Boaz Dvir

Unmasking the Cool Factor

The Cool Factor has played a key though unacknowledged role in the so-called culture war over COVID-blocking facial masks. Photo by Boaz Dvir

The Cool Factor—possessed by some, recognized by all—could help us defeat COVID-19 and, quite possibly, future pandemics.

Before I get to the virus that’s been attacking our lungs, heart, kidneys, vascular system, taste/smell, and sanity, I’d like to take a moment to break down why I hold the Cool Factor in such high regard. I first experienced its power in the 1990s when my social standing collapsed like an Antarctic ice shelf after I became, for humanitarian and environmental reasons, an uncool vegan. Walking away from burgers and hot dogs at barbecues and Super Bowl parties, I removed my name from guest lists; declining to share cheesecakes and crèmes brûlées with dates, I soured my appeal.

Over the years, my respect for the Cool Factor has only grown as I watched it demolish smoking, fur-wearing, masochism and other trendy behaviors and attitudes.

Unlike trends—think office high-fiving, Vanilla Ice, and neon-colored blow-up chairs—truly cool behaviors, artists, and objects are timeless. Beyoncé and Johnny Cash have always been and will always be cool, while Celine Dion and Neil Diamond have not and never will be. Banksy? Forever cool. PBS’ painter-by-numbers Bob Ross? Eternally uncool (and, along with his hypnotized fans, basking in it). “Car Talk”? Effortlessly cool. The numerous podcasts giving tips to used-car salesmen? Walk away. Barefoot on a beach? Timeless. Socks in sandals? Thanks to Kendall Jenner and Kanye West, it may be trendy, but it will never become bona fide cool.

The Cool Factor, I believe, has played a key though unacknowledged role in the so-called culture war over COVID-blocking facial masks. It’s not yet cool in our society to put them on. In many parts of our country, it’s downright uncool.

A quick glance at social media posts and local government recordings appears to indicate that this has become a political issue. For instance, at last week’s Palm Beach County Commission meeting, anti-maskers defended their right to spread a fatal disease on conservative constitutional, religious, and personal freedom grounds. “I don’t wear a mask for the same reason I don’t wear underwear,” said a woman who may have lost her common sense but has kept her sense of humor. “Things gotta breathe.” (The commission voted unanimously to mandate masks.)

But politics offer only a partial explanation. If we were embroiled in a culture war, liberals would wear masks. Yet a large number do not. I know just as many mask refuseniks on the left as on the right. I live in a progressive bastion, a college town, and I only occasionally see folks cover the lower half of their faces. When I do—mostly in places that require them, like supermarkets—I notice that people often wear them incorrectly, some perhaps unknowingly, others maybe purposely, sticking out their noses as if holding up a middle finger.

This, in face of recent studies showing that wearing masks—and doing so properly and consistently—could help control COVID’s cancer-like advance. For instance, the University of Washington’s Institute for Health Metrics has concluded, after examining a slew of data, that “widespread mask use may temper or even help prevent a second wave.”

The institute estimates that if 95 percent of us wore masks, we’d keep the Angel of Death away from 33,000 Americans.

Masks are far from a panacea. A study practically proclaiming as such has drawn criticism from several researchers, who’ve demanded that the Proceedings of National Academy of Sciences, a peer-reviewed journal, retract it. In reality, facial covering will not eliminate all of COVID’s death, destruction, and delusion. But there’s no doubt that this inexpensive form of defense belongs in our collective and individual arsenal and should become a new-normal lifestyle fixture.

Look, I get masks’ downsides. They hide some of our expressions, potentially turning social distancing into social dissing. They sometimes cause acne, better known as maskne. They’re uncomfortable. They can instill a false sense of security, leading to possible, dangerous neglect of social distancing and hand washing. And they increase the excessive number of times we already touch our faces.

Nonetheless, they save lives. Yours, theirs, ours.

So, how do we get 95 percent of Americans to wear them? It’s too late to depoliticize the issue. The more scientific facts and intellectual points of persuasion we throw at anti-maskers, the more entrenched they become in their beliefs and conspiracy theories. Instead, we must stage an innovative campaign to make wearing masks as cool as snapchatting with your friends while kicking back an ice-cold Stone IPA and wiggling your toes in sun-kissed beach sand.

I know, that’s a tall order. It’s tough enough to expunge the Cool Factor from unhealthy behavior such as binge drinking and vaping. To inculcate a controversial concept with coolness would take an ingenious, trail-blasting effort.

