When accusations become inversions
The most disturbing feature of modern antisemitism is the inversion of accusations against Israel and the Jewish people, who are repeatedly accused of conduct that has also been practiced by some of their historical accusers: colonialism, ethnic cleansing, apartheid, genocide, and even Nazism. These inflammatory accusations have become political weapons. They frequently involve the reversal of historical realities, moral responsibilities, and the distinction between aggressor and victim. These inverted accusations share a common psychological attribute: psychological projection.
The Psychological Mirror
There are two primary types of psychological projection.
First, we have idealistic Westerners who often project positive paradigms, or Western values, onto other non-Western groups. For example, left-wing intellectuals and activists often assume that others think and behave as they themselves would. This can be especially true in isolated ivory-tower academic circles. They profess to believe that all cultures are equally important. But in reality, they childishly project their own thinking onto the minds of other people. Paradoxically, just as these idealists project their utopian ideas onto foreign cultures and political movements, some of those movements regard the idealists as easy to manipulate. This incongruous situation can have disastrous consequences for both sides, but especially for societies that follow these ideologues.
Then there are morally flawed individuals who project their own immoral behavior onto others. This mirror effect is one reason they may invert the truth when falsely accusing others, rather than simply concocting a new lie. The accuser may assume that others possess the same sinister intentions and willingness to commit atrocities that he himself possesses. What he would do to his enemies, he imagines his enemies must be doing to him. In this way, an accusation can become a reflection of the accuser’s own dark character.
When accusations repeatedly reverse the documented historical record, the psychological projection mechanism deserves scrutiny. The inversion becomes particularly dangerous when it is repeated through political movements, universities, international institutions, and the media until an accusation is treated as an established fact.
Below are five examples of these types of inversions against Israel.
1. The Colonialism Inversion
Israel is frequently portrayed as a European colonial enterprise imposed upon an indigenous population. Yet the Jewish people’s historical, religious, linguistic, and archaeological connections to the Land of Israel extend back thousands of years. Jewish communities maintained a continuous presence in the land long before modern Zionism. [1]
Modern Israel also includes Jewish families originating in the Middle East and North Africa, many of whom fled or departed countries where their communities had existed for centuries.
The Jewish people’s national aspirations have historically centered on restoring their homeland rather than establishing an empire. There is no central doctrine within Judaism calling for the conquest of territories beyond Israel’s borders.
In contrast, successive Arab and Islamic empires conquered extensive territories beginning in the seventh century, expanding across the Middle East, North Africa, and into parts of Europe and Asia. These conquests transformed the political, religious, and cultural character of vast regions, introducing new rulers, institutions, and systems of government. [2]
Describing Jewish national restoration solely as a foreign colonial enterprise, while overlooking the Jewish people’s indigenous historical connection to the land and the extensive history of imperial conquest throughout the surrounding region, presents a striking historical contrast.
2. The Ethnic Cleansing Inversion
Israel is repeatedly accused of ethnically cleansing its Arab population. Yet, according to Israel’s Central Bureau of Statistics, the Arab population of Israel increased from approximately 156,000 in November 1948 to approximately 2.173 million in September 2026—an increase of nearly 1,300%. [3, 4]
In contrast, during the decades surrounding and following Israel’s establishment, ancient Jewish communities across Iraq, Egypt, Yemen, Libya, Syria, Morocco, Tunisia, Algeria, and other Arab countries experienced persecution, discriminatory legislation, confiscation of property, violence, and mass displacement. An estimated 850,000 Jews left or were displaced from Arab countries during this period. [5, 6]
Many of these communities had existed for centuries, some for more than 2,000 years. Today, most have virtually disappeared, and much of their historical heritage has been destroyed, abandoned, or appropriated.
The disappearance of these ancient Jewish communities from much of the Middle East and North Africa receives remarkably little attention in discussions of ethnic displacement.
The contrast between the enormous growth of Israel’s Arab population and the near disappearance of Jewish communities from numerous neighboring countries is striking.
3. The Apartheid Inversion
Israel is routinely accused of practicing apartheid, although its Arab and Muslim citizens enjoy political and civil rights under Israeli law. Israel retains a substantial Arab minority with citizenship, political representation, religious institutions, and participation in elections and national life. Arab and Muslim Israeli citizens vote in national elections, serve in the Knesset, practice their religions, attend universities, and hold positions throughout the professions, government, and judiciary. Public buildings and road signs commonly display Hebrew, Arabic, and English. [7, 8]
Palestinian Arabs living in Palestinian Authority-administered areas of the West Bank are not Israeli citizens by virtue of their residence there. Their different legal and political status is distinct from the status of Arab citizens living within Israel.
