of annexation, and the IDF is failing to stop Jewish terrorism. Gaza is devastated, but Hamas still exists as a terrorist organization, and the IDF is mired in a campaign without a clear strategic horizon. The fronts in Lebanon and Syria remain open, and Israel is more isolated than ever. This isolation is not just an image problem; it is a strategic danger to our national security.
The war with Iran did not solve the problem. The regime still possesses significant nuclear capabilities and enriched material that allow it to advance toward a bomb, and it may even be more motivated to do so now. The war, which never received broad support from the American public, intensified American fatigue with military involvement in the Middle East. The results of the midterm elections and the criticism that followed illustrated how much the war has become a political burden on the administration. More and more Americans, including Trump supporters, are asking why the United States is being dragged into costly wars in the Middle East and what American interests they serve. Growing segments of the American public and political system perceive Israel as pushing the United States into this involvement.
In Washington, both Democrats and influential parts of the Republican Party conclude that it is time for a new strategy in relations with Israel. The emerging understanding is that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and especially the Israeli government’s refusal to address its resolution, is one of the main factors contributing to regional instability and harming American interests and those of its allies. Therefore, support for Israel will not disappear, but it is expected to shift from unconditional support to a partnership based on clear interests, values, and conditions. One of the main conditions will be progress toward a demilitarized Palestinian state within the framework of a regional arrangement.
Contrary to the Israeli right’s campaign of fear, such a shift does not necessarily mean abandoning Israel. On the contrary, such a shift could be the way to save Israel from a future of occupation, isolation, and endless conflict.
Traditional American policy has allowed Israeli governments to repeatedly postpone crucial decisions for our future. Unconditional support is not necessarily support for Israel’s long-term interests. Sometimes it allows the government to continue a policy that endangers the state without facing the political and strategic consequences. Right now, American diplomacy is creating an opportunity to change direction and ensure Israel’s future as the democratic nation-state of the Jewish people.
From a partnership of dependence to a partnership of interests
The Trump administration has already announced its intention to stop direct subsidies for the purchase of American weapons, and Netanyahu has agreed to this change. Both parties in the United States support this trend. It is becoming increasingly difficult to justify to American taxpayers subsidizing arms purchases for a country with one of the world’s highest GDPs per capita. Moreover, it is appropriate for Israel to gradually transition from a dependency on American aid to a partnership based on shared interests.
But the more important question is not just who pays for the weapons, but what purpose they serve. The sale of offensive weapons to Israel will need to comply with American law and also serve the values and interests of the United States. Future deals will be examined on their merits, and the American ability to condition them will become a lever to promote policies that serve both countries and American partners in the region.
Israel has a paramount interest in maintaining the American commitment to its defense against real threats. Therefore, continued cooperation is essential. There is no question that defense systems like Iron Dome, Arrow, and David’s Sling are useful. There is no logic in harming Israel’s defensive capability. What is needed is an examination of every sale of American offensive weapons to see whether it truly serves Israel’s security for deterrence or a justified response. Funding prolonged and expensive wars that deepen Israel’s isolation and fail to provide sustainable security is illogical.
Iran: Not every threat can be resolved through war.
The same logic applies to Iran. Months of fighting did not remove the nuclear threat nor guarantee the end of Iranian aggression in the region. Military force alone is not a strategy. Smart diplomacy, supported by credible military power and an international coalition, can provide Israel with greater security over time.
The Obama administration proved this point when it built an international coalition that led to the Iran nuclear agreement. The United States should strive for an arrangement that ensures close supervision of the Iranian nuclear program in exchange for measured sanctions relief. At the same time, it should work together with the Gulf states to ensure freedom of navigation in the Strait of Hormuz and to stop the aggression of Iran’s proxies in Lebanon, Gaza, Yemen, and Iraq. Military action should remain an option when an immediate and proven threat arises, but it should not be the default choice.
Israel also has a clear interest in the success of international efforts to strengthen the Lebanese government, so it can regain its sovereignty and disarm Hezbollah. In Syria, Israel needs to support the effort to help the al-Sharaj government unite the religious and ethnic groups in the country and build a stable regime that can prevent Iran from returning to a central position of influence. Israel is safer when its neighbors are stable and sovereign, not when they become battlegrounds for regional wars.
The Palestinian issue is primarily an Israeli problem.
But above all the military threats, there must seep into Israel the understanding that the greatest strategic danger to our future is not only military. Without a solution to the conflict and without a Palestinian state, Israel will ultimately have to choose between being the nation-state of the Jewish people and being a democracy. It is impossible to continue to control millions of Palestinians without national and political rights for an extended period and expect that this will not change the character of the state. Every new settlement and every step of annexation brings us closer to a bloody bi-national reality from which it will be very difficult to extricate ourselves.
