What Happened to Israel’s Sovereignty?

We have internalized the idea that individual nations are sovereign – independent, and in control of their respective countries. They protect their own borders, using soldiers who are part of an army of that sovereign power.

All countries respect the rights of other countries to exert their sovereignty in such ways as a particular nation sees fit.

It all sounds well and good, but it all breaks down in the case of Israel. When Israel seeks to protect its borders or transition points to sensitive areas, it is frequently met with contempt – contempt for its soldiers guarding these locations, and, by extension, contempt for the nation itself.

How is this manifested? “Observers” routinely hover at checkpoints or guardhouses to “monitor” the behavior of the soldiers manning them. In practice, this monitoring often takes the form of subtle or not so subtle harassment, in which observers film soldiers at extremely close range, hoping to provoke a reaction from a soldier that can go viral as an act of oppression, or even a war crime.

Much of this contemptuous behavior is undertaken or sponsored by the European Union, individual European governments or NGOs connected with them.

What is the significance of this despicable behavior?  First and foremost, it shows a complete disregard and derogation of Israeli sovereignty. The clear implication is that Israel has no right to patrol and guard and control its sovereign territory as it sees fit.

Did these countries not get the memo informing the world some 70 years ago that Israel was now an independent nation, just like all the member states of the United Nations? Or is this part of the creeping and creepy morphing of the European Union into an imperialist entity that is uncaring as to national borders and nation states in general?

One senses that even with the EU’s transnational orientation, Israel is a special case. There is the clear sense that somehow Israel’s sovereignty is contingent and conditional; it exists at the sufferance of the European nations from whom most of Israel’s founders fled.

It is no secret that the EU and most Western European countries support the Palestinians. They are eager to see a Palestinian state come into existence, regardless of the security implications that would entail for Israel.

The policies of successive Israeli governments have therefore been maddening to varying degrees. From the European perspective, the Netanyahu government has been one of the worst, because there has been no movement, no meaningful concessions, to reaching the goal of Palestinian statehood.

So, Europeans have decided to use the back door. They employ anti-Zionist Israeli NGOs to espouse the policies that they, the Europeans, are seeking to implement. The idea here is that if actual Israelis push for these policies there will be a greater likelihood that their government will comply.

At the same time, the Europeans have chosen to react as if the problem didn’t exist, meaning as if there was no Israeli sovereignty to begin with.

This attitude is manifested in the harassment of soldiers at checkpoints and at sensitive locations such as Hebron. Harassing the soldiers of a foreign country is akin to not recognizing the legitimacy of that country, nor the soldiers who serve it.

Until recently, Israel has chosen to endure this state of affairs. Army protocols allow for civilians to approach soldiers and to film them in close proximity. The government typically does not interfere with the resulting harassment by arresting or deporting those who undertake it.

Fortunately, change is coming. Recently, thanks to unremitting pressure from Zionist groups, the Government has decided to end the 25 year tenure of TIPH, a European observatory group in Hebron, which has been consistently biased and prejudicial to Israel.

Soon thereafter, thanks to the work of Im Tirtzu, Israel’s largest grassroots Zionist organization, and its new initiative known as the Video Commandos, EAPPI, a European group affiliated with the anti-Zionist World Council of Churches, announced that it was removing its members from Hebron, claiming that they were being harassed.

What was the harassment? Simply stated, the Video Commandos fought fire with fire, as they filmed the filmers of our soldiers.

The reaction to this initiative has been wildly popular, as people can see first hand the blatant cynicism and hostility for Israeli soldiers being demonstrated by the filming harassers.

Im Tirtzu is seeking to build on this initial success by expanding the “Video Commandos,” to cover more checkpoints, more often. Armed with cameras and intelligence as to where harassers are likely to be, the Commandos will aim, click and shoot – photographically.

The Video Commandos seek to send a simple message to the harassers and to the foreign governments that dispatch them: Israel is a sovereign country, like it or not. And its policies will be determined by its own government, not by yourselves.

Im Tirtzu recently launched a crowdfunding campaign to expand and enhance the work of the Video Commandos. All those who understand the important work that the Commandos are doing on behalf of Israel’s soldiers, and Israel itself, are urged to contribute.

Help the Video Commandos help protect Israel’s defenders. Make a difference: aim, click and shoot!

Mr. Altabef is Chairman of the Board of Im Tirtzu

About the Author
After a successful money management career in NYC, Doug Altabef made aliyah to Rosh Pina with his wife Linda and their youngest of four kids in 2009. As a money manager, Doug was a frequent guest commentator on Bloomberg TV, CNNfn TV as well as Wall Street Radio, which was syndicated out to dozens of radio stations throughout the US. Today he spends his time serving as Chairman of the Board of Im Tirtzu and a Director of the Israel Independence Fund, where he has been privileged to get some amazing insights into how people are making a difference here. Doug also has invested in several early stage Israeli companies and is a big believer in the Start Up Nation attractiveness of Israeli technology.
Comments