In contrast, for more than a millennium, various Muslim governments enforced systems of religious discrimination against Jews and Christians. Under classical Islamic jurisprudence, Jews and Christians were classified as dhimmis—protected but legally subordinate non-Muslim subjects.
Their inferior status was codified in classical Sharia, which prescribed a special jizya tax and unequal legal standing. Various Muslim authorities imposed restrictions on building and repairing synagogues, public worship, clothing, horseback riding, bearing arms, court testimony, government positions, and marriage. Jews were sometimes required to wear identifying garments, show deference to Muslims, and live in segregated quarters. [9, 10]
Although enforcement varied across countries and centuries, these discriminatory laws institutionalized Jewish subordination rather than religious and civil equality.
4. The Genocide Inversion
Perhaps the most inflammatory accusation against Israel is that of genocide. Under the 1948 Genocide Convention, the term describes specified acts committed with the intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group. It is not synonymous with civilian casualties, however tragic, or with every military action that causes substantial destruction. [11]
In response to the heinous October 7, 2023, attack, Israel possessed overwhelming military capabilities but also undertook extensive ground operations against Hamas, exposing its own soldiers to considerable danger. Israeli troops entered densely populated neighborhoods and Hamas’s extensive tunnel networks, where entrances and exits were frequently concealed within or beneath private homes and civilian institutions.
Israel also employed leaflets, telephone calls, evacuation notices, and other measures intended to warn civilians before military operations. According to figures released by the Israel Defense Forces, by March 31, 2024, approximately 100,000 evacuation phone calls had been placed, 9.3 million leaflets distributed, and 15.5 million evacuation text messages sent. [12] These actions are important considerations in examining the accusations directed against Israel.
In contrast, Hamas’s 1988 founding charter contained explicitly antisemitic language calling for Israel’s destruction and the killing of Jews. On October 7, 2023, Hamas-led attackers massacred approximately 1,200 people in Israel, committed acts of extraordinary barbarism, and took hundreds of hostages. [13, 14]
The contrast between Israel’s stated objective of destroying Hamas’s military capabilities and the explicitly antisemitic provisions of Hamas’s founding charter is central to understanding this accusation.
A particularly egregious example of moral inversion.
5. The Nazi Inversion
One of the most grotesque inversions is the comparison of Israel and the Jewish people to Nazi Germany. Nazism was built upon a racial ideology that defined Jews as an existential enemy and culminated in the systematic, industrialized murder of six million Jews. Yet Nazi imagery and terminology are frequently employed against Israel, sometimes by individuals and movements that openly celebrate the murder of Jews or promote antisemitic conspiracy theories. Equating the Jewish state with the regime that attempted to exterminate the Jewish people is an inversion of victim and perpetrator.
By portraying Jews and Israelis as Nazis, their accusers seek to exploit the universal revulsion associated with Hitler’s regime and transfer that moral condemnation onto the Jewish people. The message is calculated to make support for Israel appear morally indefensible: How can anyone defend people who are supposedly behaving like the perpetrators of the Holocaust? By falsely portraying Israel as morally equivalent to Nazi Germany, its accusers seek to justify the argument that Israel should not exist.
But this inversion serves an even more insidious purpose: the trivialization and moral reversal of the Holocaust itself. By equating Jews with Nazis, the accuser diminishes the unique historical significance of the systematic extermination of six million Jews and undermines the moral standing of its victims. In its most extreme form, the implication becomes that Jews were not innocent victims after all, but people capable of the very evil inflicted upon them—and therefore somehow deserving of their fate. This is not merely historical distortion; it is a form of retrospective victim-blaming that can serve to rationalize antisemitic hatred in the present. The Holocaust, rather than remaining an enduring warning against the consequences of antisemitism, is inverted into a weapon against the very people who suffered it.
