Unity Government as Bibi Defines It
Ever since Gadi Eisenkot was given the mandate by Israeli President Herzog to form a government, there has been intense political activity (some would term it horse trading) in Israel given the 30-day time limit attendant to the life of the mandate.
In the interim, the Knesset members elected in the October 27th vote have now been sworn in and a new speaker of the Knesset has been elected as well. Although a clear majority of the 120-member body voted for the new speaker, a segment of the population has raised the ugly specter of whether a speaker can be considered legitimately elected if it took Arab Israeli members of parliament to create the majority.
I have chosen to use the term “ugly specter” intentionally, as those who attempt to bifurcate the Knesset body by charging that the votes of the19 Arab Israeli members do not have the same level of agency as do those of the Jewish parliament members make it much easier for our enemies to accuse us of being an apartheid state.
After all, what is the definition of apartheid if it is not considering the votes of certain members of the Knesset less legitimate than others based on race or ethnicity? Need we be reminded, once again, of the text of the founding document of the State of Israel, where it is written:
The State of Israel will be open to the immigration of Jews from all countries of their dispersion; will promote the development of the country for the benefit of all its inhabitants; will be based on the precepts of liberty, justice, and peace taught by the Hebrew Prophets; will uphold the full social and political equality of all its citizens, without distinction of race, creed, or sex; will guarantee full freedom of conscience, worship, education, and culture; will safeguard the sanctity and inviolability of the shrines and Holy Places of all religions; and will dedicate itself to the principles of the Charter of the United Nations.
Perhaps this document should be read aloud at the initial convening of each elected Knesset.
During these last two weeks of political activity, there has been talk of a unity government with some form of rotation at the prime ministerial level between Netanyahu and Eisenkot and perhaps the inclusion of all of the Zionist parties given that Zionism is also a founding principle of the State.
The thought of a unity government is certainly appealing and in this time of crisis would, if properly constructed, seem to make a great deal of sense. Except, of course, that we are dealing with a sitting prime minister whose clear goal, as demonstrated by his actions, is to remain in office at all costs.
Over this past weekend, Netanyahu’s representatives put out a list of principles/demands/expectations, call them what you will, that would have to be agreed to by any party that joins his unity government.
These include…..
First, confirm that Netanyahu will remain prime minister for another four years ruling out a rotation agreement that would allow Eisenkot to assume the premiership. This is not likely to be accepted by the “change bloc” given that Eisenkot has indicated that he would consider a unity government with Likud only if he leads it.
Second, preserve Netanyahu’s existing political alliances so that all his present coalition partners can participate in the new government, including National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir’s Otzma Yehudit party. Yet another unlikely option, given that probably 70% of the country is dead set against Ben Gvir remaining in government.
Third, prevent the establishment of a state commission of inquiry into the Hamas massacre as is customary under Israeli law for events of the magnitude of October 7th. Remember, a state commission of inquiry operates under an established legal framework in which the president of the Supreme Court appoints its members.
Netanyahu has constantly indicated that he prefers a six-member politically appointed investigative panel to conduct the review so that individuals who have held certain senior positions since June 6, 2004 (presumably many of whom are not Netanyahu supporters) would be barred from serving on the commission.
According to a report in the Times of Israel, “those excluded would include Supreme Court justices, government ministers, senior military officers holding the rank of major general or above, Shin Bet directors and their deputies, attorneys general, military advocates general and Shin Bet legal advisers. The restrictions would exclude a broad range of former senior officials with direct experience in Israel’s security, military and legal institutions.”
Fourth, that the judicial overhaul legislation enacted during the previous Knesset would remain in force unless coalition partners mutually agreed to changes. This was the legislation that created the massive demonstrations in Israel for the first 10 months of 2023 that brought millions of Israelis into the streets to protest what was perceived as yet another nail in the coffin of Israeli democracy.
Fifth, on the issue of the drafting of ultra-Orthodox men (commonly referred to as Haredim), Netanyahu wants the next government to advance legislation that would provide more lenient sanctions for ultra-Orthodox men who fail to comply with military enlistment requirements even though the IDF is desperate for new recruits given the ongoing security challenges faced by Israel.
Sixth, it was also reported that Netanyahu will require coalition members to commit to supporting any future military campaign he authorizes against Iran. As for the ongoing military actions in Gaza, Lebanon and Syria, there is a concomitant demand that coalition partners agree to prevent Israeli forces from withdrawing from their existing military positions until the relevant security threats have been eliminated.
As if this was not enough to scuttle any possibility of a unity government, Netanyahu’s people more recently added a demand to end political boycotts and personal attacks against Netanyahu and his political allies. And of course, no one was surprised at the latest addition, a call for the unity agreement to exclude parties that are accused of supporting terrorism and opposing Israel’s existence as a Jewish state, an apparent reference to the Arab-led Ra’am and Joint List parties.
For the record, the most recent versions of these demands published by the Likud did not explicitly demand that Netanyahu remain prime minister for four years, nor did they repeat the reported requirements concerning the October 7 investigative commission and preservation of judicial overhaul legislation.
No doubt each day will continue to produce further new versions of a possible agreement, new frameworks for a pathway to government by Eisenkot and Netanyahu’s people as well as total frustration with the whole process on the part of the electorate.
Sadly, it seems that the Likud representatives have failed to learn the lesson martyred former US President John F. Kennedy meant to teach when he said: “We cannot negotiate with people who say what’s mine is mine and what’s yours is negotiable.” Perhaps they should go back to civics class and hit the books a bit more pragmatically.