So, let’s put our geniuses and trailblazers on it. Besides raising tens of millions of public and private dollars to support this mission, they’d work to:

  • Convince federal, state, and local governments to enact and enforce laws and regulations requiring people to wear masks indoors (excluding daily routines in private homes and automobiles), as well as crowded outdoor venues. For many, a mandate such as a presidential executive order would provide the excuse they’d need to adapt an uncool behavior. True, at the same time, it’d make it even cooler for others to keep masks off their faces. That’s why this is a multipronged plan.
  • Launch an edgy, emotionally engaging ad campaign. Take a page from the anti-smoking movement to instill a new image for masks on platforms ranging from TikTok to TV.
    • Pull out all the stops. Many COVID commercials have been gentle, going for Hallmark-like “inspirational.” Let’s take off the gloves and show suffering, loss, and painful, complicated triumphs.
    • Tell the stories of individuals. When it comes to COVID, we’re bombarded with statistics on a daily basis. We need to humanize this global crisis. It’s time for personal testimonies to take center stage.
  • Learn from other successful and unsuccessful campaigns such as the 2014 Ice Bucket Challenge and the 1980s Just Say No effort, respectively.
  • Get the right celebrities involved. When the Gap announced a partnership with Kayne West last week, its languishing stock spiked 18.8 percent. Although still a year from being unveiled, the Yeezy Gap Collection has rebranded a previously uncool brand.
  • Offer a $1 million innovation prize for mask designers.
    • Let’s see what inventors across the country can create. A transparent mask? A series of masks featuring original artwork? An extremely comfortable yet highly effective mask? One-of-a-kind masks signed by artists?
    • Let’s figure out the best consumer-grade mask. A recent Florida Atlantic University study showed stitching two quilting fabric layers kept sneeze-and-cough droplets from endangering those who practice social distancing. But more work is needed on this front.
  • Recruit icons, thought leaders, influencers, disruptors, and captains of industries such as Oprah, Tim Ferriss, Selena Gomez, Daymond John, and Elon Musk.
  • Petition sports leagues to allow athletes to write pro-mask statements on their uniforms. Go Masks! Beat COVID! (I know, that’s lame. That’s why we need the geniuses.)
  • Enlist fashion houses such as Gucci and Versace to make masks the season’s hottest fashion accessory.
  • Convince stores like American Eagle, Anthropologie. Target, and Walmart to prominently feature masks in their physical and virtual storefronts.
  • Craft targeted messages to different segments of the population.
    • Tell anti-maskers that wearing a mask is patriotic. Because it is.
    • Tell capitalists that a wide use of masks gives businesses a much better chance to reopen and stay open. Because it does. This week, Goldman Sachs chief economist Jan Hatzius said, “a mask mandate could potentially substitute for lockdowns that would otherwise subtract nearly 5 percent from GDP.” That’s about a trillion dollars.
  • Focus on the youth. Everything cool flows from them.

What about us? What can we do? A lot. We can wear masks whenever and wherever needed. We can post photos of ourselves smiling under them. We can avoid the complacency that may result from our mask-wearing and continue to wash our hands and practice social distancing. We can take the 21-Day No Complaining About Masks Challenge. Instead of shaming friends and family members who do not wear them, we can appeal to their emotional side. And we can share images, write ups, ads, and other material that infuse masks with the Cool Factor.

We’re already seeing some progress. Designers such as Fendi, Lisa Says Gah, and Prabal Gurung are manufacturing beautiful masks. This past weekend, New Yorker staff writer Rachel Syme tweeted, “Whoever did the pr in the 90s about cutting open plastic six pack rings so they don’t choke animals … [should be] in charge of the wear a mask campaign.” And on Thursday, Gov. Greg Abbott mandated mask-wearing in most of Texas.

This is just a start. With the help of the Cool Factor, we can popularize other personal protection equipment (PPE)—yes, even the super-duper uncool face shields.

Once we conquer PPE, we can tackle the next necessary behavior in need of a Cool Factor boost: vaccination.

A recent CNN poll shows that, when we’re lucky enough to have a COVID vaccine, only two out of three of Americans would opt to get it. Scientific facts won’t change the minds of the other third. But the Cool Factor? It just might.


About the Author
Boaz Dvir is the author of the critically acclaimed nonfiction book “Saving Israel” (Rowman & Littlefield, 2020), which follows World War II aviators who risked their lives and freedom in 1947-49 to prevent what they viewed as an imminent second Holocaust. Washington Times book reviewer Joshua Sinai described this nonfiction book as a “fascinating and dramatic account filled with lots of new information about a crucially formative period.” A Penn State associate professor, Dvir is the founding director of the Holocaust, Genocide and Human Rights Initiative and the Hammel Family Human Rights Initiative at the university. He's an award-winning filmmaker. He tells the stories of ordinary people who, under extraordinary circumstances, transform into trailblazers who change the world around them. They include an average inner-city schoolteacher who emerges as a disruptive innovator and a national model (Class of Her Own); a World War II flight engineer who transforms into the leader of a secret operation to prevent a second Holocaust (A Wing and a Prayer); an uneducated truck driver who becomes a highly effective child-protection activist (Jessie’s Dad); and a French business consultant who sets out to kill former Nazi officer Klaus Barbie and ends up playing a pivotal role in history’s most daring hostage-rescue operation (Cojot).
Related Topics
Related Posts