In contrast, Haj Amin al-Husayni, the former Grand Mufti of Jerusalem and an influential figure in the Palestinian Arab national movement, was an active collaborator with Nazi Germany during World War II. He met Adolf Hitler in Berlin in November 1941, participated in Nazi propaganda broadcasts, advocated the murder of Jews, and assisted efforts to recruit Muslims into German military and auxiliary formations. His collaboration is extensively documented by the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. [15]
Conclusion
These inversions may afford their perpetrators a perverse pleasure or serve to whitewash their own conduct. Yet some accusers may also genuinely believe their accusations. This is what makes the mirroring effect so peculiar.
Unfortunately, these inversions are also unquestioningly accepted and repeated by antisemites whenever doing so furthers their own goals.
When the accuser attributes to others the intentions and conduct he himself is prepared to embrace, the accusation may reveal more about its author than its target.
Every Inversion May Be a Confession.
Sources and References
[1] Israel’s Declaration of Independence, May 14, 1948. Knesset. Historical Jewish connection to the Land of Israel and the restoration of Jewish sovereignty.
https://main.knesset.gov.il/EN/About/pages/declaration.aspx
[2] Ira M. Lapidus, A History of Islamic Societies, Cambridge University Press, third edition, 2014. Historical expansion of the Arab-Muslim empires.
https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781139027670.009
[3] Israel Central Bureau of Statistics, Statistical Abstract of Israel, Table 2.1, Population by Population Group. Records 156,000 Arabs on November 8, 1948.
https://www.cbs.gov.il/he/publications/doclib/2024/2.shnatonpopulation/st02_01.pdf
[4] The Times of Israel, September 9, 2026, reporting CBS population figures of 2,173,000 Arabs. The increase from 156,000 is approximately 1,293%.
https://www.timesofisrael.com/ahead-of-rosh-hashanah-israel-population-is-at-10305000-up-1-2-over-last-year/
[5] United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, Seven Decades in Egypt. Documents the displacement of Egyptian Jews and UNHCR recognition of Jewish refugees from Arab countries.
https://www.unhcr.org/eg/sites/eg/files/legacy-pdf/UNHCR-7-Decades-In-Egypt.pdf
[6] Israel Legal Advocacy Project, Jewish Refugees from Muslim Lands. Historical demographic information and estimates of Jewish migration and displacement.
https://www.lawandisrael.org/library/topical/refugees/jews/
[7] State of Israel, Basic Law: The Knesset, Sections 4–6. Voting rights and eligibility for election to the Knesset.
https://main.knesset.gov.il/EN/activity/Documents/BasicLawsPDF/BasicLawTheKnesset.pdf
[8] State of Israel, Basic Law: Human Dignity and Liberty, 1992. Legal protections for human dignity, liberty, and property.
https://m.knesset.gov.il/EN/activity/Documents/BasicLawsPDF/BasicLawLiberty.pdf
[9] Majid Khadduri and Herbert J. Liebesny, editors, Law in the Middle East, Volume I: Origin and Development of Islamic Law. Historical Islamic jurisprudence and the legal position of non-Muslim communities.
[10] Christian Müller, The Legal Status of Dhimmis in the Islamic West. Scholarly examination of the legal status of non-Muslims under historical Islamic governments. Library of Congress digital collection.
https://tile.loc.gov/storage-services/master/gdc/gdcebookspublic/20/20/42/66/35/2020426635/2020426635.pdf
[11] United Nations, Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, December 9, 1948, Article II. International Committee of the Red Cross treaty database.
https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/en/ihl-treaties/genocide-conv-1948/article-2
[12] Israel Defense Forces, April 6, 2024, Data Regarding Evacuation of Civilian Population Within Gaza. IDF-reported civilian warning measures.
https://www.idf.il/en/mini-sites/idf-press-releases-israel-at-war/april-24-press-releases/war-against-hamas-6-months-operational-update/data-regarding-evacuation-of-civilian-population-within-gaza/
[13] Council on Foreign Relations, What Is Hamas? History of Hamas, its founding charter, and the 2017 political document.
https://www.cfr.org/backgrounders/what-hamas
[14] United Nations Independent International Commission of Inquiry, Report A/HRC/56/26, May 2024. Investigation of the October 7 attacks and related violations.
https://www.un.org/unispal/document/coi-report-a-hrc-56-26-27may24/
[15] United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, Holocaust Encyclopedia, Hajj Amin al-Husayni: The Mufti of Jerusalem. Documents his collaboration with Nazi Germany, meeting with Hitler, propaganda activities, and recruitment efforts.
https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/hajj-amin-al-husayni-the-mufti-of-jerusalem