To help Israel escape the political and cognitive trap it has put itself in, the United States must lead a regional and international initiative to establish a demilitarized Palestinian state. This is not about compromising Israel’s security but rather about creating a reality where Israeli security also relies on arrangements, regional guarantees, and international cooperation, and not just on ongoing military control.
The United States should recognize a demilitarized Palestinian state and lead a regional effort to assist in building its institutions, strengthening the Palestinian Authority, and ensuring free and fair elections. Participation in elections should be conditional on an explicit commitment to renounce violence and support for terrorism. At the same time, outdated legal barriers in the relations between the United States and the Palestinians should be removed, and efforts should be made with international partners to improve Palestinian governance.
Clear demands from Israel should also accompany this move. It must transfer to the Palestinian Authority the billions of shekels it is withholding from Palestinian tax revenues, which it is owed under the agreements. Targeted sanctions should be imposed on those responsible for the violence of extremist settlers, and the expansion of settlements and annexation measures should be halted. Israel must understand that continued subsidization of the settlement enterprise could seriously damage its relations with the United States and Europe. This situation is a choice between a narrow sectoral and political interest and Israel’s national interest.
Gaza: Security through arrangement, not through prolonged occupation
In Gaza, Israel’s interest is clear: Hamas must lose its military and governing capabilities, but Israel cannot remain responsible for Gaza in the long term. American policy should lead a gradual process of disarming Hamas, with the assistance of Egypt, Qatar, and Turkey, and with the participation of a Palestinian technocratic government that would serve as a governing alternative to the terrorist organization.
Washington should resolutely lead the diplomatic effort to implement Trump’s 20-point plan and the 15 points announced by the UN Special Coordinator for the Middle East Peace Process, Nickolay Mladenov, which include the gradual disarmament of Hamas, a gradual Israeli withdrawal, and the transfer of security and governance to legitimate Palestinian authorities. Only a credible political settlement that ensures Gaza does not become a base for terrorism against Israel will allow the Gulf states and the international community to invest the enormous resources needed for the reconstruction of the Strip.
At the same time, there is no justification for waiting for an agreement to alleviate the humanitarian distress. We must increase immediate assistance to the residents of Gaza to prevent the continuation of their terrible suffering. This approach is also a way to protect Israeli interests: to reduce hostility, prevent a prolonged humanitarian disaster, and create conditions for a different reality.
An alliance with America also requires shared values.
Even on the international stage, the United States needs to adopt a balanced policy. It should vote at the United Nations against decisions that unjustly discriminate against Israel, but not automatically defend it when the criticism is justified and reflects American values and interests. Such conduct could actually strengthen Israel’s position and reduce the political use against it in international institutions.
The same principle applies in the fight against antisemitism. The United States needs to lead a genuine and resolute national strategy against antisemitism from both the right and the left. But legitimate criticism of the Israeli government’s policies must not be defined as antisemitism, nor should this important struggle be used to harm freedom of speech, universities, or immigrant rights. True protection for Jews and Israel requires distinguishing between hatred of Jews and opposition to the policies of a specific government.
The historic choice facing Israel
In the end, the United States needs to present a clear choice to the Israeli public. On one hand, there is a future that integrates Israel into the regional space, with peace with its neighbors, including a demilitarized Palestinian state, economic and security cooperation, and international acceptance.
On the other hand, the continuation of the occupation, the conflict, the annexation, and the deepening isolation, even within American society.
The advantage for Israel in choosing the 23-state framework is immense. Israel will be able to ensure its security within recognized borders, live in peace with all its neighbors, and be part of a regional space in cooperation and prosperity. It will be able to preserve its identity as the democratic nation-state of the Jewish people and provide the next generations with a future not based on endless war. This vision is, ultimately, the realization of the founders’ dream.
There will be those who will call such an American policy an abandonment. But it is worth asking what abandonment really is. Is abandonment demanding that Israel stop policies that endanger its future or allow it to continue without limits, with generous funding and political backing, even as it becomes an isolated state, under continuous occupation and in an endless war?
True support for Israel does not mean giving a “blank check” to any government or any policy. True support for Israel means committing to help it reach the future promised by its founders in the Declaration of Independence: security, peace, equality, and democracy.
Israel needs a strong America, but also a brave America that is willing to tell it the truth. And the responsibility for changing this direction cannot rest solely with Washington. It is primarily our responsibility, the citizens of Israel. Tikkun olam begins with tikkun of ourselves.
