Lazer Gurkow

Vayishlach: When Reconciliation Makes Sense

When Jacob prepared to meet Esau after years of estrangement, he had good reason to be wary. Esau was approaching with four hundred men, and it looked like his brother intended to destroy him.

Jacob prepared for war, prayed for protection, and sent gifts ahead to appease his brother. Then, when the two finally met, Jacob bowed seven times before Esau embraced him(Genesis 32:7–33:4).

The Midrash is critical of Jacob’s conduct. It questions why he humbled himself so thoroughly before Esau and suggests that his excessive deference had negative consequences (Bereishit Rabbah 75:3). Yet another Midrashic tradition spoke well of Jacob’s conduct (Yalkut Shimoni, Torah 133).

These opposing perspectives leave us with a perplexing question: Is it right to be obsequious, to show weakness before our enemies, in the hope of preventing conflict and opening a path to reconciliation? Or does such deference come at too high a price?

The Lubavitcher Rebbe once explained it like this (Likutei Sichot 15, pp. 298–301): Jacob lowered himself through his conduct. By bowing to a wicked man, he sullied his own purity. Yet Jacob was willing to pay this price because he had a greater objective than simply protecting himself or asserting his rights. He sought to influence Esau.

Jacob did not expect to turn Esau into a follower. Esau would remain Esau. But something changed. Esau acknowledged Jacob’s claim to the blessings (including the blessing to rule over Esau), embraced him, and even invited him to travel together (Genesis 33:4, 9, 12). As a result of Jacob’s inappropriate deference, Esau was no longer seeking to harm him. Jacob had made it possible for them to coexist.

There are times when standing tall and refusing to compromise is the right thing to do. But there are also times when insisting on our dignity and demanding that the other person submit accomplishes very little. If we want to change someone’s thinking, we may have to meet them where they are, even at the real cost of lowering ourselves. It was a defect. It soiled Jacob’s purity. But it accomplished a larger goal.

The Letter That Crossed Barriers
The Rebbe often advocated negotiations over demonstrations and cooperation over confrontation.

Mapam was a socialist-Zionist party associated with the kibbutz movement and the left wing of the Israeli political spectrum. It accepted Arab members and advocated cooperation between Jews and Arabs.

The Rebbe would pen periodic public letters to all Jews, and Al HaMishmar, Mapam’s daily newspaper, often published them. This was not an obvious home for the Rebbe’s writings. The paper’s readership included secular, socialist-Zionist Jews whose outlook was far removed from the Rebbe’s worldview. It also reached Arab readers who might never have picked up a publication devoted to Torah. One of these readers was Muhammed Wattad, an Arab Israeli Knesset member in the Mapam party.

Rabbi Aharon-Dov Halperin, editor of the Kfar Chabad Magazine, once found himself seated beside Wattad on a flight to Paris. Wattad was on his way to meet with PLO leadership. During their conversation, Wattad spoke about the Rebbe’s letters in Al HaMishmar. He told Halperin how much he enjoyed reading them and described the ideas in the latest letter he had read. He explained that he found the Rebbe’s philosophy enchanting and his pragmatic messaging eminently relatable to all people.

Halperin recognized the letter. He knew it because his newspaper had translated it. When the Hebrew translation was sent to the Rebbe for approval, the Rebbe instructed the editors to replace every occurrence of the word Jew with the word human being.

The change was striking. The Rebbe had shifted the letter from a Jewish to a universal audience. He adapted the language so the ideas could reach readers who might otherwise have felt he was not speaking to them. And the effect was evident in Wattad himself. Here was an Arab Knesset member, on his way to meet PLO leaders, who was deeply moved by Jewish thought. He also defended the continued publication of the letters when Mapam members objected and tried to have them stopped. Wattad argued that the letters were valuable and that readers, including Arabs like himself, benefited from them.

The Rebbe’s audience was twofold. He was reaching Arab readers like Wattad, but he was also reaching the secular Jewish readership of Mapam. The Rebbe did not want to forfeit the opportunity to speak to Jews who might be put off by language that seemed too explicitly religious. He was prepared to adjust how he expressed his ideas so that people who would not ordinarily listen might hear it.

But this adjustment was not without a cost. The Rebbe’s instruction to replace every Jew with human being could be criticized as watering down the distinctively Jewish character of his message, or as blurring the difference between Jew and non-Jew. That criticism would not be baseless. The Rebbe was willing to accept a genuine lowering of his language to reach his readers.

Preserving The Message
Yet there is a difference between adapting the language and diluting the message. Jacob bowed before Esau and addressed him as his master, but he never crossed the line to concede that Esau was right. He lowered his posture, not his convictions. The Rebbe, too, adapted the language of the letter without abandoning its Jewish message, which brings us to the second part of the story.

When the Rebbe’s secretary, Rabbi Klein, later related the Wattad episode to the Rebbe, he explained which letter Wattad had found so compelling. The Rebbe smiled and asked whether Wattad had noticed the heading. The letter’s body had used the word human being, but its heading was still addressed to “all Jewish sons and daughters.” Had Wattad not noticed that? Had that not bothered him?

The Rebbe’s question revealed the boundary of the concession. The language had been made more universal, but the intended message had not changed. The Rebbe had not surrendered the principle. It was still a distinctly Jewish teaching but made accessible to a wider audience.

The Jewish readers of Al Hamishmar didn’t become observant overnight, but they were exposed to Jewish ideas. Wattad didn’t abandon his political philosophy and commitments. He remained on his way to meet PLO leadership. But he had come to appreciate Jewish thought and had a meaningful discussion with a religious Jew. As a result, he even suggested areas in which Jews and Arabs might work together. He had moved in a meaningful way. To the Rebbe, that was a victory worth the price.

We don’t always score resounding victories. Sometimes the other person does not embrace your position, abandon their old loyalties, or become the person you hoped they would be. But every movement, every influence accomplishes something. The next time they confront hateful rhetoric, a counter-voice might arise in their minds, influencing how they respond.

Jacob understood that. He could have insisted on standing tall before Esau. Instead, he bowed seven times. He accepted the cost because he recognized that reconciliation might accomplish what confrontation could not. Sometimes, if our goal is to bring the other person closer, insisting on standing tall can become an obstacle to the very reconciliation we seek.

About the Author
Rabbi Lazer Gurkow, a renowned lecturer, serves as Rabbi to Congregation Beth Tefilah in London Ontario. He is a member of the curriculum development team at Rohr Jewish Learning Institute and is the author of two books and nearly a thousand online essays. You can find his work at www.innerstream.org
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.