Eitan Chikli

When Shame Disappears: The Danger Threatening Israel from Within

A democracy does not die on the day its leaders lie. It begins to die on the day its citizens stop being outraged by it.

On the occasion of Matan Kahana’s election as Knesset Speaker, Minister Amichai Chikli delivered a speech in which he gave a name to this affliction: “Bennettism,” a conception of politics in which an electoral commitment is worth only as much as it remains compatible with the conquest of power.

The term refers to Naftali Bennett’s about-face in 2021. Elected on a right-wing platform, he had promised his voters that he would not make Yair Lapid prime minister, even in a rotation; that he would not form a government dependent on Mansour Abbas and Ra’am; and that he would not become prime minister with ten seats. His party had won only seven. He nevertheless became prime minister, at the head of a coalition that included both Lapid and Ra’am. His most emblematic commitments did not survive the test of power.

Matan Kahana’s election extends this pattern. Mr. Kahana had promised repeatedly in recent months that he would not rely on the support of Arab parties. He was elected Speaker of the Knesset with their votes.

I am not writing to reopen an old case, nor to put any individual on trial. “Bennettism” is only the visible symptom of a deeper malaise.

Lying Is Old; the Shrug Is New

Democracies have always known broken promises, reversed alliances, and abandoned ideologies. What has changed is the reaction they provoke. Where transgression once drew shame, it now draws a shrug, or even admiration.

One can respect the letter of the law and still betray the trust of those who elected you. A coalition can be perfectly legal and yet rest on the repudiation of the very commitments that made it possible. The law does not close that gap. Only moral culture does: respect for one’s word, intellectual honesty, and consistency between what one proclaims and what one does.

When that culture erodes, words change their meaning. Repudiation becomes “pragmatism,” deception becomes “shrewdness,” and anyone who recalls yesterday’s promises is dismissed as naïve. Fidelity to one’s word becomes a weakness; the ability to cast it off, a talent. A society can survive dishonest leaders. Can it survive dishonesty that no longer shocks anyone?

When Commentators Move the Line

Commentators are not mere observers. In describing what is acceptable, they help define it. When influential voices argue that an electoral commitment can, or even must, be sacrificed to a higher goal, such as forming an alternative government, they shift the boundary of what the public considers tolerable.

But it would be too comfortable to blame only politicians and the press. The harder question concerns each of us: why do we accept from our own side what we condemn in others? When an opponent breaks his promises, we call it betrayal. When it is an ally, we cite the complexity of the circumstances. The criterion is no longer the nature of the act, but the identity of the person who commits it. From that moment, the citizen is no longer merely the victim of political deception. By excusing it when it serves his preferences, he helps to legitimize it. Leaders end up reflecting the moral norms their voters are willing to accept.

When voters accept that deception can become a strategy for conquering power, they themselves weaken the mechanism of accountability on which democracy rests.

For Israel, Cynicism Is an Impossible Luxury

This question carries particular weight here. Israel faces persistent threats and deep social and religious divisions. Its strength lies not only in its army and its economy but in a rare capacity for collective mobilization, which presupposes a minimum of mutual trust.

The soldier who risks his life and the reservist who leaves behind his family and his job must be able to believe that the shared enterprise follows rules that are reasonably fair, and that its leaders honor a minimum of moral standards. External danger alone cannot sustain solidarity. People must also believe that sacrifices are shared and that public speech still means something.

Montesquieu made political virtue, understood as the love of laws and of country, the principle of the republic. He understood that institutions, however solid, cannot function over time without certain moral dispositions among those who govern and those who obey. We measure Israel by its military, economic, and technological performance. There is another dimension, harder to quantify and just as decisive: the moral quality of our collective life. No army can replace the bond that unites the members of a nation.

A Standard We Already Apply to Ourselves

I do not claim that Israeli society has lost its virtues. Its courage and solidarity in times of hardship prove the opposite. It is precisely this contrast that is so striking: how can a people capable of such a spirit of sacrifice tolerate in politics behavior it would refuse in ordinary life? We would not accept from a business partner that he routinely renege on his commitments, from a friend that he treat his promises as optional, or from an officer that he deliberately deceive the men under his command. Why should we ask less of those who govern us?

The Test

The question is not only whether Naftali Bennett and Matan Kahana broke their promises, or whether others are preparing to follow their example. It is what our tolerance reveals about us. A society’s moral decline is measured by the failings of its leaders, but above all by its citizens’ ability to recognize those failings for what they are, including when they are committed by those they support.

History does not teach that a morally weakened society is doomed. It teaches that material power alone cannot guarantee the survival of a political community. We have learned to defend ourselves against the enemies who threaten our borders. We must also learn to identify what, from within, can erode the ethical foundations of our common life. For the day a society can no longer tell fidelity from betrayal, honesty from manipulation, compromise from imposture, it is not only its institutions that are in jeopardy, but its capacity to remain a community bound by a common fate.

About the Author
The author holds a Doctor of Hebrew Letters from the Jewish Theological Seminary of New York and an MPA from Harvard University's Kennedy School of Government. He is the former director of the TALI Education Fund and former rector of Universidad Hebraica in Mexico. He is also the father of Minister Amichai Chikli.
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.